Caricatures of Scientists: Problems of Source Analysis

This article analyzes different methodological approaches in the studies of caricatures of scientists. Satirical drawings are discussed as important sources for the history of science: they reveal little-explored episodes from the scientists’ life; shed some light on the scientists’ psychological, social, and professional characteristics; and influence public opinion even though more indirectly than written documents do. It is shown that their completeness and fairness vary significantly but all of these caricatures have a number of common characteristics such as hidden meaning, emphasis on various features of their subjects’ appearance or character traits, and abundance of meaningful details. Caricatures not only evoke smiles but also help understand whether scientific discoveries were accepted or opposed by society. The analysis of artistic devices used by the caricaturists allows to determine their ideological focus, emotional impact, and power of conviction. The article offers examples of how the caricatures in printed media played an important role in the emergence of myths about scientists and their discoveries. Therefore the historians of science need to decipher the images in the caricatures and elucidate the motives for creating them. Visual sources, presented and analyzed in this paper, were found to be unique in their message, artistic devices, theme, and emotional impact, and therefore were reviewed as complementary sources of information that demand additional resources for their deciphering.

Keywords

science studies, caricatures, scientist’s image, perception of science by society

Publication date

23.09.2022

Number of characters

45604

Cite

GOST	Fando R. Caricatures of Scientists: Problems of Source Analysis // Voprosy istorii estestvoznaniia i tekhniki – 2022. – V. 43. – Issue 3 C. 490-512 [Electronic resource]. URL: https://vietmag.org/S020596060021608-0-1 (circulation date: 28.04.2024). DOI: 10.31857/S020596060021608-0
MLA	Fando, Roman "Caricatures of Scientists: Problems of Source Analysis." Voprosy istorii estestvoznaniia i tekhniki 43.3 (2022):490-512. DOI: 10.31857/S020596060021608-0
APA	Fando R. (2022). Caricatures of Scientists: Problems of Source Analysis. Voprosy istorii estestvoznaniia i tekhniki 43(3), pp.490-512 DOI: 10.31857/S020596060021608-0

100 rub.

When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 0, views: 302

Readers community rating: votes 0

1. Arnold-Foster, T. (2022) Rethinking the Scopes Trial: Cultural Conflict, Media Spectacle, and Circus Politics, Journal of American Studies, vol. 56, iss. 1, pp. 142‒166.

2. Barysheva, E. V. (2020) “V veselom grokhote, v ogniakh i zvonakh”. Sovetskii prazdnik v sotsialʼnom konstruirovanii novogo obshchestva [“In a Cheerful Roar, in Lights and Ringings”. The Soviet Holiday in the Social Construction of a New Society]. Moskva: RGGU.

3. Browne, J. (2003) Charles Darwin as a Celebrity, Science in Context, vol. 16, iss. 1/2, pp. 175‒194.

4. Dubinin, N. P. (1989) Vechnoe dvizhenie [Perpetual Motion]. Moskva: Politizdat.

5. Fando, R. A. (2014) Biologiia v zerkale karikatury [Biology in the Mirror of Caricatures], Priroda, no. 7, pp. 87‒95.

6. Fando, R. A. (2014) Formirovanie stereotipov ob uchenykh i ikh nauchnykh dostizheniiakh sredstvami karikatury [Formation of Stereotypes about Scientists and Their Scientific Achievements by Means of Caricature], in: Baturin, Iu. M., and Borisov, V. P. (eds.) Institut istorii estestvoznaniia i tekhniki im. S. I. Vavilova. Godichnaia nauchnaia konferentsiia, 2014 [S. I. Vavilov Institute for the History of Science and Technology. Annual Scientific Conference, 2014]. Moskva: LENAND, pp. 137‒141.

7. Fando, R. A. (2016) Formirovanie obraza “uchenogo-vreditelia” v sovetskoi propagande 20‒50-kh gg. [Formation of the Image of a “Saboteur Scientist” in the Soviet Propaganda from the 1920s to the 1950s], Vseobshchaia istoriia, no. 2, pp. 15‒24.

8. Fando, R. A. (2016) Karikatura kak istoriko-nauchnyi istochnik [Caricature as a Historical and Scientific Source], in: Baturin, Iu. M., Ilizarov, S. S., and Iurkin, I. N. (eds.), Minina, E. V. (comp.) Istoriia nauki: istochniki, pamiatniki, nasledie: vtorye chteniia po istoriografii i istochnikovedeniiu istorii nauki i tekhniki: Materialy nauchnoi konferentsii. Moskva, 19–20 oktiabria 2016 g. [History of Science: Sources, Monuments, Heritage: Second Readings on Historiography and Source Study of the History of Science and Technology: Proceedings of a Scientific Conference, Moskva, October 19–20, 2016]. Moskva: Ianus-K, pp. 54‒66.

9. Fando, R. A. (2016) Nauchnaia karikatura kak zerkalo nastroenii uchenogo soobshchestva: satiricheskii zhurnal zoologov Moskovskogo universiteta [Scientific Caricature as a Mirror of an Academic Communityʼs State of Mind: A Satirical Journal of Moscow Universityʼs Zoologists], Voprosy istorii estestvoznaniia i tekhniki, vol. 37, no. 1, pp. 27‒49.

10. Fando, R. A. (2019) Obraz uchenogo-genetika na stranitsakh periodicheskoi pechati 1920‒1940-kh godov [The Image of Geneticist in the Periodicals of the 1920s – 1940s], in: Minina, E. V., Baturin, Iu. M., Ilizarov, S. S., and Iurkin, I. N. (eds.), Minina, E. V. (comp.) Istoriia nauki: pamiatniki, nasledie. Tretʼi chteniia po istoriografii i istochnikovedeniiu istorii nauki i tekhniki. K 150-letiiu so dnia rozhdeniia V. L. Komarova (1869‒1945). Materialy mezhdunarodnoi nauchnoi konferentsii [History of Science: Sources, Monuments, Heritage. Third Readings in the Historiography and Source Studies in the History of Science and Technology. Towards the 150th Anniversary of the Birth of V. L. Komarov (1869‒1945). Materials of the International Scientific Conference]. Moskva: Ianus-K, pp. 470‒474.

11. Fando, R. A. (2020) Felʼetony i karikatury na uchenykh kak istoricheskie istochniki [Caricatures and Satires of Scientists as Historical Sources], Voprosy istorii estestvoznaniia i tekhniki], vol. 41, no. 4, pp. 717‒745.

12. Fedosov, E. A. (2021) “Tovarishchu perche!”: specifika vizualʼnoi satiry Sovetskoi Ukrainy v usloviiakh kholodnoi voiny (1954‒1964) [“Comrade Pepper!”: Specifics of Visual Satire in Soviet Ukraine during the Cold War (1954–1964)], Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Istoriia, iss. 69, pp. 149‒155.

13. Golikov, A. G. (2011) Problemy istochnikovedcheskogo izucheniia politicheskoi karikatury (vtoraia polovina XIX – nachalo XX v.) [Issues in Source Studies of Political Cartoons (Second Half of the 19th ‒ Early 20th Century], Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta, seriia 8: Istoriia, no. 4, July ‒ August, pp. 51‒71.

14. Golikov, A. G. (2014) Metodika raboty s istoricheskimi istochnikami: uchebnoe posobie dlia studentov vysshikh uchebnykh zavedenii, obuchaiushchihsia po napravleniiu podgotovki 03.06.00 “Istoriia” [Methods of Working with Historical Sources: A Textbook for Students of Higher Educational Institutions Studying in the Field of 03.06.00 “History”]. Moskva: Akademiia.

15. Van Gorp, B., and Rommes, E. (2014) Scientists in Belgian Comics: Typology, Chronology and Origins, Journal of Graphic Novels & Comics, vol. 5, iss. 2, pp. 154‒169.

16. Grinʼko, I. A., and Shevtsova, A. A. (2018) “Diatel dokladodolbiashchii” i drugie zhivotnye: nauka v zerkale sovetskoi karikatury [“Report-Hammering Woodpecker” and Other Animals: Science in the Mirror of Soviet Caricature], Istoricheskaia ehkspertiza, no. 2 (15), pp. 276‒289.

17. Kantha, S. S. (2013) Cartoon Humour of Nobel Prizes, Current Science, vol. 105, iss. 8, pp. 1175‒1177.

18. Kevin, M. (2008) World War I and After: Godlessness and the Scopes Trial, in: Mathewes, Ch., and Nichols, Ch. (eds.) Prophesies of Godlessness: Predictions of Americaʼs Imminent Secularization, from the Puritans to the Present Day, New York: Oxford University Press, pp. 137–153.

19. Khan, M. I., Hanif, M. K., and Talib, R. (2022) Caricature Face Photo Facial Attribute Similarity Generator, Complexity, iss. 2, pp. 1‒14.

20. Khlebovich, V. V. (2020) Kadry zhizni odnogo zoologa [Images from the Life of a Zoologist]. Sankt-Peterburg.

21. Kolʼtsov, N. K. (1922) Uluchshenie chelovecheskoi porody [Improvement of the Human Breed], Russkii evgenicheskii zhurnal, vol. 1, iss. 1, pp. 3–27.

22. Kolchinskii, E. I. (2009) Iubilei Ch. Darvina v sotsialʼno-kulʼturnykh i kognitivnykh protsessakh [Ch. Darwin’s Anniversaries in Socio-Cultural and Cognitive Processes], Istorikobiologicheskie issledovaniia [Studies in the History of biology], vol. 1, no 1, pp. 15‒47.

23. Kovalʼchenko I. D. (1987) Metody istoricheskogo issledovaniia [Methods of Historical Research]. Moskva: Nauka.

24. Krotkov, A. P. (2015) Karikatura. Nepridumannaia istoriia [Caricature. A Real-Life Story]. Moskva: AST.

25. Mazing, Iu. (comp.) A. (2016) Druzheskie sharzhi v otdele morfologii Leningradskogo filiala VIEM (gazeta “BIOS”) [Friendly Cartoons at the Morphology Department of the Leningrad Branch of IEM (“BIOS” Newspaper)]. Sankt-Peterburg: IEM.

26. Melʼnichuk, L. D. (2020) Karikatura v tvorcheskom nasledii I. A. Vsevolozhskogo: istoriko-kulʼturnyi i khudozhestvennyi aspekty. Diss. … kand. iskusstv. [Caricature in I. A. Vsevolozhsky’s Creative Heritage: Historico-Cultural and Artistic Aspects. Thesis for the Candidate of Art History Degree]. Sankt-Peterburg.

27. Panofsky, E. (1957) Meaning of the Visual Arts. Papers in and on Art History. New York: Doubleday and Company.

28. Pavuk, A. (2018) The American Association for the Advancement of Science Committee on Evolution and the Scopes Trial: Race, Eugenics, and Public Science in the U. S. A, Historical Research, vol. 95, iss. 251, pp. 137–159.

29. Razina, T. V., and Volodarskaia, E. A. (2017) Istochnikovaia baza dlia izucheniia imidzha uchenogo [Source Base for Studying the Image of Scientist], Chelovecheskii kapital, no. 2, pp. 6–11.

30. Rogulin, N. G. (2013) Izobrazitelʼnye istochniki: vyiavlenie, atributsiia, interpretatsiia (Gollandskaia ekspeditsiia 1799 g.) [Visual Sources: Identification, Attribution, Interpretation (Dutch Expedition of 1799)]. Sankt-Peterburg: Lema.

31. Sarica, N., and Kara, N. (2017) Analyse semiotique des caricatures des immigrants de Plantu, Pamukkale University Journal of Social Sciences Institute, iss. 29, pp. 153‒161.

32. Sidorchuk, I. V. (2020) Nauka i tekhnika v satiricheskikh izdaniiakh Rossiiskoi imperii 1870‒1910-kh gg. [Science and Technology in Satirical Publications of the Russian Empire in the 1870s – 1910s], Bylye gody, vol. 55, no. 1, pp. 188‒205.

33. Terentʼeva, L. A. (1991) Metodicheskie rekomendatsii k izucheniiu kursa “Istochnikovedenie istorii SSSR”. Tema: Izobrazitelʼnye istochniki i metodika ikh ispolʼzovaniia v istoricheskikh issledovaniiakh [Methodological Recommendations for Course “Source Studies in the History of the USSR”. Subject: Visual Sources and Methods of Their Use in Historical Research]. Moskva.

34. Terentʼeva, L. A. (2009) Izobrazitelʼnye istochniki: teoriia i praktika. Uchebno-metodicheskii kompleks po spetskursu [Visual Sources: Theory and Practice. Special Course Teaching and Learning Package]. Moskva: Pravoslavnyi Sviato-Tikhonovskii gumanitarnyi universitet.

35. Vernois, S. (2006) La caricature de la Belle Epoque: Une forme d᾿autoportrait ‒ Quelques questions de méthodologie, in: Auzolle, C. (ed.) Le comparatisme: enjeux et methods, Paris: Université de Paris, pp. 85‒94.

36. Volodarskaia, E. A. (2005) Professionalʼnaia identichnostʼ uchenogo i imidzh nauki v obshchestve [Professional Identity of Scientist and the Image of Science in Society], in: Allakhverdian, A. G. (ed.) Naukovedenie i novye tendentsii v razvitii rossiiskoi nauki [Science of Science and New Trends in the Development of Russian Science]. Moskva: Izdatelʼskaia gruppa “LogoS”, pp. 187–201.

37. Volodarskaia, E. A. (2007) Imidzh nauki v obshchestve: psikhologicheskie problemy [The Image of Science in Society: Psychological Problems]. Moskva: Institut biznesa i politiki.

38. Vorontsova, E. A., and Golikov, A. G. (eds.) (2019) Rolʼ izobrazitelʼnykh istochnikov v informatsionnom obespechenii istoricheskoi nauki: sbornik statei [The Role of Visual Sources in the Information Support of Historical Science: A Collection of Articles]. Moskva. Warburg, A. (2010) Werke in einem Band. Berlin: Suhrkamp.