All
 
|
 
 


The Churching of Russia: Parish Empowerment and Parish Protest
 
Title (other)Воцерковление России: расширение полномочий приходов и приходской протест
PIIS207987840029349-2-1
DOI10.18254/S207987840029349-2
Publication type Article
Status Published
Authors
Gregory Freeze 
Affiliation: Brandeis University
Address: USA, Waltham
Journal nameISTORIYA
Edition
Abstract

Western scholarship on secularization takes into account “churching” — expansion of the parish base to accommodate population growth and migration. This study examines churching in Imperial Russia, with a focus on two questions: how well (when) did the Orthodox Church expand its parish base, and how did that churching impact the aspirations and activity of parishioners? Perhaps even more than its peers in Europe, the Russian Orthodox Church faced a growing challenge in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries: on the one hand, enormous social change, but on the other hand, limited resources to adapt. This paper suggests that the Russian response was belated, but intense, with churching sharply accelerating after 1880. The local parish, almost alone, had to finance churching, yet continuing paying substantial diocesan levies that mainly served the interests of the clergy. The double burden was too much. Parishioners, encouraged to organize and mobilize since the 1860s, became increasingly assertive in claiming their right to govern the parish, to control its finances, and to choose its clergy. In short, churching led to revolution in the church.

Keywordschurching, secularization, laicization, Russian Orthodox Church, clergy, parish
Received13.10.2023
Publication date27.12.2023
Number of characters69828
Cite  
100 rub.
When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 0, views: 83

Readers community rating: votes 0 

1. Adamenko A. M. Obrazovanie i deyatel'nost' tserkovno-prikhodskikh popechitel'stv na territorii Tomskoj eparkhii // Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Istoriya. 2011. № 3 (15). S. 34—37.
2. Adamenko A. M. Prikhody russkoj pravoslavnoj tserkvi na yuge zapadnoj Sibiri v XVII v. — nachale XX v. Kemerovo, 2004.
3. Barabash M. N. Religioznoe soznanie pravoslavnogo naseleniya v Yaroslavskoj i Kostromskoj guberniyakh (vtoraya polovina XIX v. — nachalo XX v.). Kandadatskaya dissertatsiya. Yaroslavl': Yaroslavskij gosudarstvennyj universitet, 2006.
4. Barsukov I. Graf Nikolaj Nikolaevich Murav'ev-Amurskij. Kn. 2. M.: Sinodal'naya tipografiya, 1891.
5. Beglov A. L. Ot popytok obuzdat' «prikhodskuyu revolyutsiyu» — k mobilizatsii prikhozhan. Prikhodskij vopros v Rossijskoj pravoslavnoj tserkvi v 1917—1918 gg. // Vestnik Svyato-filaretovskogo instituta. Vyp. 25 (2018). S. 11—27.
6. Beglov A. L. Pravoslavnyj prikhod na zakate Rossijskoj imperii: sostoyanie, diskussii, reformy. M.: Indrik, 2021.
7. Blagorazumov V. N. K voprosu o vozrozhdenii pravoslavnogo prikhoda. M: Tipografiya M. Berksenko, 1906.
8. Bodeh A. B., Zhigal'tsova T. V., Khodakovskij E. V. Nimen'gskij prikhod onezhskogo uezda Arkhangel'skoj gubernii: stroitel'naya istoriya // Uchenye zapiski petrozavodskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. 2020. T. 42. № 6. S. 40—49.
9. Bokarev A. V. Derevyannoe tserkovnoe zodchestvo Arkhangel'skoj gubernii XIX v. — nachalo XX v. // Derevyannoe zodchestvo: novye materialy i otkrytiya. M.; SPb., 2015. Vyp. 4. S. 256—292.
10. Bokareva L. S. Proekty reformy pravoslavnogo prikhoda i material'nogo obespecheniya dukhovenstva v Rossii v 1913—1917 gg. Kandidatskaya dissertatsiya. SPb.: Rossijskij gosudarstvennyj pedagogicheskij universitet, 2015.
11. Vasil'ev A. V. Dokumentatsiya o stroitel'stve sel'skikh tserkvej kak istoricheskij istochnik (na primere Tomskoj gubernii) // Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. 2014. № 289. S. 139—144.
12. Vladimirov V. N. Prikhody Barnaul'skogo dukhovnogo pravleniya v 1829—1864 gg. (po materialam klirovykh vedomostej). Barnaul: Izdatel'stvo Altajskogo universiteta, 2006.
13. Volosnov R. Yu. Sel'skoe kul'tovoe zodchestvo Altaya kontsa XIX v. — nachala KhKh v. // Mir nauki, kul'tur, obrazovaniya. 2008. №5 (12). S. 118—122.
14. Vsepoddannejshij otchet ober-prokurora Svyatejshego Sinoda po vedomstvu pravoslavnogo ispovedaniya za … god. SPb.; Petrograd: Sinodal'naya tipografiya, 1866—1916.
15. Damaskin M. «Nashi tserkovno-prikhodskie popechitel'stva // Tserkovno-obschestvennyj vestnik. 1875. № 45 (25 aprelya). S. 1—3.
16. Dobren'kij S. I. Tserkovno-prikhodskie letopisi kak istoricheskij istochnik (seredina XIX v. — nachalo XX v.): dis. ... kand. ist. nauk. M.: RGGU, 2006.
17. Dokumenty Svyaschennogo Sobora Pravoslavnoj rossijskoj tserkvi 1917—1918 gg. T. 14: Protokoly zasedanij i materialy Otdela o blagoustroenii prikhoda / sost. Beglov A. L. M.: Izdatel'stvo Novospasskogo monastyrya, 2017.
18. Druzhinkina N. G. Pravoslavnye prikhody Sankt-Peterburgskoj eparkhii vo vtoroj polovine XIX v. — nachale XX v. Doktorskaya dissertatsiya. SPb.: Sankt-Peterburgskij gosudarstvennyj universitet, 2010.
19. Zhurnaly zasedanij kazanskogo eparkhial'nogo s'ezda // Izvestiya po kazanskoj eparkhii. 1905. № 43 (15 noyabr'). S. 1273—1282. № 44 (22 noyabr'). S. 1306—1307.
20. Zol'nikova N. D. Prosheniya v Konsistoriyu i Sinod kak istochnik dlya izucheniya sotsial'noj psikhologii krest'yanstva poreformennoj Sibiri // Istochniki po kul'ture i klassovoj bor'be feodal'nogo perioda. Novosibirsk: Nauka, 1982. S. 185—181.
21. Izvlechenie iz vsepoddannejshego otcheta ober-prokurora Svyatejshego Sinoda po vedomstvu pravoslavnogo vedomstvu za … g. 1837—1863. SPb., 1837—1865. Novaya seriya: Izvlecheniya iz vsepoddannejshego otcheta ober-prokurora Sv. Sinoda po vedomstvu pravoslavnogo ispovedaniya. SPb., 1866—1884.
22. Ikonnikov S. A. Tserkovno-prikhodskie popechitel'stva i ikh rol' v material'nom obespechenii prikhodskogo dukhovenstva tsentral'nogo Chernozem'ya vo vtoroj polovine XIX v. — nachale XX v. // Istoriya: fakty i simvoly. 2018. № 4 (17). S. 77—85.
23. Klyuchareva A. V. Zhiznedeyatel'nost' pravoslavnykh prikhodov v russkoj provintsii v 1881—1917 gg. (po materialam Tul'skoj eparkhii). Kandidatskaya dissertatsiya. Tula: Tul'skij gosudarstvennyj pedagogicheskij universitet, 2009.
24. Koroleva E. D. Tserkovno-prikhodskie popechitel'stva v ob'ektive mnenij sovremennikov i issledovatelej (po materialam Orenburgskoj gubernii vtoroj poloviny XIX v. — nachala XX v. // Vestnik Chelyabinskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. 2007. № 3. S. 33—40.
25. Krylov V. Administrativnye dokumenty i pis'ma Vysokopreosvyaschennogo Innokentiya, arkhiepiskopa Kamchatskogo, po upravleniyu Kamchatskoj eparkhiej i mestnymi dukhovno-uchebnymi zavedeniyami za 1846—1868 gg. Kazan': Tsentral'naya tipografiya, 1908.
26. Lebedev K. N. Tserkovno-prikhodskie popechitel'stva // Chernigovskie eparkhial'nye izvestiya. 1901, № 23 (1 dekabrya). S. 817—828; № 24 (15 dekabrya) S. 875—886.
27. Leont'eva T. G. Tserkovnaya intelligentsiya Tverskoj gubernii v kontse XIX v. — nachale XX v. (1895—1907 gg.) Kandidatskaya dissertatsiya. Tver': Tverskoj gosudarstvennyj universitet, 1992.
28. N. K. Vopros o tserkovno-prikhodskikh popechitel'stvakh // Beseda. 1872. № 12. S. 345—346.
29. Otzyvy eparkhial'nykh arkhiereev po voprosu o tserkovnoj reforme. 2 ch. M.: Izdatel'stvo Krutitskogo podvor'ya, 2004.
30. Papkov A. A. Besedy o pravoslavnom prikhode. SPb.: Sel'skij vestnik, 1912.
31. Papkov A. A. Nachalo vozrozhdeniya tserkovno-prikhodskoj zhizni v Rossii. M., 1900.
32. Papkov A. A. Neobkhodimost' obnovleniya pravoslavnogo tserkovno-prikhodskogo stroya (s proektom prikhodskogo upravleniya). SPb.: Tipografiya V. V. Komarova, 1903.
33. Papkov A. A. O blagoustrojstve pravoslavnogo prikhoda. SPb.: Sinodal'naya tipografiya, 1907.
34. Papkov A. A. Trevozhnoe sostoyanie nashej Tserkvi // Tserkovno-obschestvennyj vestnik. 1913. № 10. S. 5—7.
35. Papkov A. A. Upadok pravoslavnogo prikhoda XVIII—XIX vv. M.: Tipografiya Vladimira Chicherina, 1899.
36. Pis'ma mitropolita kievskogo Arseniya // Russkij arkhiv. 1892. № 2. S. 202—232.
37. Polnoe sobranie zakonov Rossijskoj Imperii. 1 seriya. 45 t. SPb., 1830. 2 seriya. 55 t. SPb., 1830—1884. 3 seriya: 28 t. SPb., 1911.
38. Preobrazhenskij I. V. Periodicheskaya pechat' po voprosu o prikhodskoj reforme. SPb.: Tipografiya Montvida, 1908.
39. Protokol postanovlenij i zhurnaly eparkhial'nogo sobraniya dukhovenstva i miryan mogilevskoj eparkhii 19—21 sentyabrya 1906 g. Mogilev, 1905.
40. Protokoly i zhurnaly s'ezda dukhovenstva vyatskoj eparkhii za 1905 g. Vyatka: Tipografiya Shklyaevoj, 1905.
41. Pul'kin M. V. Pravoslavnyj prikhod i vlast' v seredine XVIII v. — nachalo XX v. (po materialam Olonetskoj eparkhii). Petrozavodsk: Karel'skij nauchnyj tsentr RAN, 2009.
42. Rasporyazhenie Eparkhial'nogo Nachal'stva // Chernigovskie eparkhial'nye izvestiya. 1901. № 24 (15 dekabrya). S. 771—772.
43. Rozanov N. Istoriya moskovskogo eparkhial'nogo upravleniya. 3 ch. M.: V tipografii «Russkikh vedomostej», 1869—1871.
44. Ropakova E. N. Uezdnye prikhody Sankt-Peterburgskoj eparkhii vo vtoroj polovine XIX v. Kandidatskaya dissertatsiya. SPb.: Sankt-Peterburgskij gosudarstvennyj universitet, 2009.
45. Selo Lykovo, Vladimirskaya guberniya // Klyaz'ma. 1906. № 23 (25 yanvarya). S. 3.
46. Skutnev A. V. Prikhodskoe dukhovenstvo v usloviyakh krizisa russkoj pravoslavnoj tserkvi vo vtoroj polovine XIX v. — 1917 g. (na materialakh Vyatskoj eparkhii). Kandidatskaya dissertatsiya. Kirov: Vyatskij gosudarstvennyj gumanitarnyj universitet, 2005.
47. Smeta dokhodov i raskhodov Sv. Pravitel'stvuyuschego Sinoda za 1910 g. SPb., 1911.
48. Smolich I. Istoriya russkoj tserkvi, 1700—1917 gg. Ch. 1. M.: Izdatel'stvo Spaso-preobrazhenskogo valaamskogo monastyrya, 1996.
49. Strupoleva N. S. Pravoslavnye prikhody Stavropol'ya i Kubani v 40-e gg. XIX v. — nachale KhKh v.: sotsial'nye funktsii i dukhovnaya zhizn'. Kandidatskaya dissertatsiya. Stavropol': Stavropol'skij gosudarstvennyj universitet, 2007.
50. Uzlaner D. Konets religii? Istoriya teorii sekulyarizatsii. M.: Izdatel'skij Dom Vysshej shkoly ehkonomiki, 2019.
51. Friz G. L. Vladimirskaya eparkhiya: ot tserkovnoj k prikhodskoj revolyutsii // Konfessional'naya politika sovetskogo gosudarstva 1920—1950-e gg. M.: ROSSPEhN, 2019. S. 6—16.
52. Friz G. L. Votserkovlenie 1917 g.: tserkovnyj krizis i prikhodskaya revolyutsiya // Gosudarstvo, religiya, tserkov' v Rossii i za rubezhom. 2019. № 1/2. S. 30—57.
53. Friz G. L. Eparkhial'nye s'ezdy: povestka dnya dlya novykh issledovanij po provintsial'noj tserkovnoj istorii // Lichnoe est' istoricheskoe 2.0: Sbornik statej k 65-yu T. G. Leont'evoj / red. Belov A. V. Tver': Tverskoj gosudarstvennyj universitet, 2022. S. 33—38.
54. Friz G. L. Otkryvaya zanovo pravoslavnoe proshloe: mikro-istoricheskij podkhod v Rossii perioda imperii» // Nestor. 2007. № 11. S. 369—395.
55. Friz G. L. Revolyutsiya v Tserkvi: eparkhial'nye s'ezdy, 1905—1917 gg. // «Gubitel'noe blagochestie». Rossijskaya tserkov' i padenie imperii. SPb.: Izdatel'stvo Evropejskogo universiteta, 2019. S. 267—315.
56. Freeze G. “Entangled History” and the Religious Quotidian in the USSR // ISTORIYA. 2020. Vol. 11. Issue 7 (93). URL: https://history.jes.su/s207987840010690-8-1/  DOI: 10.18254/S207987840010690-8
57. Khodakovskij E. V. Derevyannaya tserkovnaya arkhitektura russkogo severa XIX v. — nachala XX v. Doktorskaya dissertatsiya. SPb.: Sankt-Peterburgskij gosudarstvennyj universitet, 2022.
58. Khodakovskij E. V., Melyukh E. A. Preobrazhenskaya tserkov' v Nimen'ge i derevyannoe tserkovnoe zodchestvo Belomor'ya XIX v. // Arkhitekturnoe nasledstvo. Vyp. 59. 2013. S. 157—167.
59. Yakimov I. S. Kak ya byl tserkovnym starostoj. Kazan', 1909.
60. Baty E. Victorian Church Building and Restoration in the Diocese of Norwich. Ph. D. diss. Norwich: University of East Anglia, 1987.
61. Berger P. Secularization and De-Secularization // Religions in the Modern World / ed. Fletcher P., Kawanami H., Smith D., Woodhead L. N. Y.: Routledge, 2002. P. 291—208.
62. Berger P. The Desecularization of the World. Washington: Ethics & Public Policy Center, 1999.
63. Borussa M. Genealogie der Säkularisierungstheorie: Zur Historisierung einer großen Erzählung der Moderne // Geschichte und Gesellschaft. 36 (2010). S. 347—376.
64. Brandwood G. Church Building and Restoration in Leicestershire, 1800—1914. PhD thesis. Leicester: University of Leicester, 1984.
65. Breitschneider K. G. Über die Unkirchlichkeit dieser Zeit im protestantischen Deutschland. Gotha, 1820.
66. Brown C. Did Urbanization Secularize Britain? // Urban History Yearbook. 15 (1988). S. 1—14.
67. Brown C. Religion and the Development of an Urban Society: Glasgow, 1780—1914. D. Phil. thesis. Glasgow: University of Glasgow, 1981.
68. Bruce S. Secularization: In Defense of an Unfashionable Theory. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2011.
69. Burkhardt M. Die Diskussion über die Unkirchlichkeit, ihre Ursachen und möglichen Abhilfen im ausgehenden 18. und frühen 19. Jahrhundert. Frankfurt am Main: Peter Lang, 1999.
70. Clark J. C. D. Secularization and Modernization: The Failure of a “Grand Narrative” // Historical Journal 55 (2012). P. 161—191.
71. Coleman B. E. Anglican Church Extension and Related Movements, 1800—1860, with Special Reference to London. D. Phil. thesis. Cambridge: University of Cambridge, 1969.
72. Einführung einer Gemeindeordnung in den evangelischen Kirchengemeinden der östlichen Provinzen // Allgemeines Kirchenblatt für das evangelische Deutschland. 1852. No. 33—39. P. 477—524.
73. Ell P. S., Slater T. R. The Religious Census of 1851: A Computer-Mapped Survey of the Church of England // Journal of Historical Geography. 20 (1994). P. 44—61.
74. Fierson C. All Russia Is Burning. A Cultural History of Fire and Arson in Late Imperial Russia. Seattle: University of Washington Press, 2012.
75. Finke R., Stark R. Churching of America, 1776—2005. New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press, 2005.
76. Fordahl C. The Post-Secular: Paradigm Shift or Provocation? // European Journal of Social Theory. 20 (2017). P. 550—568.
77. Freeze G. L. All Power to the Parish? The Problem and Politics of Church Reform in Late Imperial Russia // Social Identities in Revolutionary Russia / ed. Palat M. K. L.: Macmillan, 2001. P. 174—208.
78. Freeze G. L. Dechristianization in Holy Rus’? Reports from Vladimir Diocese on Popular Piety, 1900—1913 // Orthodox Christianity in Imperial Russia: A Source Book on Lived Religio / ed. Coleman H. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 2014. P. 208—28.
79. Freeze G. L. Priests and Revolution: The Parish Clergy of Vladimir in 1905 // Rethinking the Russian Revolution of 1905: The Russian Revolution of 1905 in Transcultural Perspective: Identities, Peripheries, and the Flow of Ideas / ed. von Weikersthal F., Grüner F., Hohler S., Schedewie F., Tuchtenhagen R., Utz R., Wezel K. Bloomington: Slavica, 2013. P. 19—38.
80. Freeze G. L. Russian Orthodoxy on the Periphery: Decoding the Raporty blagochinnykh in Lithuania Diocese // Problemy vsemirnoj istorii / red. Anan'ich B. V. SPb.: Dmitrij Bulanin, 2000. S. 124—131.
81. Freeze G. L. Russian Orthodoxy: Church, People and Politics in Imperial Russia // Cambridge History of Russia. Vol. 2: Imperial Russia, 1689—1917 / ed. Lieven D. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2008. P. 284—305.
82. Freeze G. L. The Parish Clergy in Nineteenth-Century Russia. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1983.
83. Freeze G. L. The Russian Levites: Parish Clergy in the Eighteenth Century. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1977.
84. Geary F. Characteristics of Religious Diversity in Mid-Nineteenth Century Warwickshire: A Study of the 1851 Religious Census. D. Phil. thesis. Oxford: Oxford University, 2016.
85. Gilley S. Introduction // Cambridge History of Christianity. Vol. 8: c. 1851 — c. 1914. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2006. P. 1—9.
86. Inglis K. S. Patterns of Religious Worship in 1851 // Journal of Ecclesiastical History. 11 (1960). S. 74—86.
87. Kantzenbach F. W. Zur Entfaltung der Problematik von “Kirchlichkeit” und “Unkirchlichkeit” in der ersten Hälfte des 19. Jahrhunderts // Hospitium ecclesiae. 11 (1978). P. 93—128.
88. Kselman T. The Varieties of Religious Experience in Urban France // European Religion in the Great Cities, 1830—1930 / ed. McLeod H. L.: Routledge, 1995. P. 165—190.
89. Lagnée M. The Impact of Technology on Catholicism in France // The Decline of Christendom in Western Europe, 1750—2000 / ed. McLeod H., Ustorf W. Cambridge University Press, 2003. P. 163—183.
90. Laird J. Religion and Life, 1793—1865: A Study in the Social and Religious History within the Bounds of the Presbytery of Cupar. Ph. D. diss. Saint Andrews: University of St. Andrews, 1977.
91. McCloud H. Religion // Atlas of Industrializing Britain 1750—1914. L.: Routledge, 1986. P. 211—217.
92. McLeod H. Introduction // European Religion in the Great Cities, 1830—1930. L.: Routledge, 1995. P. 1—39.
93. McLeod H. Religion in the City // Urban History Yearbook. 5 (1978). S. 7—22.
94. McLeod H. Secularization in Western Europe 1848—1914. N. Y.: St. Martin’s Press, 2000.
95. McLeod H., Ustof W. The Decline of Christendom in Western Europe, 1750—2000. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2003.
96. Morris J. Secularization and Religious Experience: Arguments in the Historiography of Modern British Religion // Historical Journal. 55 (2012). P. 195—219.
97. Otte H. More Churches — More Churchgoers // European Religion in the Great Cities, 1830—1930 / ed. McLeod H. L.: Routledge, 1995. S. 90—118.
98. Papkov A. A. Za tserkovnoj stenoj // Novoe vremya. 1914. № 13626 (17 fevralya).
99. Papkov A. A. Trevozhvnoe sostoyanie nashej tserkvi (strashnaya kniga) // Tserkovno—obschestvennyj vestnik. 1914. № 10 (6 marta). S. 5—7.
100. Parmaksiz U. Making Sense of the Postsecular // European Journal of Social Theory. 21 (2016). P. 98—116.
101. Phayer F. Religion und das gewöhnliche Volk in Bayern in der Zeit von 1750—1850. München: Stadtarchiv, 1970.
102. Pickering W. S. F. The 1851 Religious Census: A Useless Experiment? // British Journal of Sociology. 18 (1967). P. 382—407.
103. Pieper D. P. Kirchliche Statistik Deutschlands. Tübingen: J. C. B. Mohr, 1900.
104. Preußen: Mittheilungen über Aufnmahme und Wirksamkeit der evangelischen Gemeindekirchenräthe während des ersten Jahres ihres Bestehens in der Provinz Preußen // Allgemeines Kirchenblatt für das evangelische Deutschland. 1853. No. 37/38 (12.09). P. 633—633; No. 39/40 (26.9). P. 649—664.
105. Pro-Benedictrine Code of Canon Law. San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 2001.
106. Sanders A. Church Architecture and Religious Art // Cambridge History of Christianity. Vol. 8: c. 1851 — c. 1914. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2006. P. 103—120.
107. Schematismus der Geistlichkeit des Erzbistums München und Freysing für das Jahr 1823. München: Verlag der Ignaz Joseph Lentner’schen Buchhandlung, 1823.
108. Shevzov V. Popular Orthodoxy in Late Imperial Russia. Ph. D. Diss. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1994.
109. Snell K. D. M., Ell P. S. Rival Jerusalems: The Geography of Victorian Religion. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2000.
110. Stark R., Iannaccone L. A Supply-Side Reinterpretation of the “Secularization” of Europe // Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion. 33 (1994). P. 230—252.
111. The Secularization Debate / ed. Swatos W. H., Olson D. V. A. Lanham: Rowman & Littlefield, 2000.
112. Thompson D. M. The 1851 Religious Census: Problems and Possibilities // Victorian Studies. 11 (1967). P. 87—97.
113. Thompson D. M. The Religious Census of 1851 // The Census and Social Structure: An Interpretative Guide to Nineteenth Century Censuses for England and Wales / ed. Lawton R. L., 1978. P. 281—286.
114. Wakeling C. The Architecture of the Nonconformist Churches during the Victorian and Edwardian Years. Ph. D. diss. Anglia: University of East Anglia, 1983.
115. Ward W. R. The Cost of Establishment: some Reflections on Church Building in Manchester // Studies in Church History. 3 (1966). P. 273—287.
116. Young G. Into Church Matters: Lay Identity, Rural Parish Life, and Popular Politics in Late Imperial and Early Soviet Russia, 1864—1928 // Russian History. 23 (1996). P. 367—384.

Система Orphus

Loading...
Up