Ethical Aspects of Ventilator Triage During the COVID-19 Pandemic

The article deals with the issues related to mechanical ventilation triage of critically ill patients during the current pandemic of COVID-19. A brief overview of the guidelines recently published in the United States and Europe is presented. The author points out at the sociocultural variability on the necessity and duration of ventilation, closely related to resources, which influence the approaches to triage. The principles and criteria for selecting critically ill patients to be admitted to intensive care units during the pandemic are analysed in comparison with regular situations. In particular, the principles of “first come — first served” and saving the maximum number of lives are considered. Special attention is paid to the problem of forced withdrawal of life support. If just a few decades ago weaning from mechanical ventilation was considered an act of killing, prohibited by both law and ethics, by now, long before the pandemic outbreak, the attitudes towards this procedure have begun to change. Under the extreme circumstances of the pandemic, some openly believe that withdrawing a ventilator from one patient for the sake of another is not an act of killing. The question about decision-makers is also raised. The author outlines two positions on to whom the responsibility for rationing scarce ventilators is recommended to be assigned. The first approach presumes that this responsibility has to be undertaken by intensivists directly involved in patient care, whereas the second one ascribes it to triage officers and committees who do not contact critically ill patients. The paper also discusses the risks of an utilitarian approach to triage, leading to implicit discrimination against the elderly and people with disabilities, including chronic critical patients on long-term mechanical ventilation in nursing homes or LTAC hospitals. The conclusion points to the conflict between the ethical principles of mercy and equity. Finally, the question is raised about the acceptability and limits of institutionalizing and algorithmizing life-and-death ethical choices regarding individual patients or population groups.

Keywords

pandemic, triage, critical patients, resource allocation, exclusion criteria, intensive care unit, mechanical ventilation

Received

23.12.2020

Publication date

23.12.2020

Number of characters

24414

Cite

GOST	Patrakova A. Ethical Aspects of Ventilator Triage During the COVID-19 Pandemic // Chelovek – 2020. – V. 31. – Issue №6 C. 165-180 [Electronic resource]. URL: https://chelovek-journal.ru/S023620070013089-4-1 (circulation date: 16.04.2024). DOI: 10.31857/S023620070013089-4
MLA	Patrakova, Alina P. "Ethical Aspects of Ventilator Triage During the COVID-19 Pandemic." Chelovek 31.6 (2020):165-180. DOI: 10.31857/S023620070013089-4
APA	Patrakova A. (2020). Ethical Aspects of Ventilator Triage During the COVID-19 Pandemic. Chelovek 31(6), pp.165-180 DOI: 10.31857/S023620070013089-4

100 rub.

When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 0, views: 829

Readers community rating: votes 0

1. Bledsoe T.A., Ward N.S., Levy М.M. Eticheskiye principy v medicine kriticheskih sostoyaniy [Ethical Principles in Critical Care Medicine]. Rukovodstvo po kriticheskoi meditsine [Textbook of Critical Care], ed. by J.-L. Vincent. St. Petersburg: Chelovek Publ., 2019. Vol. 2. P. 1726–1730.

2. Lidov I.P., Lobanov G.P. Sortirovka medicinskaya [Medical Triage]. BME [Great Medical Encyclopaedia], ed. by B. V. Petrovskiy. 3rd ed. Мoscow: Sovetskaya Entsiklopediya Publ., 1984. Vol. 23. P. 528–531.

3. Pivina L.M., Alibayeva G.A., Dyusupov A.A. et al. Sistema medicinskoy sortirovki bolnyh (triage) pri okazanii neotlozhnoy pomoshhi: obzor literatury [Triage in Emergency Care Medicine: Literature Review]. Nauka i zdravookhranenie. 2018. N 1. P. 70–84.

4. Rubenfeld G.D. Raspredelenie resursov v otdelenii intensivnoy terapii [Resource Allocation in the Intensive Care Unit]. Rukovodstvo po kriticheskoi meditsine [Textbook of Critical Care], ed. by J.-L. Vincent. St. Petersburg: Chelovek Publ., 2019. Vol. 2. P. 1718–1725.

5. Antommaria A.H., Gibb T.S., McGuire A.L. et al. Ventilator Triage Policies During the COVID-19 Pandemic at U.S. Hospitals Associated with Members of the Association of Bioethics Program Directors. Annals of Internal Medicine. 2020. Vol. 173, iss. 3. P. 188–195. DOI:10.7326/M20-1738

6. Baker M., Fink S. At the Top of the Covid-19 Curve, How Do Hospitals Decide Who Gets Treatment? URL: https://www.nytimes.com/ 2020/03/31/us/coronavirus-covid-triage-rationing-ventilators.html (date of access: 30.06.2020).

7. Beall A. The Heart-Wrenching Choice of Who Lives and Dies. URL: https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20200428-coronavirus-how-doctors-choose-who-lives-and-dies (date of access: 30.06.2020).

8. Biller-Andorno N, Biller A. Algorithm-Aided Prediction of Patient Preferences — an Ethics Sneak Peek. New England Journal of Medicine. 2019. Vol. 381, N 15. P. 1480–1485.

9. Dutzmann J., Hartog C., Janssens U. et al. Entscheidungen über die Zuteilung von Ressourcen in der Notfall — und der Intensivmedizin im Kontext der COVID-19-Pandemie. URL: https://www.divi.de/empfehlungen/ publikationen-alt/covid-19/1549-entscheidungen-ueber-die-zuteilung-intensivmedizinischer-ressourcen-im-kontext-der-covid-19-pandemie-klinisch-ethische-empfehlungen/file (date of access: 30.06.2020).

10. Emanuel E.J., Persad G., Upshur R. et al. Fair Allocation of Scarce Medical Resources in the Time of Covid-19. The New England Journal of Medicine. 2020. Vol. 382, N 21. P. 2049–2055. DOI:10.1056/NEJMsb2005114

11. Gold A., Strous R.D. Second Thoughts About Who is First: The Medical Triage of Violent Perpetrators and Their Victims. Journal of Medical Ethics. 2017. Vol. 43. P. 293–300. DOI: 10.1136/medethics-2016-103496

12. Haas L.E. M., Lange D.W. de, Dijk D. van et al. Should We Deny ICU Admission to the Elderly? Ethical Considerations in Times of COVID-19. Critical Care. 2020. Vol. 24, N 321. P. 1–3. DOI: 10.1186/s13054-020-03050-x

13. Hick J.L., Barbera J.A., Kelen G.D. Refining Surge Capacity: Conventional, Contingency, and Crisis Capacity. Disaster Medicine and Public Health Preparedness. 2009. Vol. 3, Suppl. 2. P. 59–67. DOI: 10.1097/DMP.0b013e31819f1ae2

14. Joebges S., Biller-Andorno N. Ethics Guidelines on COVID-19 Triage – an Emerging International Consensus. Critical Care. 2020. Vol. 24, N 201. P. 1–5. DOI:10.1186/s13054-020-02927-1

15. Meyfroidt G., Vlieghe E., Biston P. et al. Ethical Principles Concerning Proportionality of Critical Care during the 2020 COVID19 Pandemic in Belgium: Advice by the Belgian Society of Intensive care medicine. (Update 26-03-2020). URL: http://www.siz.be/wp-content/uploads/COVID_19_ ethical_E_rev3.pdf (date of access: 30.06.2020).

16. NICE. COVID-19 Rapid Guideline: Critical Care in Adults. URL: https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/NG159 (date of access: 30.06.2020).

17. OEGARI. Allokation intensivmedizinischer Ressourcen aus Anlass der Covid 19 Pandemie. URL: https://www.oegari.at/web_ files/cms_daten/covid-19_ressourcenallokation_garistatement_v1.7_final_2020-03-17.pdf (date of access: 30.06.2020).

18. Peterson A., Owen A.M., Weijer C. Is It Ethical for Forcibly Withdraw Ventilators from Nursing Home Patients for Reallocation to Covid-19 Patients? Journal of Medical Ethics blog. URL: https://blogs.bmj.com/medical-ethics/2020/04/27/is-it-ethical-to-forcibly-withdraw-ventilators-from-nursing-home-patients-for-reallocation-to-covid-19-patients/ (date of access: 30.06.2020).

19. Peterson A., Largent E.A., Hart E. et al. Ethics of Reallocating Ventilators in the Covid-19 Pandemic. BMJ. 2020. Vol. 369, N 1828. P. 1–4. DOI: 10.1136/bmj.m1828

20. Rosenbaum L. Facing Covid-19 in Italy — Ethics, Logistics, and Therapeutics on the Epidemic Front Line. The New England Journal of Medicine. 2020. Vol. 382. P. 1873–1875.

21. SAMW. COVID-19 Pandemic: Triage for Intensive-Care Treatment under Resource Scarcity. URL: https://www.samw.ch/de/Ethik/Themen-A-bis-Z/Intensivmedizin.html (date of access: 30.06.2020).

22. Sprung Ch.L., Joynt G.M., Christian M.D. et al. Adult ICU Triage During the Coronavirus Disease 2019 Pandemic: Who Will Live and Who Will Die? Recommendations to Improve Survival. Critical Care Medicine. 2020. [Advance online publication]. P. 1–7. DOI: 10.1097/CCM.0000000000004410

23. Truog R.D., Mitchell C., Daley G.Q. The Toughest Triage – Allocating Ventilators in a Pandemic. The New England Journal of Medicine. 2020. Vol. 382, N 21. P. 1973–1975. DOI: 10.1056/NEJMp2005689.

24. Ventilator Allocation Guidelines. Albany: New York State Task Force on Life and the Law, New York State Department of Health, November 2015. URL: https://www.health.ny.gov/regulations/task_force/reports_publications/ docs/ventilator_guidelines.pdf (date of access: 30.06.2020).

25. Vergano M., Bertolini G., Giannini A. et al. Clinical Ethics Recommendation for the Allocation of Intensive Care Treatments in Exceptional, Resource-Limited Circumstances. URL: http://www.siaarti.it/SiteAssets/ News/COVID19%20-%20documenti%20SIAARTI/SIAARTI%20-%20Covid-19%20-%20Clinical%20Ethics%20Reccomendations.pdf (date of access: 30.06.2020).

26. Wunsch H. Mechanical Ventilation in COVID-19: Interpreting the Current Epidemiology. American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine. 2020. Vol. 202, N 1. P. 1–4. DOI: 10.1164/rccm.202004-1385ED