Art without an Artist: On the Question of the Criteria of Contemporary Art

The article raises the question of the authorship of works of contemporary art, the institutional nature and socio-economic conditions of its production, as well as the spatial and media-aesthetic mediations of its perception. The main research problem is formulated at the intersection of two questions: is everything that artists produce may be considered art? And: are artists the only authors of the works they signed? The problem is the appearance of a commodity form for works of contemporary art, which does not interfere with them, but, on the contrary, becomes a condition for their social and cultural legitimation, recognition in the context of the history of world art, i.e. museumification. In addition, the article discusses: The ontological status of art objects produced by contemporary artists or, more precisely, by the entire industry and contemporary art market; a specific way of their impact on a person, which, as a purely aesthetic, is abstracted from other channels of sensory and existential experience; and: The integral artistic experience of being-with-art or in-art of spectators and artists, its structure and essence. The methodological approach to the phenomenon of contemporary art developed in the article simultaneously criticizes the positions of aesthetic nominalism and realism, relying on the vocabulary and tools of the theory of art by Walter Benjamin and Russian constructivism. As an alternative to the currently dominant criteria for evaluating works of contemporary art (for example, by T. de Duve), the authors propose an original theory of the Russian left avant-garde with the central concepts of the artistic “thing-comrade” and the collective author-producer.

Keywords

Benjamin, aura, aesthetic experience, readymade, Campbell's Soup, T. de Duve, industrial art, constructivism

Received

21.11.2023

Publication date

23.11.2023

Number of characters

26850

Cite

GOST	Chubarov I., Samokhvalova E. Art without an Artist: On the Question of the Criteria of Contemporary Art // Chelovek – 2023. – V. 34. – Issue 5 C. 130-148 [Electronic resource]. URL: https://chelovek-journal.ru/S023620070028506-3-1 (circulation date: 17.05.2024). DOI: 10.31857/S023620070028506-3
MLA	Chubarov, Igor M, Samokhvalova, Elina V "Art without an Artist: On the Question of the Criteria of Contemporary Art." Chelovek 34.5 (2023):130-148. DOI: 10.31857/S023620070028506-3
APA	Chubarov I., Samokhvalova E. (2023). Art without an Artist: On the Question of the Criteria of Contemporary Art. Chelovek 34(5), pp.130-148 DOI: 10.31857/S023620070028506-3

100 rub.

When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 0, views: 65

Readers community rating: votes 0

1. Agamben G. Tvorenie i anarkhiya: Proizvedenie v epokhu kapitalisticheskoi religii [Creazione e anarchia. L’opera nell’età della religione capitalista]. Transl. from Ital. by N. Okhotin et al. Moscow: Gileya Publ., 2021.

2. Anashvili V. Simvoly v iskusstve: religioznyĭ, istoricheskiĭ i kul'turnyĭ kontekst [Symbols in Art: Religious, Historical and Cultural Context]. Moscow: Izdatel'skii dom «Delo» RANHiGS Publ., 2022.

3. Benjamin W. Proizvedenie iskusstva v epokhu ego tekhnicheskoi vosproizvodimosti [A Work of Art in the Era of its Technical Reproducibility]. Transl. from Germ. by I. Boldyrev, A. Belobratov et al. Uchenie o podobii. Mediaesteticheskie proizvedeniia [Doctrine of the Similar. Mediaesthetic Works]. Moscow: RSUH Publ., 2012. P. 189–235.

4. Benjamin W. Uchenie o podobii [Doctrine of the Similar]. Transl. from Germ. by I. Boldyrev, A. Belobratov et al. Uchenie o podobii. Mediaesteticheskie proizvedeniia [Doctrine of the Similar. Mediaesthetic Works]. Moscow: RSUH Publ., 2012. P. 163–170.

5. Benjamin W. O nekotorykh motivakh u Bodlera [On Some of Baudelaire's Motives]. Transl. from French and Germ., comp., preface and note by A. Belobratov. Maski vremeni [Masks of Time]. Moscow: Symposium Publ., 2004.

6. Benjamin W. Ozareniya [Illuminationen]. Transl. from Germ. by N.M. Bernovskaya, Yu.A. Danilov, S.A. Romashko. Moscow: Martis Publ., 2000.

7. Brik O. Hudozhnik-proletarii [Proletarian the Artist]. Iskusstvo kommuny [Communal Art]. 1918. N 2. P. 25–26.

8. De Duve T. Imenem iskusstva. K arkheologii sovremennosti [In the Name of Art. Toward the Archeology of Moderity]. Transl. from French by A. Shestakov. Moscow: HSE Publishing House Publ., 2014.

9. Deleuze G. Chto takoe akt tvoreniya? [What is the act of creation?] URL: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PMhdr3YoMEE. (date of access: 25.07.2022).

10. Joselit D. Posle iskusstva [After Art]. Moscow: V-A-C Publ., 2017.

11. Zuboff Sh. Epokha nadzornogo kapitalizma [The Age of Surveillance Capitalism]. Moscow: Izdatel'stvo Instituta Gaidara Publ., 2022.

12. McLuhan, H. M. Ponimanie media [Understanding Media: The Extensions of Man] Moscow: Kuchkovo Pole Publ., 2019.

13. Ot kartiny k fotografii: vizual'naya kul'tura XIX–XX vekov [From Painting to Photography: Visual Culture of the XIX–XX centuries. Anthology]. Moscow: Ad Marginem Press Publ., 2020.

14. Srnichek N. Kapitalizm platform [Platform Capitalism]. Transl. from English, ed. by M. Dobryakova. Moscow: HSE Publishing House Publ., 2019.

15. Chubarov I. Kollektivnaya chuvstvennost': Teorii i praktiki levogo avangarda [Collective Sensibility: Theories and Practices of the Left Avant-Garde]. Moscow: HSE Publishing House Publ., 2014.

16. Benjamin W. Goethes Wahlverwandschaften. Neue deutsche Beiträge. Hrsg, von H. von Hofmannsthal. München, 1925. II, 2.

17. Benjamin W. Gesammelte Schriften, Bd. I–VII, unter Mitwirkung von Theodor W. Adorno und Gershom Scholem hg. von Tiedemann, Rolf/Schweppenhäuser, Hermann, Frankfurt/M., 1972–1989.

18. Bourdon D. Warhol. New York: Abradale press: Abrams, 1991.

19. Clark M. NFTs, explained. The Verge. Jun 6, 2022. URL: https://www.theverge.com/22310188/nft-explainer-what-is-blockchain-crypto-art-faq (дата обращения: 29.07.2023).

20. Danto A., De Duve T., Shusterman R. Autour du «monde de l'art». Cahiers philosophiques. 2012. N 4/131. P. 108–128. URL: https://www.cairn.info/revue-cahiers-philosophiques1-2012-4-page-108.htm (date of access: 29.07.2023).

21. Hegel G.W.F. Werke. Vollständige Ausgabe durch einen Verein von Freunden des Verewigten. Bd. 9: Vorlesungen über die Philosophie der Geschichte. Berlin, 1837.

22. Kramer S. Walter Benjamin, Zur Einführung. Junius Verlag GmbH, 2003.

23. Levy A., Scott-Clark, C. Warhol's box of tricks. The Guardian. Sat. 21. Aug. 2010. URL: https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/2010/aug/21/warhol-brillo-boxes-scandal-fraud (date of access: 29.07.2023).