Once Again on the Time-Reckoning After Menophris (A History of a Scholarly Problem and a Search of Its Solution)

The article deals with an important problem of the international and Russian Egyptology, i.e. with the interpretation of a statement by the Alexandrian scientist of the 4th–5th centuries A.D. Theon on an era “after Menophris” (ἀπὸ Μενόφρεως), allegedly started at the beginning of the “Sothic period” in 1322/1321 B.C. The first part of the article analyses the polemic on the identification of the name *Μενόφρις with a specific Ancient Egyptian royal name, with special attention paid to the interpretations by the Russian Soviet Egyptologists V.V. Struve and O.D. Berlev. The former one proposed in the 1920s was largely based on earlier European scholarship and contained a number of errors, which remained unnoticed due to a decline of the scholarly criticism at the time. On the contrary, Berlev’s view (1999) was totally original and in fact trail-blazing for the ultimate solution of the problem. The second part of the article proposes a development of Berlev’s hypothesis. The epithet “Memphite” (*Mn-nfry) that backed the name *Μενόφρις and was originally applied to Zoser, the inaugurator of the “Sothic calendar”, could be transferred on an image of a great king that reigned in Egypt after the catastrophe of the Amarna time. This king could be considered the founder of the “Memphite time” in Egyptian history, the creator of the “Sothic calendar” and respectively the contemporary of the start of a “Sothic period” (Theon’s “Menophris’ era”).

Keywords

Egypt, time-reckoning, Theon, Menophris, Dynasty XIX, Memphis, history-writing, Manetho, Egyptology, V.V. Struve, O.D. Berlev

Received

19.09.2019

Publication date

24.09.2019

Number of characters

59815

Cite

GOST	Ladynin I. Once Again on the Time-Reckoning “After Menophris” (A History of a Scholarly Problem and a Search of Its Solution) // Vestnik drevnei istorii – 2019. – V. 79. – Issue 2 C. 245-265 [Electronic resource]. URL: http://ras.jes.su/vdi/s032103910005032-8-1-en (circulation date: 08.10.2024). DOI: 10.31857/S032103910005032-8
MLA	Ladynin, Ivan "Once Again on the Time-Reckoning “After Menophris” (A History of a Scholarly Problem and a Search of Its Solution)." Vestnik drevnei istorii 79.2 (2019):245-265. DOI: 10.31857/S032103910005032-8
APA	Ladynin I. (2019). Once Again on the Time-Reckoning “After Menophris” (A History of a Scholarly Problem and a Search of Its Solution). Vestnik drevnei istorii 79(2), pp.245-265 DOI: 10.31857/S032103910005032-8

100 rub.

When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 3, views: 1770

Readers community rating: votes 0

1. Aleksandrova, N.V., Ladynin, I.A., Nemirovskij, A.A., Yakovlev, V.M. Drevnij Vostok. M., 2008.

2. Bagnall, R.S., Worp, K.A. 1978: The Chronological Systems of Byzantine Egypt. (Studia Amstelodamensia ad epigraphicam, ius antiquum et papyrologicam pertinentia, 8). Zutphen.

3. Bagnall, R.S., Worp, K.A. 2004: The Chronological Systems of Byzantine Egypt. 2nd ed. Leiden–Boston.

4. Bard, K.A. (ed.) 1999: Encyclopedia of the Archaeology of Ancient Egypt. London–New York.

5. Barguet, P. 1953: La stèle de la famine, à Séhel. (Bibliothèque d’étude, 24). Le Caire.

6. Beckerath, J. von 1997: Chronologie des pharaonischen Ägypten. Die Zeitbestimmung der ägyptischen Geschichte von der Vorzeit bis 332 v. Chr. (Münchner ägyptologische Studien; 46). Mainz am Rhein.

7. Beckerath, J. von 1999: Handbuch der ägyptischen Königsnamen. (Münchner ägyptologische Studien, 49). 2. Aufl. München.

8. Berlev, O.D. Dva perioda Sotisa mezhdu Godom 18 tsarya Senu, ili Tosortrosa, i Godom 2 faraona Antonina Piya. V sb.: Drevnij Egipet: yazyk–kul'tura–soznanie. Po materialam egiptologicheskoj konferentsii 12–13 marta 1998 g. M., 1999. S. 42–62.

9. Berlev, O.D., Dandamaev, M.A., Fikhman, I.F. K 100-letiyu so dnya rozhdeniya akademika Vasiliya Vasil'evicha Struve. VDI 1, 1989. S. 244–249.

10. Bikerman, Eh. Khronologiya drevnego mira: Blizhnij Vostok i antichnost'. M., 1975.

11. Biot, J.-B. 1849: Mémoires sur divers points d’astronomie ancienne et en particulier sur la période sothiaque, comprenant 1460 années juliennes de 365 j ¼. Mémoires de l’Académie des Sciences 20, 1–158.

12. Blackman, A.M. 1924: Some recent egyptological works. Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society of Great Britain and Ireland 2, 313–327.

13. Blumenthal, E. 1970: Untersuchungen zum ägyptischen Königtum des Mittleren Reiches. I. Die Phraseologie. (Abhandlungen der Sächsischen Akademie der Wissenschaften zu Leipzig. Philologisch-Historische Klasse, 61/1). Berlin.

14. Bol'shakov, A.O. Leningradskij egiptologicheskij kruzhok: polgoda predystorii. Aegyptiaca rossica 2, 2014. S. 48–120.

15. Brand, P. 2010: Usurpation of monuments. In: W. Wendrich (ed.), UCLA Encyclopedia of Egyptology. Los Angeles (URL: https://escholarship.org/content/qt5gj996k5/qt5gj996k5.pdf; data obrascheniya: 30.06.2019).

16. Černý, J. 1935: Ostraca hiératiques (Catalogue général des antiquités égyptiennes du Musée du Caire, Nos. 25501–25832). Vol. I–II. Le Caire.

17. Černý, J. 1961: Note on the supposed beginning of a Sothic Period under Sethos I. Journal of Egyptian Archaeology 47, 150–152.

18. Champollion, J.F. 1824–1826: Lettres à M. le duc de Blacas d’Aulps, premier gentilhomme de la chambre, pair de France, etc., relatives au Musée Royal égyptien de Turin. Fasc. 1. Première lettre. Monuments historiques. Fasc. 2. Seconde Lettre. Suite des monuments historiques. Paris.

19. Demidchik, A.E. Bezymyannaya piramida. Gosudarstvennaya doktrina drevneegipetskoj Gerakleopol'skoj monarkhii. (Aegyptiaca, I). SPb., 2005.

20. Demidchik, A.E. Esche raz ob avtore «Poucheniya tsaryu Merikara». Vestnik Novosibirskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seriya: Istoriya, filologiya 9/1, 2010. S. 5–10.

21. Depuydt, L. 1995: On the consistency of the wandering year as backbone of Egyptian chronology. Journal of the American Research Center in Egypt 32, 43–58.

22. Dillery, J. 2015: Clio’s Other Sons. Berossus and Manetho. A Discussion of the First Written Histories of Babylon and Egypt. Ann Arbor.

23. Dodson, A. 2009: Amarna Sunset: Nefertiti, Tutankhamun, Ay, Horemheb, and the Egyptian Counter-Reformation. Cairo–New York.

24. Fairman, H.W., Grdseloff, B. 1947: Texts of Ḥatshepsut and Sethos I inside Speos Artemidos. Journal of Egyptian Archaeology 33, 12–33.

25. Fikhman, I.F. Vvedenie v dokumental'nuyu papirologiyu. M., 1986.

26. Firth, C.M. 1926: Inscriptions from the Step Pyramid Site. Annales du Service des Antiquités de l’Égypte 26, 177–202.

27. Gardiner, A.H. 1905: The Inscription of Mes. A Contribution to the Study of Egyptian Judicial Procedure. (Untersuchungen zur Geschichte und Altertumskunde Ägyptens, 4, Bd 3). Leipzig.

28. Gardiner, A.H. 1947: Ancient Egyptian Onomastica. Vol. I–III. Oxford.

29. Gardiner, A.H. 1961: Egypt of the Pharaohs: an Introduction. London–New York.

30. Grejvs, R. Mify drevnej Gretsii. M., 1992.

31. Griffith, F.Ll. 1927: The Abydos decree of Seti I at Nauri. Journal of Egyptian Archaeology 13, 193–208.

32. Grimal, N.-Chr. 1986: Les termes de la propagande royale égyptienne de la XIX dynastie à la conquète d’Alexandre. (Mémoires de l’Académie des Inscriptions et Belles-Lettres, 6). Paris.

33. Güterbock, H.G. 1956: The deeds of Suppiluliuma as told by his son, Mursili II. Journal of Cuneiform Studies 10, 41–68.

34. Hall, H.R.H. 1923: Egypt and Babylonia to 1580 B.C.: Egyptian chronology. In: J.B. Bury et al. (eds.), The Cambridge Ancient History. Vol. I. Egypt and Babylonia. Cambridge–New York, 166–173.

35. Hari, R. 1965: Horemheb et la reine Moutnedjemet ou la fin d’une dynastie. Genève.

36. Khodzhash, S.I. i dr. (sost.). Pamyatniki i lyudi. M., 2003.

37. Hornung, E. 1964: Untersuchungen zur Chronologie und Geschichte des Neuen Reiches. (Ägyptologische Abhandlungen, 11). Wiesbaden.

38. Hornung, E., Krauss, R., Warburton, D.A. (eds.) 2006: Ancient Egyptian Chronology. (Handbook of Oriental Studies. Section One: The Near and Middle East, 83). Leiden.

39. Krall, J. 1885: Der Kalender des Papyrus Ebers. Recueil de travaux relatifs à la philologie et à l’archéologie égyptiennes et assiriennes 6, 57–63.

40. Krauss, R. 1979: Das Ende der Amarnazeit: Beiträge zur Geschichte u. Chronologie des Neuen Reiches. (Hildesheimer ägyptologische Beiträge, 7). Hildesheim.

41. Krauss, R., Detlef, U. 1982: Ein gläserner Doppelring aus Altägypten. Jahrbuch Preussischer Kulturbesitz 19, 199–212.

42. Ladynin, I.A. Legenda o tsare Amenofise (Manetho, ed. W.G. Waddell, frg. 54, Chaeremon, FGrHist. 618. F. 1) i final vtorogo tomosa truda Manefona. V sb.: A.O. Bol'shakov (red.), Peterburgskie egiptologicheskie chteniya 2007–2008: pamyati O.D. Berleva. K 75-letiyu so dnya ego rozhdeniya: Doklady. (Trudy Gosudarstvennogo Ehrmitazha, 45). SPb., 2009. S. 164–180.

43. Ladynin, I.A. 2015: The ‘Crisis of the pyramid builders’ in Herodotus’ Book II and the epochs of Egyptian history. In: P.D. Rhodes (ed.), Deformations and Crises of the Ancient Civil Communities. Stuttgart, 15–26.

44. Ladynin, I.A. Trud Manefona Sevennitskogo i istoriya Egipta I tys. do n.eh. v issledovaniyakh V.V. Struve. Vestnik Universiteta Dmitriya Pozharskogo 2 (4), 2016. S. 73–104.

45. Ladynin, I.A. «Snova pravit Egipet!» Nachalo ehllinisticheskogo vremeni v kontseptsiyakh i konstruktakh pozdneegipetskikh istoriografii i propagandy. (Trudy Istoricheskogo fakul'teta MGU, 84, Ser. II: Istoricheskie issledovaniya, 40). M.–SPb., 2017.

46. Ladynin, I.A. Dve versii Iskhoda v traditsii Manefona Sevennitskogo (Manetho, ed. W.G. Waddell, frgg. 51–53a-b). V sb.: A.A. Banschikova, I.A. Ladynin, V.V. Shelestin (red), «Khranyaschij bol'shoe vremya»: Sbornik nauchnykh trudov k pyatidesyatiletiyu A.A. Nemirovskogo. M., 2018. S. 96–113.

47. Ladynin, I.A., Nemirovskij, A.A. K ehvolyutsii vospriyatiya amarnskikh tsarej i Khoremkheba v ideologicheskoj i istoricheskoj traditsii drevnego Egipta. V sb.: O.I. Pavlova, A.A. Nemirovskij (red.), Drevnij Vostok: Obschnost' i svoeobrazie kul'turnykh traditsij. M., 2001, S. 80–99.

48. Ladynin, I.A., Nemirovskij, A.A. [Rets.:] J. von Beckerath. Chronologie des pharaonischen Ägypten. Die Zeitbestimmung der ägyptischen Geschichte von der 260 Vorzeit bis 332 v. Chr. München–Berlin, 1998. VDI 2, 2001. S. 216–226.

49. Lepsius, K.R. 1849: Die Chronologie der Aegypter. Berlin.

50. Lepsius, K.R. 1858: Königsbuch der alten Ägypter. Berlin.

51. Łukaszewicz, A. 1995: Menophres reconsidered. Journal of Juristic Papyrology 25, 99–108.

52. Luft, U. 1984: Sothisperiode. In: LÄ. 5, 1117–1121.

53. Martin, G.T. 1989: The Memphite Tomb of Ḥoremḥeb, Commander-in-Chief of Tut’ankhamūn. Vol. I. The Reliefs, Inscriptions, and Commentary. London.

54. Meyer, Ed. 1904: Ägyptische Chronologie. Berlin.

55. Montet, P. 1937: L’ère de Menophrès. Comptes Rendus des Séances de l'Académie des Inscriptions et Belles-Lettres 81, 5, 418–426.

56. Newberry, P.E. 1932: King Ay, the successor of Tutcankhamun. Journal of Egyptian Archaeology 18, 50–52.

57. Rowton, M.B. 1946: Mesopotamian chronology and the ‘Era of Menophres’. Iraq 8, 94–110.

58. Schaden, O.J. 1966. The God’s Father Ay. MA Diss. Chicago.

59. Schneider, H.D. 1996: The Memphite Tomb of Ḥoremḥeb, Commander-in-Chief of Tut‘ankhamūn. Vol. II: A Catalogue of the Finds. Leiden–London.

60. Sethe, K. 1919: Die Zeitrechnung der alten Aegypter im Verhältnis zu der der andern Völker: eine entwicklungsgeschichtliche Studie. I. Das Jahr. In: Nachrichten von der Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften zu Göttingen. Philologisch-Historische Klasse aus dem Jahre 1919, 287–320.

61. Sethe, K. 1931: Sethos I. und die Erneuerung der Hundssternperiode: (mit einem Exkurs über das wHm msw.t der thebanischen Grabberaubungs-akten. Zeitschrift für ägyptische Sprache und Altertumskunde 66, 1–7.

62. Sobolevskij, S.I. Drevnegrecheskij yazyk. Uchebnik dlya vysshikh uchebnykh zavedenij. M., 1948.

63. Struve, W. 1928: Die Ära ἀπὸ Μενόφρεως und die XIX. Dynastie Manethos. Zeitschrift für ägyptische Sprache und Altertumskunde 63, 45–50.

64. Struve, V.V. Manefon i ego vremya. Glava II. Zapiski Kollegii vostokovedov pri Aziatskom muzee Akademii nauk SSSR 4, 1930. S. 158–248.

65. Struve, W. (Hrsg.) 1930: Mathematischer Papyrus des Staatlichen Museums der Schönen Künste in Moskau. (Quellen und Studien zur Geschichte der Mathematik, Abt. A, 1). Berlin.

66. Tomashevich, O.V. Egiptolog Vladimir Vikent'ev – sozdatel' muzeya novogo tipa. V sb.: S.I. Khodzhash i dr. (sost.), Pamyatniki i lyudi. M., 2003. S. 141–170.

67. Tomashevich O.V. Deshifrovka Zh.F. Shampol'ona i stanovlenie egiptologii kak nauchnogo napravleniya v XIX–XX vv. Formirovanie egiptologicheskikh shkol. V kn.: V.I. Kuzischin (red.), Istoriografiya istorii drevnego Vostoka. Uchebnik dlya vuzov. T. I. M., 2008. S. 17–119.

68. Unger, G.F. 1867: Chronologie des Manetho. Berlin.

69. Waddell, W.G. (ed.) 1980: Manetho. (Loeb Classical Library, 350). Cambridge (MA)–London.

70. Wernicke, K. 1893: Aigyptos (3). In: RE. I, 1, 1005–1006.

71. Wildung, D. 1969: Die Rolle ägyptischer Könige im Bewusstsein ihrer Nachwelt I. (Münchner ägyptologische Studien, 17). Berlin.

72. Wildung, D. 1977: Imhotep und Amenhotep: Gottwerdung im alten Ägypten. (Münchner ägyptologische Studien, 36). München.