Modern English Historiography of the Communist International: A General Overview

The article is devoted to the analysis of the 21st-century English-language historiography of the Communist International. Contemporary historians are showing increasing interest in the study of this international organization. Three available conceptual approaches to this topic (“traditionalist”, “revisionist”, and “post-revisionist”) are considered and characterized, the works of historians from Great Britain, the USA, Canada, Ireland, Australia, New Zealand are analyzed. The article demonstrates an increase in research interest in the Communist International. In a fairly large volume of studies, there are monographs and articles devoted to the organization both directly (the historiography of the Comintern, the activities of its sections around the world, etc.) and indirectly, i.e., to related issues such as the history of communism, in particular, and the left forces, in general, international relations of Soviet Russia, the communist movement in individual countries, etc. These studies touch on the period of the Comintern's activity from 1920 to the end of the 1930s, including several controversial issues: the impact on the policy of the national communist parties of the “The Twenty-one Conditions”, united front tactics, Bolshevization, Stalinization, and the Popular Front. The author believes that most of the studies (especially those published in the first decade of the 21st century) are based on studies published long before the 2000s, however, archival materials are being used in increasing volumes, which makes modern research more objective. This gives grounds for a conclusion about the revision of the historiographic tradition of the Comintern that existed in the 20th century: new approaches (“revisionist” and “post-revisionist”) entailed a change in emphasis and a revision of some established points of view. Authors adhering to these approaches rely mainly on modern literature (including Russian) and a wide source base represented by materials from both national archives and the Russian State Archives of Social-Political History.

Keywords

Historiography, Comintern, Bolshevization, Stalinization, “third period”, political history

Received

21.04.2021

Publication date

05.08.2021

Number of characters

33841

Cite

GOST	Suzdaltsev I. Modern English Historiography of the Communist International: A General Overview // Novaia i noveishaia istoriia – 2021. – Issue 4 C. 18-30 [Electronic resource]. URL: https://nni.jes.su/S013038640013465-9-1 (circulation date: 25.04.2024). DOI: 10.31857/S013038640013465-9
MLA	Suzdaltsev, Ilya "Modern English Historiography of the Communist International: A General Overview." Novaia i noveishaia istoriia 4 (2021):18-30. DOI: 10.31857/S013038640013465-9
APA	Suzdaltsev I. (2021). Modern English Historiography of the Communist International: A General Overview. Novaia i noveishaia istoriia (4), pp.18-30 DOI: 10.31857/S013038640013465-9

100 rub.

When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 0, views: 688

Readers community rating: votes 0

1. Pristland D. Krasnyy flag: istoriya kommunizma [per. s angl.]. Moscow, 2006. (In Russ.).

2. Suzdal'tsev I.A. Bol'sheviki i politika Kominterna v 1919-1924 gg.: dis. na soisk. uchen. step. kand. ist. nauk. Mytishchi, 2019. (In Russ.).

3. Adi H. Pan-Africanism and communism The Communist International, Africa and the diaspora, 1919–1939. Trenton, 2013 // URL: https://salvage.zone/online-exclusive/pan-africanism-and-communism-an-interview-with-hakim-adi/ (access date 05.10.2020).

4. Becker M. Mariátegui, the Comintern, and the indigenous question in Latin America // Science & Society, 2006, vol. 70, №4, p. 450–479.

5. Brown A. The rise and fall of communism. NY, 2009.

6. Callaghan J. Storm Over Asia: Comintern Colonial Policy in the Third Period // In Search of Revolution: International Communist Parties in the Third Period. Edited by Worley M. London, 2004, p. 18-37.

7. Chase W.J. Enemies within the gates? The Comintern and the Stalinist Repression, 1934–1939. New Haven and London, 2001.

8. Cohen G., Morgan K. Stalin’s Sausage Machine: British Students at the International Lenin School 1926 – 1937. Twentieth Century British History, 2002, vol.13, №4, p. 327–355.

9. Cunha C. The Portuguese Communist Party, Its Ancillary Organisations, and the Communist International's Third Period // In Search of Revolution: International Communist Parties in the Third Period. Edited by Worley M. London, 2004, p. 152–173.

10. Drachewych O. The Communist International, Anti-Imperialism and Racial Equality in British Dominions. London and New York, 2019.

11. Drew A. The New Line in South Africa: Ideology and Perception in a Very Small Communist Party // In Search of Revolution: International Communist Parties in the Third Period. Edited by Worley M. London, 2004, p. 337–359.

12. Eley G. Forging Democracy: The History of the Left in Europe, 1850–2000. Oxford, 2002.

13. Firsov F.I., Klehr H., Haynes J.E. Secret Cables of the Comintern, 1933–1943. New Haven and London, 2014.

14. Fowkes B. To Make the Nation or to Break It: Communist Dilemmas in Two Interwar Multinational States // Bolshevism, Stalinism and the Comintern. Perspectives on Stalinization, 1917–53. Edited by Morgan K., Worley M., LaPorte N. London, 2008, p. 206–225.

15. Haslam J. Comintern and Soviet foreign policy, 1919–1941 // The Cambridge History of Russia. Edited by Suny R.G. Cambridge, 2006, p. 636–661.

16. Holmes L. Communism. A Very Short Introduction. Oxford, 2009.

17. Hopkins S. French Communism, The Comintern and Class Against Class: Interpretations and Rationales // In Search of Revolution: International Communist Parties in the Third Period. Edited by Worley M. London, Palgrave Macmillan. 2004, p. 106–128.

18. Khalid A. Communism on the Frontier: The Sovietization of Central Asia and Mongolia // The Cambridge History of Communism. Volume I. World Revolution and Socialism in One Country 1917–1941. Edited by Pons S. and Smith S.A. Cambridge, 2017. P. 616-636.

19. Kirschenbaum L.A. International Communism and the Spanish Civil War. Cambridge, 2015.

20. Klehr H. The Communist Experience in America: A Political and Social History. New York, 2010.

21. Kocho-Williams A. Russia’s International Relations in the Twentieth Century. London and New York, 2013.

22. Kocho-Williams A. Soviet Diplomacy and the Comintern 1921-1927 // Researchgate, november 2013, p. 1-37 // URL: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/310770954_Soviet_Diplomacy_and_the_Comintern_1921-1927 (access date 08.10.2020).

23. Kocho-Williams A. The Communist International through a British Lens // Conference: 123th Annual Meeting American Historical Association, 2009 // URL: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/267536670_The_Communist_International_through_a_British_Lens (access date 08.10.2020).

24. LaPorte N. Presenting a Crisis as an Opportunity: The KPD and the Third Period, 1929-1933 // In Search of Revolution: International Communist Parties in the Third Period. Edited by Worley M. London, 2004, p. 38–64.

25. LaPorte N., Morgan K. ‘Kings among their subjects’? Ernst Thälmann, Harry Pollitt and the Leadership Cult as Stalinization // Bolshevism, Stalinism and the Comintern. Perspectives on Stalinization, 1917–53. Edited by Morgan K., Worley M., LaPorte N. London, 2008, p. 124–145.

26. Macintyre S. The New Line in the Antipodes: Australian Communists and Class Against Class // In Search of Revolution: International Communist Parties in the Third Period. Edited by Worley M. London, 2004, p. 247–269.

27. Manley J. Red or Yellow? Canadian Communists and the 'Long' Third Period, 1927-36 // In Search of Revolution: International Communist Parties in the Third Period. Edited by Worley M. London, 2004, p. 220–246.

28. Mcllroy J. Campbell A. Bolshevism, Stalinism and the Comintern: a historical controversy revisited // Labor History, 2019, vol. 60, issue 3, p. 165–192.

29. Mcllroy J., Campbell A. "Nina Ponomareva's Hats': The New Revisionism, the Communist International, and the Communist Parry of Great Britain, 1920-30 // Labour/Le Travail, 2002, №49, p. 147-187.

30. O’Connor E. From Bolshevism to Stalinism: Communism and the Comintern in Ireland // Bolshevism, Stalinism and the Comintern. Perspectives on Stalinization, 1917–53. Edited by Morgan K., Worley M., LaPorte N. London, 2008, p. 245–262.

31. Palmer B.D. Rethinking the historiography of United States Communism // American Communist History, 2003, №2, p. 139–173.

32. Pons S., Smith S.A. Introduction to Volume I // The Cambridge History of Communism. Volume I. World Revolution and Socialism in One Country 1917–1941. Edited by Pons S. and Smith S.A. Cambridge, 2017, p. 28-45.

33. Priestland D. Stalinism and the politics of mobilization: Ideas, power and terror in inter-war Russia. Oxford, 2007.

34. Rees T. 1936 // The Oxford handbook of the history of communism. Edited by Stephen A. Smith. Oxford, 2014, p. 126-140.

35. Rees T. The 'Good Bolsheviks': The Spanish Communist Party and the Third Period // In Search of Revolution: International Communist Parties in the Third Period. Edited by Worley M. London, 2004, p. 174–202.

36. Riddell J. The Comintern in 1922 // Historical Materialism, 2014, №22 (3–4), p. 52–103.

37. Rieber A.J. How Per sis tent Are Per sis tent Factors? // Russian foreign policy in the twenty- first century and the shadow of the past. Edited by Robert Legvold. New York, 2007, p. 205–278.

38. Ryan J. A Final Stab at Insurrection: The American Communist Party, 1928-34 // In Search of Revolution: International Communist Parties in the Third Period. Edited by Worley M. London, 2004, p. 203–219.

39. Saich T. The Chinese Communist Party During the Era of the Comintern (1919-1943). Scotts Valley, 2014.

40. Service R. Comrades! A history of world communism. Cambridge, 2007.

41. Smith S.A. Issues in Comintern Historiography // The Oxford handbook of the history of communism. Edited by Stephen A. Smith. Oxford, 2014, p. 195–203.

42. Smith S.A. Russia in revolution: An empire in crisis, 1890–1928. Oxford, 2017.

43. Steiner Z. The Lights That Failed: European International History 1919-1933. Oxford, 2005.

44. Storch R. Red Chicago: American Communism at its Grassroots, 1928–35. Urbana, 2007. URL: https://www.questia.com/library/journal/1P3-1995144921/red-chicago-american-communism-at-its-grassroots (access date 13.10.2020).

45. Stranahan P. The Chinese Communist Party During the Third Period, 1927-34 // In Search of Revolution: International Communist Parties in the Third Period. Edited by Worley M. London, 2004, p. 301–318.

46. Taylor K. The Communist Party of New Zealand and the Third Period, 1928-35 // In Search of Revolution: International Communist Parties in the Third Period. Edited by Worley M. London, 2004, p. 270–300.

47. Taylor K., Worley M. Testing the Limits: Stalinization and the New Zealand and British Communist Parties // Bolshevism, Stalinism and the Comintern. Perspectives on Stalinization, 1917–53. Edited by Morgan K., Worley M., LaPorte N. London, 2008, p. 226-244.

48. Worley M. Class against class: The Communist party in Britain between the wars London; New York, 2002.

49. Worley M. Courting Disaster? The Communist International in the Third Period // In Search of Revolution: International Communist Parties in the Third Period. Edited by Worley M. London, 2004, p. 1–17.

50. Worley M. To the Left and Back Again: The Communist Party of Great Britain in the Third Period // In Search of Revolution: International Communist Parties in the Third Period. Edited by Worley M. London, 2004, p. 65–87.

51. Wydra H. Communism and the Emergence of Democracy. Cambridge, 2006.

52. Zumoff J.A. The Communist International and U.S. Communism, 1919–1929. Chicago, 2015. URL: https://www.questia.com/library/journal/1G1-436982203/jacob-a-zumoff-the-communist-international-and-us (access date 23.10.2020).