All
 
|
 
 


The myth of the instinct
 
PIIS023620070005904-1-1
DOI10.31857/S023620070005904-1
Publication type Article
Status Published
Authors
Dmitiy A. Leontyev 
Occupation: The head of the International Laboratory of Positive Psychology of Personality and Motivation
Affiliation: National Research University “Higher school of economics”
Address: 4 Slavyanskaya Sq., Bld. 2, Moscow 101000 Russian Federation
Yelena Yu. Fedorovich
Occupation: Senior research fellow of the Chair of General Psychology Department of Psychology
Affiliation: Lomonosov Moscow State University
Address: 11 Mokhovaya Str., Bld. 9, 125009 Moscow, Russian Federation
Journal nameChelovek
EditionVolume 30 Issue №4
Pages53-71
Abstract

The paper reviews the history of the concept of instinct used to refer to an innate motivational source of human and animal behavior in psychology and ethology. The reasons are disclosed for rejecting this concept as an explanatory one. The first psychological theories of motivation based on Darwinian type of scientific explanation nearly unconditionally recognized the biological nature of human motivational sources. In late 1930s – early 1940s however, the concept of instinct has yielded its place to the new concept of need in scientific explanations of human motivation. It lasted out longer in disciplines, related to animal behavior. Though the concept of instinct has been heavily criticized by some experts in the behavioral development in animals (Z.Y. Kuo), the founders of ethology, Konrad Lorenz and Niko Tinbergen, have breathed new life into it in the 1930s. The ethological theory of “instinctual” behavior stayed influential till mid-1950s, having inspired multiple research. A new wave of criticism of the concept of instinct by European and American scholars followed in 1950s-60s. Since 1960s it was replaced by the concept of species specific behavior which develops only through the process of active interaction of individuals with their environment.

Keywordsinstinct, behavior, species specific behavior, Сh. Darwin, K. Lorenz, motivation
Received17.07.2019
Publication date30.07.2019
Number of characters36029
Cite  
100 rub.
When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 11, views: 7807

Readers community rating: votes 0 

1. Bass D. Ehvolyutsiya seksual'nogo vlecheniya: strategii poiska partnerov [Evolution of sexual attraction: strategies for finding partners]. Moscow: Al'pina Pablisher, 2017.
2. Vagner V. Chto takoe instinkt [What is instinct]. St. Peterburg; Moscow: Izdanie t-va M.O. Vol'f", n.d.
3. Vagner V. Biologicheskie osnovaniya sravnitel'noi psikhologii. T. 2. Instinkt" i razum". [Biological bases of comparative psychology. Vol. 2. Instinct and reason]. St. Peterburg: Izdanie tovarishchestva M.O. Vol'f", 1913.
4. Vagner V.A. Sravnitel'naya psikhologiya: Izbrannye psikhol. trudy. [Comparative psychology: the elected psychological works]. Moscow: Moskovskii psikhologo-sotsial'nyi institute Publ.; Voronezh: NPO «MODEhK» Publ., 2010.
5. Darvin Ch. Proiskhozhdenie vidov [Origin of species]. Moscow: Gosudarstvennoe izdatel'stvo sel'skokhozyaistvennoi literatury, 1952.
6. Darvin Ch. Proiskhozhdenie cheloveka i polovoi otbor. Vyrazhenie ehmotsii u cheloveka i zhivotnykh [The origin of man and sexual selection. The expression of the emotions in man and animals]. Sobranie sochinenii: v 9 t. [The Collected Works: in 9 vol.]. Vol. 5. Moscow: AN SSSR Publ., 1953.
7. Dembovskii Ya. Psikhologiya zhivotnykh [Animal psychology] Moscow: Innostrannaya literatura Publ., 1959.
8. Lorents K. Oborotnaya storona zerkala [The reverse side of the mirror]. Moscow: Respublika Publ., 1998.
9. McDougall W. Osnovnyya problemy sotsial'noi psikhologii [The main problems of social psychology]. Moscow: Knigoizdatel'stvo «Kosmos», 1916.
10. Malinovskiy B. Nauchnaya teoriya kul'tury [Scientific theory of culture] Moscow: O.G.I. Publ., 1999.
11. Malinovskiy B. Seks i vytesnenie v obshchestve dikarey [Sex and repression in savage society] Moscow: Dom GU VShEh Publ., 2011.
12. Slonim A.D. Instinkt [Instinct]. Leningrad: Nauka Publ., 1967.
13. Fedorovich E.Yu. Razvitie povedeniya zhivotnykh v ontogeneze kak rezul'tat ikh vzaimodeistviya s okruzheniem [Development of animals behaviors in ontogenesis as consequences of their interaction with the environment]. Voprosy psikhologii. 2011. N 6. P. 56–65.
14. Fromm Eh. Anatomiya chelovecheskoy destruktivnosti [Anatomy of human destructiveness]. Moscow: Respublika Publ., 1994.
15. Khaind R. Ehnergeticheskie modeli motivatsii. Modelirovanie v biologii [Anatomy of human destructiveness. Modeling in biology]. Moscow: Innostrannaya literatura Publ. 1963. P. 273–298.
16. Khekkhauzen Kh. Motivatsiya i deyatel'nost'. Tom 1. [Motivation and activity. Vol. 1]. Moscow:  Pedagogika Publ., 1986.
17. Allport G.W. Personality: A psychological interpretation. NY.: Holt, 1937.
18. Beach F.A., Jaynes J. Effects of early experience upon the behavior of animals. Psychological Bulletin. 1954. Vol. 51, N 3. P. 239–263. DOI: 10.1037/h0061176
19. Denny M. R., Ratner S. C. Comparative psychology: Research in animal behavior. Oxford, England: Dorsey, 1970.
20. Goldstein K. The organism. N Y.: American book company, 1939.
21. Griffiths P. E. Instinct in the ‘50s: The British reception of Konrad Lorenz’s theory of instinctive behavior // Biology & Philosophy. 2004. Vol, 19. N 4. P. 609-631. DOI: 10.1007/sbiph-004-0537-z.
22. Haraway M., Maples E., Jr. Species-typical behavior. Comparative Psychology: a handbook , eds.  Greenberg G., Haraway M. M. NY.: Garland/Taylor & Francis. P., 1998. P. 191–197.
23. Kuo Z.Y. Giving up instincts in psychology. Journal of Philosophy.  1921. N 18. P. 645–664.
24. Kuo Z.Y. 1929 The net result of the anti-heredity movement in psychiatry. Psychological Review. 1929. N 36. P.181–199.
25. Lehrman D.S.  A Critique of Konrad Lorenz’s Theory of Instinctive Behavior. The Quarterly Review of Biology. 1953. Vol. 28, N 4. P. 337–363. DOI: 10.1086/399858
26. Lehrman D. S. On the organization of maternal behavior and the problem of instinct.  L’instinct dans le comportement des Animaux at de L’Homme, ed. Grasse P. P. Paris: Masson & Cie. 1956. P. 475–520.
27. Lehrman D.S. Semantic and Conceptual Issues in the Nature-Nurture Problem.  Development and Evolution of Behavior, eds. Aronson L., Tobach E., Lehrman D., Rosenblat J. San-Francisco: Freeman. 1970. P. 125–146.
28. Lorenz K. The Companion in the Bird's World.  The Auk. 1937. Vol. 54, N 1. P. 245–273.
29. Lorenz K.  The Comparative Method in Studying Innate Behaviour Patterns. Symposia of the Society for Experimental Biology. N. 4. 1950. P. 221–268.
30. Lorenz K. Das sogennante Böse. Vienna: Borotha-Shoeeler, 1963.
31. Maslow A.H. Motivation and Personality. 2-nd ed. NY: Harper and Row, 1970.
32. Murray H.A. and others. Explorations in Personality. NY.: Oxford University Press, 1938.
33. McDougall W. An Outline of Psychology. 4th ed., revised. London: Methuen & Co, 1928. XXII+456 p.
34. Schneirla T. C., Rosenblatt J. S. “Critical Periods” in the Development of Behavior. Science. 1963. Vol. 139, N 3559.  P. 1110-1115. DOI: 10.1126/scince.139.3559.1110
35. Schneirla T. C., Rosenblatt J. S., Tobach E. Maternal behavior in the cat. Maternal Behavior in Mammals, ed. Rheingold H. NY: Wiley. 1963. P. 122–168.
36. Stone C.R. Comparative psychology. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press. 1951.
37. Thorpe W.H. The definition of some terms used in animal behaviour studies. Bulletin of Animal Behavior. 1950. N 8. P. 34–40.
38. Tinbergen N. The Study of Instinct. Oxford: Clarendon. 1951.
39. Watson J.B. Behavior: An introduction to comparative psychology. NY: Holt, 1914.
40. Watson J. B. The behaviorist looks at instincts. Harper's. 1927. № 155. R. 228–235.

Система Orphus

Loading...
Up