On Certain Aspects of the Studies of the Greater German Idea of 1848–1866

A new interest in the era of the emergence of the German Empire is growing in Russian historiography. In this context, it is once again relevant to look at alternatives to the victorious Lesser German path of 1848–1866, above all at the Greater German Idea. The author attempts to outline some aspects of this historical phenomenon in the works of Russian and German scholars of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, analysing the period of 1848–1866 from a predominantly Lesser German perspective: the history of Prussia, its conflict with Austria and the politics of Otto von Bismarck came to the fore. Highlighting the ambiguity of the term “Greater German” as well as the dual discrediting of the idea of the Greater German idea (first following Austria's defeat in the nineteenth century and then under the influence of the aggressive ideology of the Third Reich in the twentieth century), the author offers a new approach to the established understanding of the Greater German Path in Russian historical scholarship. In particular, he suggests that attention should be paid to the new wave of interest in the federalist aspect of the Greater German idea, which manifested itself in the policies of the “Third Germany” states, as well as to the legitimate and evolutionary nature of the Greater German path, which envisaged German unification as a progressive development of the German Confederation instead of the Bismarckian unification by “iron and blood”. By looking directly at the German research experience, the author aims to demonstrate the significance of the 1848–1866 Greater German Idea for modern scholarship as a foundation for the study of national and supranational federal state models.

Keywords

Germany, state-building, national unification, federalism, Greater Germans, Lesser Germans, the German question, historiography, German Confederation

Received

12.09.2022

Publication date

19.12.2022

Number of characters

24643

Cite

GOST	Datsenko P. On Certain Aspects of the Studies of the Greater German Idea of 1848–1866 // Novaia i noveishaia istoriia – 2022. – Issue 6 C. 17-27 [Electronic resource]. URL: https://nni.jes.su/S013038640020570-5-1 (circulation date: 12.05.2024). DOI: 10.31857/S013038640020570-5
MLA	Datsenko, Pavel "On Certain Aspects of the Studies of the Greater German Idea of 1848–1866." Novaia i noveishaia istoriia 6 (2022):17-27. DOI: 10.31857/S013038640020570-5
APA	Datsenko P. (2022). On Certain Aspects of the Studies of the Greater German Idea of 1848–1866. Novaia i noveishaia istoriia (6), pp.17-27 DOI: 10.31857/S013038640020570-5

100 rub.

When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 0, views: 207

Readers community rating: votes 0

1. Aleksandrov A.A. “Tret'ia Germaniia” na fone avstro-prusskogo protivoborstva na rubezhe XVIII–XIX vv. [The “third Germany” amid the Austro-Prussian confrontation on the cusp of the 18th and 19th centuries] // Vestnik Kostromskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta im. N.A. Nekrasova [Bulletin of N.A. Nekrasov Kostroma State University]. 2005. T. 11. № 11. P. 32–35. (In Russ.)

2. Baev V.G. “Ispolnitel'nyi federalism” v Germanii novogo vremeni: istoki i rol' Prussii v ego stanovlenii [“Executive federalism” in the Germany in the Modern age: origines and the role of Prussia in its genesis] // Problemy federativnykh otnoshenii v stranakh Evropy: sb. nauch. st. Vserossiiskoi nauchnoi konferentsii, posviashchennoi 25-letiiu Assotsiatsii evropeiskikh issledovanii , Penza, 01–02 iiunia 2017 goda [Problems of federative relations in European countries: collection of articles of All-Russian Scientific Conference dedicated to the 25th anniversary of the Association for European Studies, Penza, 01–02 June 2017]. Penza, 2017. P. 111–117. (In Russ.)

3. Buzeskul V.P. Genrikh Zibel' kak istorik-politik [Heinrich Siebel as a historian-politician]. Khar'kov, 1896. (In Russ.)

4. Datsenko P.A. Frankfurtskii s"ezd kniazei 1863 g.: posledniaia popytka reformy Germanskogo soiuza [The Frankfurt Congress of Princes in 1863: the last attempt at reform of the German Union] // Elektronnyi nauchno-obrazovatel'nyi zhurnal “Istoriia” [Electronic scientific and educational magazine “History”]. 2021. T. 12. № 6 (104). URL: https://history.jes.su/s207987840001860-5-1/ (access date: 01.08.2022). (In Russ.)

5. Dudarev V.S. Spor ob imperatorskom titule: traditsionalizm Vil'gel'ma I i politika gosudarstvennykh interesov Otto fon Bismarka [The dispute over the imperial title: the traditionalism of Wilhelm I and the policy of state interests of Otto von Bismarck] // Novaia i noveishaia istoriia [Modern and Contemporary History]. 2022. № 1. P. 30–43. (In Russ.)

6. Dzhivelegov A.K. Istoriia sovremennoi Germanii [History of contemporary Germany]. Ch. 2. Sankt-Peterburg, 1910. (In Russ.)

7. Galkin I.S. Sozdanie Germanskoi imperii [The Creation of the German Empire]. Moskva, 1986. (In Russ.)

8. Germanskaia istoriia v novoe i noveishee vremia [German History in modern and modern times] / pod red. S.D. Skazkina. T. 1. Moskva, 1970. (In Russ.)

9. Guerrier V.I. Leibnits i ego vek [Leibniz and his century]. T. 1. Sankt-Peterburg, 1868. (In Russ.)

10. Guerrier V.I. Natsional'naia istoriografiia v Germanii [Germany national historiography] // Istoricheskii vestnik [The Historical Reporter]. T. 1. 1880. P. 567–593. (In Russ.)

11. Kotova E.V. Germanskii vopros vo vneshnei politike Avstriiskoi imperii v 1850–1866 gg. [The German question in the foreign policy of the Austrian Empire in 1850–1866] // Elektronnyi nauchno-obrazovatel'nyi zhurnal “Istoriia” [Electronic scientific and educational magazine “History”]. 2021. T. 12. № 6 (104). URL: https://history.jes.su/s207987840016050-4-1/ (access date: 01.08.2022). (In Russ.)

12. Matveeva A.G. Nekotorye aspekty vnutrennei politiki Germanii perioda kantslerstva Kh. fon Gogenloe-Shillingfiursta: ot “novogo kursa” k “mirovoi politike” (po materialam Arkhiva vneshnei politiki Rossiiskoi imperii) [Chancellor H.H. von Hohenlohe-Schillingfürst inner policy: some aspects of shift from the “New course” to the “world policy” (based on Foreign Policy Archive of the Russian Empire documents)] // Elektronnyi nauchno-obrazovatel'nyi zhurnal “Istoriia” [Electronic scientific and educational magazine “History”]. 2020. T. 11. № 7 (93). URL: https://history.jes.su/s207987840010919-9-1/ (access date: 01.08.2022). (In Russ.)

13. Mikhailov M.I. Problema ob"edineniia Germanii v trudakh K. Marksa i F. Engel'sa [The problem of German unification in the works of C. Marx and F. Engels] // Ezhegodnik germanskoi istorii [Yearbook of the German History]. 1988. Moskva, 1991. S. 24–50. (In Russ.)

14. Narochnitskaia L.I. Rossiia i voiny Prussii v 60-kh godakh XIX v. za ob"edinenie Germanii “sverkhu” [Russia and the Prussian wars for the unification of Germany “from above” in the 60s years of the 19th century]. Moskva, 1960. (In Russ.)

15. Novikova L.G. Pozitsiia Velikobritanii po voprosu ob"edineniia Germanii v 60-e – nachale 70-kh godov XIX v. [The position of Great Britain on the issue of the unification of Germany in the 60s – early 70s of the 19th century]. Moskva, 1982. (In Russ.)

16. Obolenskaia S.V. Problemy obrazovaniia germanskoi imperii 1871 g. v osveshchenii sovremennoi burzhuaznoi istoriografii FRG [Problems of the formation of the German Empire in 1871 in the light of contemporary bourgeois historiography in the West Germany] // Ezhegodnik germanskoi istorii. 1987 [Yearbook of the German History. 1987]. Moskva, 1988. P. 204–225. (In Russ.)

17. Patrushev A.I. Germanskaia istoriia cherez ternii dvukh tysiacheletii [German history through the thorns of two millennia]. Moskva, 2007. (In Russ.)

18. Petrenko S.P. Germaniia v tret'ei chetverti XIX v.: put' k natsional'nomu edinstvu [Germany in the third quarter of the 19th century: way to the national unity] // Vestnik Taganrogskogo gosudarstvennogo pedagogicheskogo instituta [Bulletin of Taganrog State Pedagogical Institute]. 2011. № 2. P. 274–280. (In Russ.)

19. Rostislavleva N.V. Retseptsiia temy Germanskoi imperii v iubileinykh istoricheskikh narrativakh Rossii i Germanii v XX veke [Reception of the theme of the German Empire in the anniversary historical narratives of the 20th century] // Novaia i noveishaia istoriia [Modern and Contemporary History]. 2022. № 3. P. 91–100. (In Russ.)

20. Sergeev V.V. Angliia i ob"edinenie Germanii v 1848–1871 gg. [England and the unification of Germany in 1848–1871]. Leningrad, 1986. (In Russ.)

21. Shneerson L.M. Avstro-prusskaia voina 1866 g. i diplomatiia velikikh derzhav (iz istorii germanskogo voprosa) [Austro-Prussian war 1866 and the diplomacy of Great Powers (from the history of the German question)]. Minsk, 1962. (In Russ.)

22. Trachevskii A.S. Germaniia nakanune revoliutsii i ee ob"edinenie [Germany on the eve of the revolution and its unification]. Sankt-Peterburg, 1898. (In Russ.)

23. Turygin A.A., Khabibova L.V. Prizrak 1866 goda i obrazovanie Germanskoi Imperii [The phantom of 1866 and creation of German Empire] // Istoriia. Obshchestvo. Politika [History. Society. Policy]. 2019. № 2 (10). P. 36–42. (In Russ.)

24. Burg P. Die Triaspolitik im Deutschen Bund (Das Problem einer partnerschaftlichen Mitwirkung und eigenständigen Entwicklung des Dritten Deutschland) // Deutscher Bund und deutsche Frage 1815–1866 / Hrsg. von H. Rumpler. Wien etc., 1990. S. 136–161.

25. Derndarsky M. Österreich und die deutsche Frage zwischen 1848 und 1866/71. Konzeptionelles Dilemma und situative Probleme der Donaumonarchie gegenüber Deutschland // Die Deutsche Frage im 19. Und 20. Jahrhundert: Referate und Diskussionsbeiträge eines Augsburger Symposions, 23. bis 25. September 1981. München, 1983. S. 63–90.

26. Fellner F. Perspektiven für eine historiographische Neubewertung des Deutschen Bundes // Deutscher Bund und deutsche Frage 1815–1866. München, 1990. S. 21–30.

27. Fuchs W.P. Die deutschen Mittelstaaten und die Bundesreform 1853–1860. Berlin, 1934.

28. Gruner W.D. Der Deutsche Bund. München, 2012.

29. Jürgens K.H. Die deutsche Politik Preußens und das Berliner Central-Preßbüreau. Hildesheim, 1855.

30. Kreutzmann M. Föderative Ordnung und nationale Integration im Deutschen Bund 1816–1848. Die Ausschüsse und Kommissionen der Deutschen Bundesversammlung als politische Gremien. Göttingen, 2022.

31. Langewiesche D. Nation, Nationalismus, Nationalstaat in Deutschland und Europa. München, 2000.

32. Lexikon der deutschen Geschichte. Leipzig, 1882.

33. Mommsen W. Von der Pfordten ein Grossdeutscher? // Historische Zeitschrift. 1940. Bd. 162. H. 3. S. 551–556.

34. Müller J. Deutscher Bund und deutsche Nation 1848–1866. Göttingen, 2005.

35. Müller J. Harter Prexit. Der Austritt Preußens aus dem Deutschen Bund 1866 // Historische Mitteilungen. 2018. Bd. 30. S. 99–118.

36. Paller H. von. Der großdeutsche Gedanke: Seine Entstehung und Entwicklung bis zur Gegenwart. Leipzig, 1928.

37. Ritter G. Großdeutsch und kleindeutsch im 19. Jahrhundert // Ritter G. Lebendige Vergangenheit: Beiträge zur historisch-politischen Selbstbesinnung. München, 1958. S. 101–125.

38. Srbik H.R. von. Deutsche Einheit in Idee und Wirklichkeit vom Heiligen Reich bis Königgrätz. Bd. 1–4. München, 1935–1942.

39. Treitschke H. von. Bundesstaat und Einheitsstaat // Treitschke H. von. Historische und politische Aufsätze. Leipzig, 1865. S. 444–595.

40. Weber R. Forschungen zur deutschen Geschichte 1849–1871 // Historische Forschungen in der DDR 1970–1980. Analysen und Berichte. Berlin, 1980. S. 169–185.