A Person in a Totalitarian State. Article Two. Heroism in War

Occupation: Chief Research Fellow, Head of the Philosophy of Culture Sector
Affiliation:
RAS Institute of Philosophy
Yaroslav-the-Wise Novgorod State University
Address: 12/1 Goncharnaya Str., Moscow 109240, Russian Federation

Journal name

Chelovek

Edition

Volume 31 Issue №3

Pages

135-154

Abstract

Heroism — a quality, ability and virtue — was one of the decisive factors of the Soviet military victory. But it would be wrong to consider it itself, in isolation from the general characteristics of the Great Patriotic war, not only as a people's war, but also as being waged by one totalitarian state against another. In this quality there inevitably appeared the traces of Stalinist totalitarianism of peacetime. Caught up in the war, Soviet people “went from hell to hell” and were often forced to show heroism, forced by man-made circumstances, forced by fear, compensating for mistakes and inhumanity, which is the result of Stalin's totalitarian evil. And if the Soviet soldiers were characterized only by this forced heroism, then, faced with the fascist heroism, which originated from the thirst for profit, discipline and duty, it would be hardly possible to win. The main reason for the Soviet soldier was a free heroism, which showed itself outside of totalitarian actions and ideology, and after the war did not immediately break out. Free military heroism had its origins. They are in the good that has ever fallen to everyone in life. For someone, the most important, the first source of heroism was the mother, family, home. For another, it is the perceived meanings and values of a great culture. For someone — loyalty to the oath and professional duty. For another one — the values and meanings of Christianity. What in reality was the correlation between the forced and free heroism, it is impossible to say. Just as it is impossible to evaluate what in the victorious end was the result of the fear of the barrage squad behind the soldiers’ back or the power of love, pushing forward into the enemy fire

Keywords

totalitarianism, man, army, war, heroism, love, duty, fear

Received

24.03.2020

Publication date

30.06.2020

Number of characters

41951

Cite

GOST	Nickolsky S. A Person in a Totalitarian State. Article Two. Heroism in War // Chelovek – 2020. – V. 31. – Issue №3 C. 135-154 [Electronic resource]. URL: https://chelovek-journal.ru/S023620070009570-4-1 (circulation date: 19.04.2024). DOI: 10.31857/S023620070009570-4
MLA	Nickolsky, Sergey A "A Person in a Totalitarian State. Article Two. Heroism in War." Chelovek 31.3 (2020):135-154. DOI: 10.31857/S023620070009570-4
APA	Nickolsky S. (2020). A Person in a Totalitarian State. Article Two. Heroism in War. Chelovek 31(3), pp.135-154 DOI: 10.31857/S023620070009570-4

100 rub.

When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 0, views: 893

Readers community rating: votes 0

1. Alexievich S.A. U vojny ne zhenskoe litso [The Unwomanly Face of War]. Мoscow: Vremya Publ., 2013.

2. Alexievich S.A. Vremya sekond hend [Second-hand Time]. Мoscow: Vremya Publ., 2013.

3. Arendt H. Istoki totalitarizma [The Origins of Totalitarianism]. Мoscow: CentrKom Publ., 1996.

4. Astafyev V.P. Moya voina. Pisatel' v okopah. Vojna glazami soldata [My War. Writer in the Trenches. War Through the Eyes of a Soldier]. Мoscow: ТD Algorithm Publ., 2012.

5. Astafyev V.P. Pastuh i pastushka [Shepherd and Shepherdess]. Мoscow: Knizhnaya palata Publ., 1996.

6. Astafyev V.P. Proklyaty i ubity [The Cursed and the Slain]. Мoscow: Eksmo Publ., 2007.

7. Beshanov V.V. Brestskaya krepost' [The Brest Fortress]. Мoscow: Yauza: Eksmo Publ., 2009.

8. Bykov V.V. Dozhit' do rassveta [To Live till Sunrise]. Мoscow: Eksmo Publ., 2010.

9. Bykov K.V. Poslednii triumf vermahta. Har'kovskii kotel [The Last Triumph of the Wehrmacht. The Kharkiv Boiler]. Мoscow: Yauza-press Publ., 2009.

10. Grossman V.S. Zhizn' i sud'ba [Life and Fate]. Kharkiv; Belgorod: Book Club “Family Leisure Club” Publ., 2016.

11. Neretina, S.S., Nikolsky S.A., Porus V.N. Filosofskaya antropologiya Andreya Platonova [Philosophical Anthropology of Andrey Platonov]. Мoscow: PAS Institute of Philosophy Publ., 2019.

12. Nikolsky S.A. Chelovek v totalitarnom gosudarstve. Voina i strah [A Person in a Totalitarian State. Article One. War and Fear]. Chelovek. 2020. Vol. 31, N 2. P. 128–149.

13. Nikolsky S.A., Mozhegov V. Rets. na kn.: Rybas S.Yu. Stalin (Moskva, 2009) [Book review: Rybas S.Yu. Stalin (Moscow, 2009)]. Voprosy filosofii. 2010. N 10. P. 163–166.

14. Platonov A.P. Chevengur. Kotlovan [Chevengur. The Foundation Pit], ed. by N.M. Malygina. Moscow: Vremya Publ., 2011. (Ser.: Sobranie sochinenii Platonova [Collected works of Platonov]).

15. Solonin M.S. Kak Sovetskii Soyuz pobedil v voine [How the Soviet Union Won the Great Patriotic War]. Moscow: Yauza-catalog Publ., 2018.

16. Hlevnyuk O.V. Sovetskaya ekonomicheskaya politika na rubezhe 1940–1950-h godov i “delo Gosplana” [Soviet Economic Policy at the Turn of 1940–1950's and “the Case of the State Planning Commission”]. Otechestvennaya istoriya. 2001. N 3.

17. Speer A. Tretii reih iznutri. Vospominaniya reihsministra voennoi promyshlennosti. 1930–1945 [Inside the Third Reich, Memoirs], transl. from Germ. by S. Lisogorskii. Moscow: Tsentrpoligraf Publ., 2005.

18. Gvardii serzhant i kapitanskaya dochka. Torzhestvo social'noi spravedlivosti [Guard Sergeant and Captain's Daughter. Celebration of Social Justice]. Livejournel. 2015. Nov. 7. URL: https://kineska.livejournal.com/203521.html (date of access: 27.03.2020).