On Amateurism in the 18th-Century Russian Science: The Case of Grigory Demidov and His Garden in Solikamsk

Publication type Article
Status Published
Affiliation: S. I. Vavilov Institute for the History of Science and Technology, Russian Academy of Sciences
Address: Moscow, Ul. Baltiyskaya, 14
Journal nameVoprosy istorii estestvoznaniia i tekhniki
EditionVolume 43 Issue 3

This article describes the case of Grigory Demidov from the dynasty of the wealthiest industrialists in 18th-century Russia, with an emphasis on his scientific amateurism and contribution to botany. Summarizing the literature on Demidov as a “botanophile”, the article offers a rethinking of the process of formation of his botanical interests. In line with the nobility’s tradition, Grigory set out to create a “paradise” with exotic plants on his estate in the Ural city of Solikamsk. There is a widespread historiographic belief that Demidov’s fascination with botany emerged due to Georg Steller, the naturalist with the Second Kamchatka Expedition, who had allegedly stayed in Solikamsk in 1739 en route to Siberia. However, our comparison of the archival sources and materials concerning Steller’s journey casts doubt on this hypothesis. On the contrary, in his letter to the botanist T. Gerber, written during the same period, Demidov recounted his experience of collecting endemic plants, including medicinal herbs, his desire to learn more about their taxonomy and nomenclature. Grigory’s amateur interest in the “science of plants” and his pharmaceutical skills were noted by Academicians G. F. Müller and I. G. Gmelin, who visited Solikamsk in 1742. Therefore, it is no coincidence that Steller, on the way back to St. Petersburg, in the spring of 1746 stayed with Demidov to salvage the plants collected during the Expedition. After Steller’s sudden death, Grigory became the owner of a vast collection of rare Kamchatka and Siberian plants. This collection enabled Demidov to begin exchanging seeds with professional botanists, primarily with Carl Linnaeus, in 1748. His correspondence with Linnaeus demonstrates an impressive progress in Grigory’s botanical experience and knowledge. The article argues that Grigory Demidov’s fascination with botany arose when he collected and cultivated ornamental and medicinal plants on his own. Professional botanists had only guided this process but had not initiated it. Nevertheless, Grigory Demidov’s amateur skills and scientific aspirations allow to place his name among the major actors in botany. Even Linnaeus himself had mentioned Demidov’s contribution to botany in his world-famous treatise, Species plantarum.                

KeywordsGrigory Akinfievich Demidov, Solikamsk Garden, the Demidovs, plant collecting, botany, botanical gardens, herbaria, amateurs, professionals, Georg Wilhelm Steller, Second (Great) Kamchatka Expedition, Russian Empire
Publication date23.09.2022
Number of characters72729
100 rub.
When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 0, views: 494

Readers community rating: votes 0

1. Andreev, A. I. (1965) Georg Vilʼgelʼm Steller [Georg Wilhelm Steller], in: Iatsunskii, V. K. (ed.) Ocherki po istochnikovedeniiu Sibiri [Essays on the Source Study of Siberia]. Moskva and Leningrad: Nauka, vol. 2: XVIII v. (pervaia polovina) [18th Century (First Half)], pp. 229–286.

2. Andreev, A. I. (1965) Gerkhard Fridrikh Miller [Gerhard Friedrich Müller], in: Iatsunskii, V. K. (ed.) Ocherki po istochnikovedeniiu Sibiri [Essays on the Source Study of Siberia]. Moskva and Leningrad: Nauka, vol. 2: XVIII v. (pervaia polovina) [18th Century (First Half)], pp. 73–164.

3. Balandin, S. A., Gubanov, I. A., Dzharvis, Ch. E., Maiorov, S. R., Simonov, S. S., and Sokolov, D. D. (2003) Rasteniia iz kollektsii Karla Linneia v Gerbarii Moskovskogo universiteta: istoriia i nauchnoe znachenie [Plants from Carl Linnaeus’ Collection in the Moscow University Herbarium: History and Scientific Significance]. Moskva: GEOS.

4. Banʼkovskii, L. V. (1997) Permistika. Zametki ob istokakh permskoi regionalʼnoi kulʼtury [Perm Studies. Notes on the Origins of the Permian Regional Culture]. Permʼ: Knizhnoe izdatelʼstvo.

5. Banʼkovskii, L. V. (2007) Botanicheskii sad Grigoriia Demidova [Botanical Garden of Grigorii Demidov], Nauka i zhiznʼ, no. 2, pp. 24–31.

6. Banʼkovskii, L. V. (2010) Sad XVIII veka. 3-e izd. [The 18th-Century Garden. 3rd ed.]. Solikamsk: SGPI.

7. Carl Linnaeus to Gustav Lidbeck, 10 September 1748, in: The Linnaean Correspondence. Letter L0931 (http://linnaeus.c18.net/).

8. Cherkasova, A. S. (2008) “Vashi nauchnye poznaniia… izvestny mne…” (Pisʼma Grigoriia Akinfievicha i Pavla Grigorʼevicha Demidovykh Karlu Linneiu) [“Your Scientific Knowledge... Is Known to Me...” (Letters from Grigorii Akinfievich and Pavel Grigorievich Demidov to Carl Linnaeus)], in: Cherkasova, A. S., Pavlovskii, N. G., and Krupina, T. V. (eds.) Demidovskii vremennik: istoricheskii alʼmanakh. 2-e izd. [Demidov Annals: A Historical Almanac. 2nd ed.]. Ekaterinburg: Demidovskii institut, book 2, pp. 9–84.

9. Cherkasova, A. S. (2010) Prokofii Akinfievich Demidov: avtoportret v pisʼmakh. 1735–1786 [Prokofii Akinfievich Demidov: A Self-Portrait in Letters. 1735–1786]. Ekaterinburg: Russkii mir”.

10. Chernov, N. N. (2010) Botanicheskie uvlecheniia uralʼskikh zavodchikov Demidovykh [Botanical Hobbies of the Ural Industrialists Demidovs], Geograficheskii vestnik, no. 3 (14), pp. 77–79.

11. Chernyi, V. D. (2010) Russkie srednevekovye sady: opyty klassifikatsii [Russian Medieval Gardens: An Attempt at Classification]. Moskva: Rukopisnye pamiatniki Drevnei Rusi.

12. D’Auteroche, Ch. (1768) Voyage en Sibérie, fait par ordre du roi en 1761... Paris: Chez Debure, vol. 1.

13. De Candole, A. P. (1822) Jardin de botanique, in: Cuvier, F. (ed.). Dictionnaire des sciences naturelles. Strasbourg: F. G. Levrault and Paris: Le Normant, vol. 24, p. 172.

14. Delilʼ, Zh. (Delille, J.) (1987) Sady [Gardens]. Leningrad: Nauka.

15. [Demidov N. A.] (1786) Zhurnal puteshestviia ego vysokorodiia gospodina statskogo sovetnika… Nikity Akinfievicha Demidova po inostrannym gosudarstvam s nachala vyezda Ego iz SanktPeterburga 17 marta 1771 goda po vozvrashchenie v Rossiiu, noiabria 22 dnia 1773 goda. [The Journal of the Tour of His High Born Mr. Councillor of State... Nikita Akinfievich Demidov of Foreign Countries from His Departure from St. Petersburg on March 17, 1771, until His Return to Russia on November 22, 1773]. Moskva: Tiporgafiia F. Gippiusa.

16. Elina, O. (2007) Private Botanical Gardens in Russia: Between Noble Culture and Scientific Professionalization, Studies in the History of Gardens & Designed Landscapes, vol. 28, no. 3–4, pp. 525–547.

17. Elina, O. (2018) Passion for Plants: Collections and Power Games in Botany in the 18th – Beginning of the 19th Century Russian Empire, Centaurus, vol. 60, no. 4, pp. 257–275.

18. Elina, O. Iu. (2008) Ot tsarskikh sadov do sovetskikh polei. Istoriia selʼskokhoziaistvennykh opytnykh uchrezhdenii, XVIII – 20-e gody XX veka. V 2 t. [From the Tsar’s Gardens to the Soviet Fields. History of Agricultural Experiment Institutions, 18th Century – the 1920s. In 2 vols.]. Moskva: Egmont-Rossiia.

19. Elina, O. Iu. (2015) Liubiteli i professionaly: botanika i arkhitektura v sadakh A. K. Razumovskogo v Tsentralʼnoi Rossii i Malorossii [Amateurs and Professionals: Botany and Architecture in the Gardens of A.K. Razumovsky in Central Russia and Malorussia], in: Baturin, Iu. M., and Fando, R. A. (eds.) Institut istorii estestvoznaniia i tekhniki im. S. I. Vavilova. Godichnaia nauchnaia konferentsiia, 2015 [S. I. Vavilov Institute for the History of Science and Technology. Annual Conference, 2015]. Moskva: LENAND, vol. 1, pp. 453–457.

20. Evangulova, O. S. (2003) Khudozhestvennaia “Vselennaia” russkoi usad’by [Artistic “Universe” of Russian Estate]. Moskva: Progress-Traditsiia.

21. Georg Vilʼgelʼm Steller [Georg Wilhelm Steller] (1870), in: Pekarskii, P. P. Istoriia Imperatorskoi akademii nauk v Peterburge [The History of the Imperial Academy of Sciences in St. Petersburg]. Sankt-Peterburg: Tipografiia Imperatorskoi AN, vol. 1, pp. 587–616.

22. Gmelin, I. G. (Gmelin, J. G.) (2012) Puteshestvie v Sibirʼ. Fragment [A Journey to Siberia. A Fragment]. Solikamsk, 2012.

23. Gmelin, Iogann-Georg [Gmelin, Johann-Georg], in: Pekarskii, P. P. Istoriia Imperatorskoi akademii nauk v Peterburge [The History of the Imperial Academy of Sciences in St. Petersburg]. Sankt-Peterburg: Tipografiia Imperatorskoi AN, vol. 1, pp. 431–457.

24. Gmelin, J. G. (1751) Reise durch Sibirien, von dem Jahre 1733 bis 1743. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck, part 1.

25. Gmelin, J. G. (1752) Reise durch Sibirien, von dem Jahre 1733 bis 1743. Göttingen: Vandenhoeck, part 4.

26. Golovshchikov, K. D. (1881) Rod dvorian Demidovykh [The Family of the Nobles Demidovs]. Iaroslavlʼ: Tipografiia Gubernskogo pravleniia.

27. Grigorii Akinfievich Demidov to Carl Linnaeus, 2 December 1748, The Linnaean Correspondence, Letter L0997 (http://linnaeus.c18.net/ or http://linnean-online.org/77777675/).

28. Grigorij Akinfievich Demidov to Carl Linnaeus, 13 September 1751, The Linnaean Correspondence, Letter L1318 (http://linnaeus.c18.net/ or http://linnean-online.org/777776711/).

29. Grigorij Akinfievich Demidov to Carl Linnaeus, 15 May 1750, The Linnaean Correspondence, Letter L1135 (http://linnaeus.c18.net/ or http://linnean-online.org/77777676/).

30. Grigorij Akinfievich Demidov to Carl Linnaeus, 16 March 1751, The Linnaean Correspondence, Letter L1257 (http://linnaeus.c18.net/ or http://linnean-online.org/777776710/).

31. Grigorij Akinfievich Demidov to Carl Linnaeus, 24 January 1752, The Linnaean Correspondence, Letter L1359 (http://linnaeus.c18.net/ or http://linnean-online.org/777776712/).

32. Grigorij Akinfievich Demidov to Carl Linnaeus, 26 February 1748, The Linnaean Correspondence, Letter L0877 (http://linnaeus.c18.net/ or http://linnean-online.org/77777671/).

33. Grigorij Akinfievich Demidov to Carl Linnaeus, 26 June 1748, The Linnaean Correspondence, Letter L0915 (http://linnaeus.c18.net/ or http://linnean-online.org/77777672/).

34. Grigorij Akinfievich Demidov to Carl Linnaeus, 28 October 1748, The Linnaean Correspondence, Letter L0969 (http://linnaeus.c18.net/).

35. Grigorij Akinfievich Demidov to Carl Linnaeus, 7 September 1749, The Linnaean Correspondence, Letter L0946 (http://linnaeus.c18.net/ or http://linnean-online.org/77777675/).

36. Grigorij Akinfievich Demidov to Carl Linnaeus, September 1748, The Linnaean Correspondence, Letter L1050 (http://linnaeus.c18.net/ or https://linnean-online.org/77777673/).

37. Iurkin, I. N. (1998) Demidovy v Tule. Iz istorii stanovleniia i razvitiia promyshlennoi dinastii [The Demidovs in Tula. From the History of the Formation and Development of an Industrial Dynasty]. Мoskva and Tula: Rarus.

38. Iurkin, I. N. (2001) Demidovy – uchenye, inzhenery, organizatory nauki i proizvodstva. Opyt naukovedcheskoi prosopografii [The Demidovs as Scientists, Engineers, Organizers of Science and Industry. An Exercise in Scientific Prosopography]. Moskva: Nauka.

39. Iurkin, I. N. (2003) K istorii russkikh usadebnykh sadov XVII veka [On the History of Russian Manor Gardens of the 17th Century], Izvestiia Tul’skogo universiteta, Istoriia i kul’turologiia, vol. 1, no. 1, pp. 12–31.

40. Iurkin, I. N. (2012) Demidovy. Stoletie pobed [The Demidovs. A Century of Victories]. Moskva: Molodaia gvardiia.

41. Karavaev, M. N. (1972) Rolʼ Moskovskogo meditsinskogo ogoroda v razvitii botaniki v nachale XVIII v. [The Role of Moscow Medicinal Garden in the Development of Botany in the Early 18th Century], Biulletenʼ MOIP, otdel biologicheskii, vol. 77, pp. 142–148.

42. Karavaev, M., and Efimov, A. I. (1983) Prokofii Demidov – naturalist XVIII veka [Prokofii Demidov, an 18th Century Naturalist], Priroda, no. 2, pp. 96–101.

43. Khinttsshe, V., Nikolʼ T., and Novokhatko, O. V. (eds.) (1998) Georg Vilʼgelʼm Shteller. Pisʼma i dokumenty. 1740 [Georg Wilhelm Steller. Letters and Documents. 1740]. Moskva: Pamiatniki istoricheskoi mysli (Istochniki po istorii Sibiri i Aliaski iz rossiiskikh arkhivov. T. 1 [Sources for the History of Siberia and Alaska from Russian Archives, vol. 1]).

44. Kolchinskii, E. I. (ed.) (2009) Stelleriana v Rossii [Stelleriana in Russia]. Sankt-Peterburg: Nestor-Istoriia.

45. Koroloff, R. (2014) Seeds of Exchange: Collecting for Russia’s Apothecary and Botanical Gardens in the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries, PhD Dissertation. University of Illinois. Urbana-Champaign.

46. Krasnova, E. I. (1992) Istoriia domovladeniia i zastroiki uchastka byvshei usad’by Demidovykh na Moike [The History of Property and Development of the Site of the Former Demidovs Estate on the Moika], in: Slavina, T. A., and Sementsov, S. V. (comp.) Peterburgskie chteniia. Tezisy dokladov koferentsii [St. Petersburg Readings. Abstracts]. Sankt-Peterburg: SanktPeterburgskaia assotsiatsiia issledovatelei goroda, pp. 126–130.

47. Lepekhin, I. I. (1814) Prodolzhenie dnevnykh zapisok puteshestviia Ivana Lepekhina, akademika i meditsiny doktora… po raznym provintsiiam Rossiiskogo gosudarstva v 1771 godu [The Continuation of the Daily Notes of the Journey of Ivan Lepekhin, Academician and Doctor of Medicine... across Different Provinces of the Russian State in 1771]. Sankt-Peterburg: Imperatorskaia akademiia nauk.

48. Linnaeus, C. (1753) Species Plantarum, exhibentes plantas rite cognitas, ad genera relates… Holmiae: Impensis Laurentii Salvii, vol. 1.

49. Miuller, Gerard-Fridrikh [Müller, Gerhard Friedrich], in: Pekarskii, P. P. Istoriia Imperatorskoi akademii nauk v Peterburge [The History of the Imperial Academy of Sciences in St. Petersburg]. Sankt-Peterburg: Tipografiia Imperatorskoi AN, vol. 1, pp. 308–430.

50. Nevskaia, N. I., Kopelevich, Iu. Kh., and Kuznetsova, A. B. (eds.) (2000) Letopisʼ Rossiiskoi akademii nauk [Chronicles of the Russian Academy of Science]. Sankt-Peterburg: Nauka, vol. 1: 1724–1802 gg. [1724–1802].

51. Novokhatko, O. V. (2000) Korrespondentsiia Georga Vil’gelʼma Shtellera (1739–1746). Russkogermanskii izdatelʼskii proekt [Correspondence of Georg Wilhelm Steller (1739–1746). Russian-German Publishing Project], in: Karp, S. Ia. (ed.) Russkie i nemtsy v XVIII veke. Vstrecha kulʼtur [Russians and Germans in the 18th Century. The Meeting of Cultures]. Moskva: Nauka, pp. 125–132.

52. Okhotina-Lind, N. A., and Meller, P. U. (comp.) (2001–2009) Vtoraia Kamchatskaia ekspeditsiia. Dokumenty [The Second Kamchatka Expedition. Documents]. Sankt-Peterburg: Nestor-Istoriia, vols. 1–4.

53. [Pallas P. S.] (1781) Katalog rasteniiam, nakhodiashchimsia v Moskve v sadu… Prokofiia Akinfievicha Demidova, sochinennyi P. S. Pallasom, akademikom sankt-peterburgskim [The Catalog of Plants Present in the Garden… of Prokofii Akinfievich Demidov, Compiled by P. S. Pallas, St. Petersburg Academician]. Sankt-Peterburg: Pri Imperatorskoi akademii nauk.

54. Pirogova, E. P. (2000) Biblioteki Demidovykh: knigi i sud’by [The Demidovs’ Libraries: Books and Fates]. Ekaterinburg: Sokrat.

55. Rentsch, M. (2013) Traugott Gerber (1710–1743), ein deutscher Arzt und Forschungsreisender im Dienst der Botanik und Medizin im Russland des 18. Jahrhunderts. Dresden: Eigendruck der SLUB Dresden.

56. Rowell, M. (1980) Linnaeus and Botanists in Eighteenth-Century Russia, Taxon, vol. 29, no. 1, pp. 15–26.

57. Rychkov, N. P. (1772) Prodolzhenie zhurnala ili dnevnykh zapisok puteshestviia kapitana Rychkova po raznym provintsiiam Rossiiskogo gosudarstva, 1770 godu [The Continuation of the Journal or Daily Notes of Captain Rychkov’s Journey across Different Provinces of the Russian State in 1770]. Sankt-Peterburg: Imperatorskaia akademiia nauk.

58. Shtiben, V. K. (2011) Grigorii Demidov: pervyi biograficheskii opyt [Grigorii Demidov: The First Attempt at a Biography]. Solikamsk: Pchela.

59. Smirnov, E. V. (ed.) (2015) Istoriia Solikamskogo sada. Solikamsk, 2015 [The History of the Solikamsk Garden] (https://uraloved.ru/istoriya/istoriya-solikamskogo-sada).

60. Sprengel, K. (1818) Geschichte der Botanik. In 2 Teilen. Altenburg and Leipzig: F. A. Brockhaus.

61. Stejneger, L. H. (1936) Georg Wilhelm Steller. The Pioneer of Alaskan Natural History. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

62. Svalov, V. M. (1983) Takoi netipichnyi Demidov: o botanicheskom sade G. A. Demidova [Such an Uncharacteristic Demidov: On G. A. Demidov’s Botanical Garden], Uralʼskii sledopyt, no. 4, pp. 74–76.

63. Trautvetter, E. R. (1837) Grundriss einer Geschichte der Botanik in Bezug auf Russland. St. Petersburg: Aus der Druckerei der Kaiserliche Akademie der Wissenschaften.

64. Vergunov, A. P., and Gorokhov, V. A. (1988) Russkie sady i parky [Russian Gardens and Parks]. Moskva: Nauka.

Система Orphus