Small Wars of the Great Powers: Charles Edward Callwell and the Russian Empire in Comparative Perspective

In this article the author focuses on the semantic and substantive aspects of the colonial conflict analysis model presented in the work of the British Army Major General Charles Edward Collwell, “Small Wars: Their Principles and Practices”, which became the most notable British treatise on the subject at the turn of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. A distinctive feature of the work is the comparative approach to the analysis of the British colonial wars fought in the Victorian era. It is established that the Russian case (the annexation of Central Asia and the pacification of the North Caucasus) is a golden thread running through all sections of the work, serving, along with similar examples from French, Spanish, and US history, as a kind of tuning fork for the universal principles of successful small warfare that Callwell laid out in his work. The aim of the paper is to form a more substantive account of the significance of comparative colonialism for British military thinking and the place of the Russian experience in its evolution. The study has shown that “Small Wars” reflected a course towards the normalisation of the Russian Empire within a professional discourse. In addition, the historiography focuses on Callwell's selective approach to the choice of factual material and its place in the evolution of British counterinsurgency. In this article, the author focuses on identifying the reasons for differences in the forms and ways of systematizing the experience of small wars in the colonial and frontier policies of both the Russian and British empires. Particular attention is paid to the circumstances that led to the gradual loss of Callwell's work to its former importance on the eve and after the Great War.

Keywords

wars, military history, colonialism, insurgency, Charles Callwell, British Empire, Russian Empire, Central Asia, Caucasus, imperialism, colonial wars

Acknowledgment

The research was supported by the Russian Science Foundation, grant № 22-18-00011.

Received

12.01.2023

Publication date

30.04.2023

Number of characters

37079

Cite

GOST	Malkin S. Small Wars of the Great Powers: Charles Edward Callwell and the Russian Empire in Comparative Perspective // Novaia i noveishaia istoriia – 2023. – Issue 2 C. 21-33 [Electronic resource]. URL: https://nni.jes.su/S013038640022926-6-1 (circulation date: 21.05.2024). DOI: 10.31857/S013038640022926-6
MLA	Malkin, Stanislav "Small Wars of the Great Powers: Charles Edward Callwell and the Russian Empire in Comparative Perspective." Novaia i noveishaia istoriia 2 (2023):21-33. DOI: 10.31857/S013038640022926-6
APA	Malkin S. (2023). Small Wars of the Great Powers: Charles Edward Callwell and the Russian Empire in Comparative Perspective. Novaia i noveishaia istoriia (2), pp.21-33 DOI: 10.31857/S013038640022926-6

100 rub.

When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 0, views: 136

Readers community rating: votes 0

1. Arbekov A.B. Kolonial'nye vojny Velikobritanii v 70-h – nachale 80-h godov XIX veka: voenno-politicheskie aspekty angliiskoi kolonizatsii [Colonial wars of Great Britain in 70s – the beginning of 80-s of the 19th century: military and political aspects of the English colonization]: dis. … kand. ist. nauk. Orel, 2021. (In Russ.)

2. Baskhanov M.K. Istoriya izucheniya vostochnyh yazykov v russkoj imperatorskoj armii [The history of the Oriental languages study in the Russian imperial army]. Sankt-Peterburg, 2018. (In Russ.)

3. Bobrovnikov V.O. Russkij Kavkaz i francuzskij Alzhir: sluchajnoe skhodstvo ili obmen opytom kolonial'nogo stroitel'stva? [Russian Caucasus and the French Algiers: accidental similarity or exchange of experience of colonial development] // Imperium inter pares: Rol' transferov v istorii Rossijskoj imperii (1700–1917) [Imperium inter pares: the role of the transfers in the history of the Russian empire (1700–1917)] / pod red. M. Austa, R. Vul'pius, A. Millera. Moskva, 2010. S. 182–209. (In Russ.)

4. Chernysheva M.A. Vasilij Vereshchagin i Zhan-Leon Zherom [Vasilii Vereshchagin and Jan-Gerome] // Vasilii Vereshchagin. 1842–1904. Moskva, 2018. S. 30–39. (In Russ.)

5. Gershel'man F.K. Partizanskaya voina [Partisan war]. Sankt-Peterburg, 1885. (In Russ.)

6. Lapin V.V. Armiya Rossii v Kavkazskoi voine XVIII–XIX vv. [Russian army in the Caucasus war of the 18th–19th centuries]. Sankt-Peterburg, 2008. (In Russ.)

7. Malkin S.G. Ot malykh voin k geril'e: imperskaya shkola voennoi mysli Velikobritanii v epohu Interbelluma [From small wars to guerrilla: imperial school of military thought in Great Britain during the Interbellum] // Novaya i Noveishaya istoriya [Modern and Contemporary history]. 2021. № 6. S. 22–30. (In Russ.)

8. Periconius G. Prikladnaya taktika [Applied tactics]. Sankt-Peterburg, 1872. (In Russ.)

9. Sbornik geograficheskikh, topograficheskikh i statisticheskikh materialov po Azii. General'nyi shtab Rossiiskoi imperatorskoi armii [Collected works on geographical, topographic and statistical materials on Asia. General Staff of the Russian imperial army]. Sankt-Peterburg, 1883–1914. (In Russ.)

10. Sergeev E.Yu. Bol'shaya igra, 1856–1907: mify i realii rossiisko-britanskih otnoshenii v Central'noi i Vostochnoi Azii [Great game, 1856–1907: myths and realities of the Russian-British relations in Central and Eastern Asia]. Moskva, 2012. (In Russ.)

11. Severnyi Kavkaz v sostave Rossiiskoi imperii [Northern Caucasus in the Russian empire] / оtv. red. V.O. Bobrovnikov, I.L. Babich. Moskva, 2007. (In Russ.)

12. Tol'c V. “Sobstvennyi vostok Rossii”: politika identichnosti i vostokovedenie v pozdneimperskii i rannesovetskii period [“Its own East of Russia”: identity politics and oriental studies in late imperial and early soviet period]. Moskva, 2013. (In Russ.)

13. Tol'c V. Rossiiskie vostokovedy i obshcheevropeiskie tendencii v razmyshleniyakh ob imperiyah konca XIX – nachala XX veka [Russian orientalists and common European tendencies of the thoughts on empires in the end of the 19th – the beginning of the 20th centuries] // Imperium inter pares: Rol' transferov v istorii Rossiiskoi imperii (1700–1917) [Imperium inter pares: the role of the transfers in the history of the Russian empire (1700–1917)] / pod red. M. Austa, R. Vul'pius, A. Millera. Moskva, 2010. S. 266–307. (In Russ.)

14. Vuich I.V. Malaya voina [Small war]. Sankt-Peterburg, 1850. (In Russ.)

15. Zapadnye okrainy v sostave Rossiiskoi imperii [The Western outskirts in the Russian empire] / otv. red. M. Dolbilov, A. Miller. Moskva, 2007. (In Russ.)

16. A German Colonial Campaign: The Operations against the Bondelszwarts and Hereros from the Beginning of October, 1903, to 31st July, 1905. Compiled by the 2nd Bureau of the French General Staff. Translated, by permission of the French Minister of War, from the Revue Militaire des Armies Etrangeres // Royal United Services Institution. Journal. 1906. Vol. 50 (336). P. 207–214.

17. Callwell C.E. Petites Guerres, leur principles et leur execution. Paris, 1899.

18. Callwell C.E. Instructions for Intelligence Officers Abroad. London, 1889.

19. Callwell C.E. Lessons to be Learnt from the Campaigns in which British Forces have been Employed since the Year 1865 // Royal United Services Institution. Journal. 1877. Vol. 31 (139). P. 357–412.

20. Callwell C.E. Small Wars. Their principles and practice. General Staff – War Office. London, 1896 [1899, 1906].

21. Cunningham A.G. The Training of the Army, 1934 // Royal United Services Institution. Journal. 1934. Vol. 79 (516). P. 723–732.

22. Ditte A. Observations sur la guerre dans les colonies, organization – execution: Conferences faites a l’Ecole Superieure de Guerre. Paris, 1905.

23. Ellis E.H. Bush Brigades // Marine Corps Gazette. March 1921. P. 1–15.

24. Griffin C. A Revolution in Colonial Military Affairs: Gallieni, Lyautey, and the “Tache d’huile”: paper prepared for the 2009 British International Studies Association Conference. Leicester, December 14–16, 2009.

25. Ground Truths: British Army Operations in the Irish War of Independence / ed. W.H. Kautt. Newbridge, 2014.

26. Gwynn C.W. Imperial Policing. London, 1934 [1936, 1939].

27. Gwynn C.W. Army Training, 1931 // Royal United Services Institution. Journal. 1931. Vol. 76 (504). P. 722–730.

28. Harrington S.M. The Strategy and Tactics of Small Wars // Marine Corps Gazette. December 1921. P. 474–491.

29. Hevia J. The Imperial Security State. British Colonial Knowledge and Empire-Building in Asia. Cambridge, 2012.

30. Hudson C.E. The Tasks of the Army // Royal United Services Institution. Journal. 1933. Vol. 78 (512). P. 773–778.

31. Jeffrey K. Field Marshal Henry Wilson: A Political Soldier. Oxford, 2006.

32. Jeffrey K. The British Army and the Crisis of Empire, 1918–22. Manchester, 1984.

33. Jeffrey K. The road to Asia and the Grafton Hotel, Dublin: Ireland and the “British world” // Irish Historical Studies. 2008. Vol. XXXVI. № 42. P. 243–256.

34. Linder U. New Forms of Knowledge Exchange Between Imperial Powers: The Development of the Institut Colonial International (ICI) Since the End of the Nineteenth Century // Imperial Cooperation and Transfer, 1870–1930. Empires and Encounters / eds V. Barth, R. Chetkovski. London; New Delhi; New York; Sydney, 2015. P. 57–78.

35. Lyautey H. Du Role Colonial de L’Armee. Paris, 1900.

36. Malkin S.G. “Lessons learned” during the Interbellum: “Irish war” and British counterinsurgency // Small Wars & Insurgencies. 2021. Vol. 32. Iss. 4–5 (Special Issue on insurgency and counterinsurgency in Ireland). P. 598618.

37. Malkin S.G. From small wars to counterinsurgency: C.W. Gwynn, “Imperial Policing” and transformation of doctrine // Small Wars & Insurgencies. 2019. Vol. 30 (3). Р. 660–678.

38. Malkin S.G. Transfers of Colonial (dis)Order: Guerrilla Warfare and the British Military Thought after the Great War // Small wars & Insurgencies. 2022. Vol. 33 (8). P. 1421–1443.

39. Moreman T. “Small Wars” and “Imperial Policing”: The British army and the theory and practice of colonial warfare in the British empire, 1919–1939 // Journal of Strategic Studies. 1996. Vol. 19. № 4. P. 105–131.

40. Moreman T. The Army in India and the Development of Frontier Warfare, 1849–1947. London, 1998.

41. Morrison A. “Applied Orientalism” in British India and Tsarist Turkestan // Comparative Studies in Society & History. 2009. Vol. 51. № 3. P. 619–647.

42. Morrison A. “The extraordinary success which the Russians have achieved” – the conquest of Central Asia in Callwell’s Small Wars // Small Wars & Insurgencies. 2019. Vol. 30 (4–5). P. 913–936.

43. Notes on Imperial Policing. War Office, 1934.

44. Porch D. Bugeaud, Gallieni, Lyautey: The Development of French Colonial Warfare // Makers of Modern Strategy: From Machiavelli to the Nuclear Age / ed. P. Paret. Oxford, 1986. P. 376–407.

45. Porch D. Counterinsurgency: Exposing the Myths of the New Way of War. Cambridge, 2013.

46. Raghaven S. Protecting the Raj: The Army in India and Internal Security, c. 1919–39 // Small Wars & Insurgencies. 2005. № 16 (3). P. 253–279.

47. Septans A. Les Expeditions Anglaises en Afrique. Paris, 1896.

48. Small Wars Manual. United States Marine Corps. United States Government Printing Office. Washington, 1940.

49. Small Wars Operations. Revision / ed. Major H.L. Larsen, the Chief of the Small Wars Section, Marine Corps Schools. Marine Barracks; Quantico; Virginia. 1935 [1938].

50. Smith A.B. The Tasks of the Army // Royal United Services Institution. Journal. 1934. Vol. 79 (513). P. 47–54.

51. Tripodi C. Edge of Empire: The British Political Officer and Tribal Administration on the North-West Frontier 1877–1947. London, 2010.

52. Utley H.H. An Introduction to the Tactics and Techniques of Small Wars // Marine Corps Gazette. May 1931. Vol. 15 (5). P. 50–53.

53. Utley H.H. An Introduction to the Tactics of Small Wars // Marine Corps Gazette. November 1933. Vol. 18 (3). P. 44–46.

54. Wavell A.P. The Training of the Army for War // Royal United Services Institution. Journal. 1933. Vol. 78 (510). P. 254–273.

55. Whittingham D. “Savage warfare”: C.E. Callwell, the roots of counter-insurgency, and the nineteenth century context // Small Wars & Insurgencies. 2012. Vol. 23 (4–5). P. 591–607.