Insiders Among Outsiders: Representation of Enemies and Allies in the Texts of British Prisoners of War on the Iberian Peninsula 1808—1814

The article is devoted to the peculiarities of the perception of enemies and allies by the British combatants who found themselves in French captivity during the war on the Iberian Peninsula in 1808—1814. The undertaken analysis of sources, including both British officers’ published memoirs, letters and diaries and the manuscript of the British soldier’s memoirs, demonstrated the multidimensionality of the images of the Spaniards and the French in the British “captivity narratives”. The authors of such narratives tended to dwell not only on the positive characteristics of the French, such their politeness or gallantry, but also on their cruelty towards the locals, as well as the tendency of French soldiers to theft and looting. The image of the Spaniards in the British “captivity narratives” on the contrary turns out to be more complimentary than in other sources left by British soldiers who were not captured. In the POWs’ texts the Spaniards are presented as good-natured and hospitable, but their two qualities — cruelty and religious fanaticism — reduce the locals from the British point of view to semi-civilized people.

Keywords

Napoleonic Wars, image of the “Other”, imagology, prisoners of war, enemies, allies, Peninsular War, “captivity narrative”

Acknowledgment

The study is sponsored by the Russian Science Foundation, project № 21-78-00078 “Images of Enemy and Ally in Reception of the British Participants of the Military Campaigns in the West Mediterranean and the Pyrenees 1793—1814”.

Received

15.04.2022

Publication date

31.01.2023

Number of characters

45256

Cite

GOST	Kosykh T. “Insiders Among Outsiders”: Representation of Enemies and Allies in the Texts of British Prisoners of War on the Iberian Peninsula 1808—1814 // ISTORIYA – 2023. – V. 14. – Issue 1 (123) [Electronic resource]. URL: https://history.jes.su/S207987840023841-4-1 (circulation date: 25.07.2024). DOI: 10.18254/S207987840023841-4
MLA	Kosykh, Tatiana "“Insiders Among Outsiders”: Representation of Enemies and Allies in the Texts of British Prisoners of War on the Iberian Peninsula 1808—1814." ISTORIYA 14.1 (123) (2023) DOI: 10.18254/S207987840023841-4
APA	Kosykh T. (2023). “Insiders Among Outsiders”: Representation of Enemies and Allies in the Texts of British Prisoners of War on the Iberian Peninsula 1808—1814. ISTORIYA 14(1 (123)) DOI: 10.18254/S207987840023841-4

100 rub.

When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 0, views: 105

Readers community rating: votes 0

1. Vul'f L. Izobretaya Vostochnuyu Evropu: Karta tsivilizatsii v soznanii ehpokhi Prosvescheniya / per. s angl. I. Fedyukina. M., 2003.

2. Kosykh T. Africa Begins at the Pyrenees? The Experience of Cross-Cultural Contact of British Soldiers in Andalusia 1810—1812 // ISTORIYA. 2021. Vol. 12. Is. 7 (105). URL: https://history.jes.su/s207987840015315-5-1/ DOI: 10.18254/S207987840015315-5

3. Forrest A. Za kromkoj polya boya. Zhizn' voennykh vo vremena Revolyutsionnykh i Napoleonovskikh vojn. M., 2022.

4. Blayney A. T. Narrative of a Forced Journey through Spain and France, as a Prisoner of War, in the Years 1810 to 1814. 2 vols. L., 1814.

5. Boswell J. Life of Johnson / ed. by R. W. Chapman. Oxford, 1998.

6. Carleton G. Memoirs of Captain George Carleton, an English Officer. L., 1811.

7. Chamberlain P. Hell Upon Water: Prisoners of War in Britain, 1793—1815. Michigan, 2010.

8. Chamberlain P. Prisoners of War in the Peninsula, 1808—1814 // The Peninsular War: Aspects of the Struggle for the Iberian Peninsula / ed. by I. Fletcher. Padstow, 1998. P. 131—147.

9. Clímaco S., Guardado da Silva C. Prisioneiros portugueses em França durante a Guerra Peninsular // XXII Colóquio de História Militar: Portugal na Guerra Peninsular: 1812—1815: Do cerco de Ciudad Rodrigo ao Congresso de Viena: o caminho para a derrocada do Império Napoleónico: Actas. Lisboa, 2014. P. 337—363.

10. Colley L. Perceiving Low Literature: The Captivity Narrative // Essays in Criticism. A Quarterly Journal founded by F.W. Bateson. July 2003. № 3. P. 199—218.

11. Croker R. Travels through Several Provinces of Spain and Portugal. L., 1799.

12. Daly G. The British Soldier in the Peninsular War: Encounters with Spain and Portugal. Basingstoke, 2013.

13. Duché E. Captives in Plantations: British Prisoners of War and Visions of Slavery in Napoleonic France and Mauritius // French History and Civilization. Papers from the 20th George Rudé Seminar, July 13—16, 2016 / ed. by J. Kalman. Vol. 7. 2017. P. 108—124.

14. Duché E. A Passage to Imprisonment: The British Prisoners of War in Verdun under the First French Empire. University of Warwick, 2014.

15. Esdaile Ch. All Roads lead to Verdun: British Prisoner of War in the Peninsular War, 1808–1814 // Revista Universitaria de Historia Militar. 2020. Vol. 9. № 18. P. 109—132.

16. Fraser E. Napoleon the Gaoler: Personal Experiences and Adventures of British Sailors and Soldiers During the Great Captivity. N. Y., 1914.

17. Kennedy K. Narratives of the Revolutionary and Napoleonic Wars: Military and Civilian Experience in Britain and Ireland. L., 2013.

18. Knight R. Britain against Napoleon: The Organization of Victory, 1793—1815. L., 2014.

19. Larpent F. S. The Private Journal of Judge-Advocate Larpent: Attached to the Head-quarters of Lord Wellington During the Peninsular War, from 1812 to Its Close / ed. by Sir G. Larpent. L., 1854.

20. Morieux R. The Society of Prisoners: Anglo-French Wars and Incarceration in the Eighteenth Century. Oxford, 2019.

21. The Napoleonic-War Journal of Captain Thomas Henry Browne, 1807—1816 / ed. by R. Buckley. L., 1987.

22. A Prisoner of Albuera — The Journal of Major William Brooke from May 18 to September 28, 1811 // Studies in the Napoleonic Wars / ed. by Sir Ch. Oman. L., 1929. P. 175—206.

23. A Prisoner of France. The Memoirs, Diary, and Correspondence of Charles Boothby, Captain Royal Engineers, During his last Campaign. L., 1898.

24. Şakul K. What happened to Pouqueville’s Frenchmen? Ottoman treatment of the French Prisoners during the War of the Second Coalition (1798—1802) // Turkish Historical Review. № 3. 2012. P. 168—195.

25. Sherer M. Recollections of the Peninsular. L., 1824.

26. Story W. A Journal Kept in France, During a Captivity of More than Nine Years, Commencing The 14th Day of April, 1805, and Ending The 5th Day of May, 1814. Sunderland, 1815.

27. Sturt Ch. The Real State of France in the Year 1809; with the Account of the Treatment of the Prisoner of War, and Persons otherwise Detained in France. L., 1810.

28. Warre W. Letters from the Peninsula, 1808—1812 / ed. by E. Warre, D. D., C. B., M. V. O. L., 1909.

29. Zozaya M. Prisioneros españoles en la Francia napoleónica. El modelo positivo de los espacios de cautiverio de los suboficiales, a través del diario de José Mª Román (1808—1900) // Trocadero: Revista de historia moderna y contemporanea. 2014. № 26. P. 75—106.