On the Reasons Why the Reinsurance Treaty Was not Renewed in 1890

The article is aimed at discussing the reasons for the non-renewal of the Reinsurance Treaty in 1890 between Russia and Germany. It analyses the fundamental traits of Bismarck’s foreign policy towards Russia and subsequently deals with the impact of Bismarck’s resignation. It further details the shift in attitudes towards Russia by Bismarck’s replacement in order to understand why the Treaty was not renewed. The article also determines how this shift influenced international politics and lists the reasons for French and Russian relations growing. The study uses methodological approaches of “traditional” political history, meaning history of states and diplomacy based on “the primacy of foreign policy” and research fields aimed at actions of states and their highest political representatives. Based on the methodological approaches, an analysis has been conducted of “highest policy” and a “realistic” insight into the history of foreign policy is presented in narrative form. The author agrees with the opinion that the changes in German foreign policy led to the so-called “revolution of the alliances”. Based on unpublished sources found during archival research, the study concludes that the post-Bismarck diplomacy negatively impacted Germany’s international position since its actions brought France and Russia closer and left Germany with the weakest ally, i.e. Austria-Hungary. The study further concludes that these changes symbolized a huge loss for Germany’s diplomacy. The author assesses that the new diplomacy did not prove itself, calculated falsely, analyzed incorrectly, and predicted wrongly.

Keywords

Reinsurance Treaty, Russian-German relations, Bismarck, Wilhelm II, Alexander III

Acknowledgment

This study was composed at Charles University as part of the program PROGRES Q09: Historie – Klíč k pochopení globalizovaného světa. Translation by Livie Stellner.

Received

10.05.2021

Publication date

19.10.2021

Number of characters

38027

Cite

GOST	Stellner F. On the Reasons Why the Reinsurance Treaty Was not Renewed in 1890 // Novaia i noveishaia istoriia – 2021. – Issue 6 C. 44-54 [Electronic resource]. URL: https://nni.jes.su/S013038640017181-7-1 (circulation date: 24.04.2024). DOI: 10.31857/S013038640017181-7
MLA	Stellner, František "On the Reasons Why the Reinsurance Treaty Was not Renewed in 1890." Novaia i noveishaia istoriia 6 (2021):44-54. DOI: 10.31857/S013038640017181-7
APA	Stellner F. (2021). On the Reasons Why the Reinsurance Treaty Was not Renewed in 1890. Novaia i noveishaia istoriia (6), pp.44-54 DOI: 10.31857/S013038640017181-7

1 rub.

When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 0, views: 1102

Readers community rating: votes 0

1. Abezgauz S.A. Vliyanie ehkonomicheskikh otnoshenij na dogovor «perestrakhovki» 1887 goda mezhdu Rossiej i Germaniej // Trudy istoricheskogo fakul'teta SPbGU. 2012. № 9. C. 79–87.

2. Vinogradov K.B., Gostenkov A.V. Dni i dela Fridrikha Gol'shtejna // Novaya i novejshaya istoriya. 1984. № 2. S. 147–165.

3. Vlasov N.A. Al'fred fon Val'derzee // Voprosy istorii. 2018. № 8. S. 26–42.

4. Dnevnik V.N. Lamzdorfa, 1886–1890 / otv. red. F.A. Rotshtejn. M. – L., 1926.

5. Ipatov A.M. Politika Aleksandra III v otnoshenii Germanii // Panorama. 2016. T. 22. C. 23–34.

6. Manfred A.Z. Obrazovanie russko-frantsuzskogo soyuza. M., 1975.

7. Medyakov A.S. «Nash Bismark»? Rossiya v politike i vzglyadakh «Zheleznogo kantslera» Germanii // Rossijskaya istoriya. 2015. № 6. S. 63–84.

8. Abezgauz S.A. Vliyanine ekonomicheskikh otnoshenii na dogovor “perestrakhovki” 1887 goda mezhdu Rossiei i Germaniei [Influence of the economic relations on the Reinsurance Treaty 1887 between Russia and Germany] // Trudy istoricheskogo fakulteta Sankt-Peterburgskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta [Works of Historical Department of St. Petersburg State University]. 2017. № 9. S. 79–87. (In Russ.)

9. Dnevnik V.N. Lamzdorfa, 1886–1890 / otv. red. F.A. Rotstein [The Diary by V.N. Lamzdorf / ed. F.A. Rotstein]. Moskva – Leningrad, 1926. (In Russ.)

10. Ipatov A.M. Politika Alexandra III v otnoshenii Germanii [Politics of Alexander III toward Germany] // Panorama. 2016. T. 22. S. 23–34. (In Russ.)

11. Vlasov N.A. Alfred von Waldersee // Voprosy istorii [Problems of History]. 2018. № 8. S. 26–42. (In Russ.)

12. Vinogradov K.B., Gostenkov A.V. Dni i dela Frirdiecha Golsteina [The days and works of Friedrich Holstein] // Novaia i noveishaia istoria [Modern and Contemporary History]. 1984. № 2. S. 147–165. (In Russ.)

13. Manfred A.Z. Making of the Russian-French alliance. Moskva, 1975. (In Russ.)

14. Mediakov A.S. “Our Bismarck”? Rossia in German “iron cancellor’s” policy and views // Rossiiskaia istoriia [Russian History]. 2015. № 6. S. 63. (In Russ.)

15. Am Hof der Hohenzollern. Aus dem Tagebuch der Baronin Spitzemberg 1865–1914. München, 1979.

16. Aufzeichnungen und Erinnerungen aus dem Leben des Botschafters Joseph Maria von Radowitz / hg. von H. Holborn. Bd. 2. Stuttgart, 1925.

17. Aus dem Briefwechsel des Generalfeldmarschalls Alfred Grafen von Waldersee. Bd. I. Stuttgart – Berlin – Leipzig, 1928.

18. Bismarck O. Gedanken und Erinnerungen. Stuttgart – Berlin, 1928.

19. Botschafter Paul Graf von Hatzfeldt Nachgelassene Papiere 1838–1901 / hg. von G. Ebel, M. Behnen. Boppard am Rhein, 1976.

20. Brauer A. Im Dienste Bismarcks. Persönliche Erinnerungen / hg. von H. Rogge. Berlin, 1936.

21. Briefe Kaiser Franz Josephs I. und Kaiser Wilhelms II. über Bismarcks Rücktritt / hg. von H. Schlitter // Österreichische Rundschau. Bd. 58. Wien, 1919.

22. Briefwechsel des Botschafters General v. Schweinitz / hg. von W. von Schweinitz. Berlin, 1928.

23. Canis K. Bismarcks Außenpolitik 1870–1890. Aufstieg und Gefährdung, Paderborn, 2003.

24. Cecil L. Wilhelm II, Prince and Emperor, 1859–1900. London, 1989.

25. Documents diplomatiques français 1871–1914. T. 7. Paris, 1929.

26. Eckardstein H. Lebenserinnerungen und politische Denkwürdigkeiten von Botschaftsrat a.D. Hermann Freiherrn von Eckardstein. Vol. 1. Leipzig, 1919.

27. Eyck E. Das persönliche Regiment Wilhelms II, Politische Geschichte des deutschen Kaiserreiches 1890–1917. Erlenbach – Zürich, 1948.

28. Die geheime Papiere Friedrich von Holstein / hg. von N. Rich, M.H. Fisher, W. Frauendienst. Bd. 1. Göttingen, 1956.

29. Geyer D. Das russische Imperium / hg. von J. Baberowski, R. Lindner. Berlin – Boston, 2020.

30. Die Grosse Politik der Europäischen Kabinette 1871–1914. Sammlung der Diplomatischen Akten des Auswärtigen Amtes / hg. von J. Lepsius, A. Mendelssohn-Bartholdy, F. Thimme. Bd. 6–7. Berlin, 1922–1924.

31. Lerchenfeld-Köfering H.G. Kaiser Wilhelm II. als Persönlichkeit und Herrscher / hg. von D. Albrecht. Kallmünz, 1985.

32. Nichols J.A. Germany After Bismarck: The Caprivi Era, 1890–1894. Cambridge, 1958.

33. Philipp Eulenburg politisches Korrespondenz / hg. von J.C.G. Röhl. Bd. 1. Boppard am Rhein, 1976.

34. Rich N. Friedrich von Holstein. Politics and Diplomacy in the Era of Bismarck and Wilhelm II. Vol. 2. Cambridge, 1965.

35. Richter G. Friedrich von Holstein. Ein Mitarbeiter Bismarcks. Lübeck – Hamburg, 1966.

36. Rogge H. Holstein und Hohenlohe. Neue Beiträge zu Friedrich v. Holsteins Tätigkeit als Mitarbeiter Bismarcks und Ratgeber Hohenlohes. Stuttgart, 1957.

37. Röhl J.C.G. Wilhelm II. Vol. 2. Der Aufbau der Persönlichen Monarchie 1888–1900. München, 2001.

38. Schölgen G. Die Macht in der Mitte Europas. Stationen deutscher Außenpolitik von Friedrich dem Großen bis zur Gegenwart. München, 1992.

39. Stellner F. Der erste Staatsbesuch des deutschen Kaisers Wilhelms II in Wien // Prague Papers on History of International Relations. Vol. 5. Prague, 2001. S. 75–83.

40. Wilhelm II, The Kaiser´s Memoirs. Wilhelm II Emperor of Germany 1888–1918. New York – London, 1922.

41. Zur Geschichte und Problematik des deutsch-russischen Rückversicherungsvertrags von 1887 / hg. H. Hallmann. Darmstadt, 1968.