The Italian Section of the Comintern, Stalin and the Russian Question

The verbatim record of a closed meeting between the General Secretary of the AUCP (b) and the Italian delegation which took place during VI Enlarged Plenum of the Comintern Executive Committee, 17 February to 15 March 1926, is kept in Moscow in the Russian State Archive of socio-political history (RGASPI). The source is translated by the author from Italian, published in Russian for the first time and is of academic interest, since it gives an opportunity to clarify the respective positions of Joseph Stalin and the Italian Communists, among whom Amadeo Bordiga stood out for his principled attitude. Contrary to the directives of the CPSU (b) delegation to the ECIC and the new Central Committee of the Italian Communist party, he consistently advocated transferring the discussion of the "Russian Question" to the ranks of the Communist International. The document reflects echoes of internal party disagreements on the key problems of building socialism in the USSR, concerning industry, trade, taxes, and policy towards the peasantry, as well as ambiguous assessments of the NEP. In addition, the organizational aspects of the Comintern's activities were touched upon: the conversation took place at a time when, after the successful "Bolshevization" of the national sections, a change in the leadership of the "headquarters of the world revolution" was gradually being prepared. It is difficult to call the judgments of the General Secretary of the AUCP (b) recorded verbatim as prepared in advance or formal: clarifying what was said, J. Stalin sometimes repeats himself, tries to be clear and convincing, while allowing some frank confessions. The future "great leader" is self-restrained and patient with his Italian comrades, except when, instead of answering a particularly acute question posed by A. Bordiga, he, a Communist and an atheist, has to call on the help of God himself.

Keywords

Italian Communist Party, Amadeo Bordiga, I. V. Stalin, Comintern, New Economic Policy (NEP)

Received

14.08.2020

Publication date

21.10.2020

Number of characters

58798

Cite

GOST	Terekhova N. The Italian Section of the Comintern, Stalin and “the Russian Question” // Novaia i noveishaia istoriia – 2020. – Issue 5 C. 111-127 [Electronic resource]. URL: https://nni.jes.su/S013038640011365-9-1 (circulation date: 26.04.2024). DOI: 10.31857/S013038640011365-9
MLA	Terekhova, Natalya "The Italian Section of the Comintern, Stalin and “the Russian Question”." Novaia i noveishaia istoriia 5 (2020):111-127. DOI: 10.31857/S013038640011365-9
APA	Terekhova N. (2020). The Italian Section of the Comintern, Stalin and “the Russian Question”. Novaia i noveishaia istoriia (5), pp.111-127 DOI: 10.31857/S013038640011365-9

100 rub.

When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 0, views: 801

Readers community rating: votes 0

1. Adibekov G. M., Shakhnazarova E. N., Shirinja K. K. Organizatsionnaja struktura Kominterna. 1919 – 1943 [Organizational structure of the Comintern. 1919–1943]. Мoskva, 1997. (In Russ.)

2. Ferrara М., Ferrara М. Beseduja s Togliatti [Conversation with Togliatti]. Мoskva, 1954. (In Russ.)

3. Firsov F. Komintern. Pogonja za prizrakom. Pereosmyslenie [Comintern. Ghost chase. Rethinking]. Мoskva, 2019. (In Russ.)

4. Firsov F. Sekrety Kommunisticheskogo Internatsionala. Shifroperepiska [The Secrets of the Communist International. Encrypted Correspondence]. Мoskva, 2011. (In Russ.)

5. Grigorieva I. V. Rossijskije stranitsy biografii Antonio Gramsci (1922-1926) v Archive Kominterna [The Russian biographical pages of Antonio Gramsci (1922–1926) in the Archives of Comintern] // Rossiia i Italiia. XX vek [Russia and Italy. ХХ century], vol. 3. Мoskva, 1998, р. 119–121. (In Russ.)

6. Gusev A. V. Osuscshestvil li Stalin programmu Trotskogo? – NEP: economicheskije, politicheskije i sotsiokul’turnye aspekty [Did Stalin implement Trotsky's program? – NEP: economic, political and socio-cultural aspects]. Moskva, 2006. (In Russ.)

7. Kobyljanskij К. V. Velikij Oktjabr i revolutsionnoje dvigenije v Italii [Great October and the Revolutionary movement in Italy (1917–1921)]. Мoskva, 1968. (In Russ.)

8. Komintern i ideja mirovoj revolutsii: dokumenty. Otv. red. K. M. Anderson, A. O. Chubar'ian. Avtor vstup. statyi Ia. S. Drabkin [Komintern and the Idea of the World Revolution: documents]. Resp. edited by K. M. Anderson, A. O. Chubarian. The author of the introductory article is Ya. S. Drabkin. Мoskva, 1998. (In Russ.)

9. Lisovskij P. A. Italjanskaja kommunisticheskaja partija i Komintern (1921-1929) [Italian Communist Party and the Comintern (1921 – 1929)] // Italiia i Evropa [Italy and Europe]. Vol. II. Мoskva, 1990, р. 355. (In Russ.)

10. Ljubin V. P. Sotsialisty v istorii Italii. ISP i ee nasledniki 1892 – 2006 [Socialists in the History of Italy. ISP and its heirs 1892 – 2006]. Moskva, 2007. (In Russ.)

11. Mitelman I. D. N. I. Bukharin i Komintern [N. I. Bukharin and the Comintern]. Мoskva, 1989. (In Russ.)

12. Stalin I. V. Sochinenija [Works], vol. 8. Мoskva, 1948. (In Russ.)

13. Suzdaltsev I. A. Ob osobennostjakh perenesenija voprosa o vnutropartijnoj discussii v RKP (b) v Komintern v 1924 g. [On the Peculiarities of Transmitting in 1924 the Question of Inner-Party Discussion of the RCP (b) into the Comintern] // Vestnik Moskovskogo gosudarstvennogo oblastnogo universiteta. Seriia: Istoriia i politicheskie nauki [Bulletin of Moscow Region State University. Series: History and Politic Sciences], 2017, № 5, р. 154–162. (In Russ.)

14. Vatlin А. Yu. Gosudarstvennye interesy v internatsionalistskoj upakovke: vneshnjaja politika SSSR i Komintern vo vtoroj polovine 1920-kh godov [State interests in internationalist packaging: Foreign policy of the USSR and the Comintern in the second half of the 1920s.] // Istorija stalinizma: itogi i problemy izuchenija. Materialy mezhdunarodnoj nauchnoj konferentsii [The history of Stalinism: results and problems of study. Materials of the International scientific conference]. Мoskva, 2008, р. 184, 187, 193. (In Russ.)

15. Vatlin А. Yu. Komintern: idei, reshenija, sud’by [The Comintern: ideas, decisions, destiny]. Мoskva, 2009. (In Russ.)

16. Vatlin А. Yu. Vneshnja politika i Komintern 1921–1929 [Foreign policy and the Comintern. 1921–1929] // Rossija nepovskaja [Russia during the NEP]. Мoskva, 2002, р. 332, 335–337. (In Russ.)

17. Vatlin А. Yu. Vtoroj congress Kominterna: tochka otscheta v istorii mirovogo kommunisma [Second Comintern Congress: a reference point for the history of world communism]. Мoskva, 2018. (In Russ.)

18. Agosti A. Palmiro Togliatti. Torino, 1996.

19. Berti G. I primi dieci anni del Partito comunista italiano. – Annali Feltrinelli. Istituto Giangiacomo Feltrinelli. Milano, 1966, p. 258.

20. Bocca G. Togliatti. Milаno, 2014.

21. Grilli L. Amadeo Bordiga: capitalismo sovietico e comunismo. Milano, 1982.

22. Spriano P. Storia del Partito comunista italiano, vol. 1–5. Torino, 1967–1969.

23. Terekhova N. L’Ottobre in Italia: Serrati, Bordiga, Gramsci // 1917 Ottobre rosso. La rivoluzione russa: i fatti, i protagonisti, il mito. Milano, 2017, p. 127–135.

24. Terekhova N. Togliatti, l’amico dimenticato. Il leader comunista nella storiografia sovietica e in quella russa // Nuova Storia Contemporanea, 2014, № 2, p. 115–132.