V.V. Struve and the Institute of the History of Arts (Towards the History of the Hypothesis of Social Revolution in Ancient Egypt)

Bukharin, Mikhail; Ananiev, Vitaliy G.

doi:10.31857/S032103910002915-9

Home

Vestnik drevnei istorii

Issue 4

V.V. Struve and the Institute of the History of Arts (Towards the History of the Hypothesis of Social Revolution in Ancient Egypt)

Annotation
Reviews
References

V.V. Struve and the Institute of the History of Arts (Towards the History of the Hypothesis of Social Revolution in Ancient Egypt)

PII

S032103910002915-9-1

DOI

10.31857/S032103910002915-9

Publication type

Article

Status

Published

Authors

Mikhail Bukharin

Occupation: Chief Researcher
Affiliation: Institute of World history, RAS
Address: Russian Federation, Moscow

Vitaliy G. Ananiev

Occupation: Senior Teacher
Affiliation: Saint Petersburg State University
Address: Russian Federation, Saint Petersburg

Journal name

Vestnik drevnei istorii

Edition

Volume 78 Issue 4

Pages

970-987

Abstract

The article presents the text of an oral communication of the leading Soviet Orientalist of the first half of the twentieth century, V.V. Struve, “Museum of Ancient Orient in Sociological Relation”, held at the session of the Museum Section of the Committee of Sociological Study of Art of the Institute of the History of Art on 16 June 1925. Struve discusses the principles of the Museums’ activity in using Ancient Oriental material. This communication dates earlier than his printed publications in which Struve put forward the idea of social revolutions in Ancient Egypt. It is set in the context of the development of Soviet Oriental studies, and connected in particular with the debate between V.V. Struve and S.Ya. Luria on this matter.

Keywords

Oriental studies, V.V. Struve, S.Ya. Luria, museums, archives, ancient Egypt, social revolution

Acknowledgment

Russian Science Foundation, project No. 18-18-00367

Received

23.01.2019

Publication date

23.01.2019

Number of characters

46225

Cite

GOST	Bukharin M., Ananiev V. V.V. Struve and the Institute of the History of Arts (Towards the History of the Hypothesis of Social Revolution in Ancient Egypt) // Vestnik drevnei istorii – 2018. – V. 78. – Issue 4 C. 970-987 [Electronic resource]. URL: http://ras.jes.su/vdi/s032103910002915-9-1-en (circulation date: 29.04.2025). DOI: 10.31857/S032103910002915-9
MLA	Bukharin, Mikhail, Ananiev, Vitaliy G "V.V. Struve and the Institute of the History of Arts (Towards the History of the Hypothesis of Social Revolution in Ancient Egypt)." Vestnik drevnei istorii 78.4 (2018):970-987. DOI: 10.31857/S032103910002915-9
APA	Bukharin M., Ananiev V. (2018). V.V. Struve and the Institute of the History of Arts (Towards the History of the Hypothesis of Social Revolution in Ancient Egypt). Vestnik drevnei istorii 78(4), pp.970-987 DOI: 10.31857/S032103910002915-9

100 rub.

When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 1, views: 2218

Readers community rating: votes 0

1. Anan'ev, V.G. O nekotorykh proektakh primeneniya sotsiologicheskogo podkhoda v muzejnom dele sovetskoj Rossii 1920-kh gg. Vestnik RGGU. Seriya «Kul'turologiya. Iskusstvovedenie. Muzeologiya» 17 (79), 2011. S. 275–283.

2. Anan'ev, V.G. Izuchenie muzejnoj auditorii v 1920-e gody (po arkhivnym materialam). Dialog so vremenem 41, 2012. S. 367–373.

3. Bakushinskij, A.V. Istoricheskie ehkskursii kak sposob uglubleniya i povtoreniya uchebnogo kursa. V sb.: A.V. Bakushinskij. Issledovaniya i stat'i. M., 1981. S. 91–98.

4. Bazant, J. 1993: The case of the talkative connoisseur. Eirene 29, 84–107.

5. Bol'shakov, A.O. Egipetskie ehkspozitsii v Ehrmitazhe. Soobscheniya Gosudarstvennogo Ehrmitazha LXXIII, 2015. S. 160–185.

6. Il'in-Tomich, A.A. Sotsial'nyj perevorot v Egipte v trudakh V.V. Struve. Vestnik Universiteta Dmitriya Pozharskogo 2 (4), 2016. S. 35–47.

7. Ismagulova, T.D. Pochemu zhe vse-taki «v Ehrmitazhe Pavlovskoj statue oblomali ruki»? (Graf Valentin Platonovich Zubov i dvortsovo-parkovyj ansambl' Pavlovska v 1920-e gg.). V sb.: N.S. Tret'yakova (red.), Pavlovskie chteniya. Materialy V i VI nauchnykh konferentsij. SPb., 2003. S. 134–145.

8. Kachalina, G.I., Marishkina, V.F., Yakovleva, E.M. (avt.-sost.). Sotrudniki Imperatorskogo Ehrmitazha. 1852–1917. Biobibliograficheskij spravochnik. SPb., 2004.

9. Kratkij otchet o deyatel'nosti Rossijskogo instituta istorii iskusstv. V sb.: A.F. Nekrylova (red.), Zadachi i metody izucheniya iskusstv (Biblioteka klassicheskikh trudov RIII). SPb., 2012. S. 187–247.

10. Krikh, S.B. Teoreticheskoe obosnovanie V.V. Struve kontseptsii rabovladel'cheskikh obschestv na Drevnem Vostoke. V sb.: A.V. Sveshnikov, S.V. Fomenko, L.R. Rotermel' (red.), Sotsial'nye instituty v istorii: retrospektsiya i real'nost'. Materialy XII mezhvuzovskoj regional'noj nauchnoj konferentsii. Omsk, 2012. S. 153–171.

11. Krikh, S.B. I.M. D'yakonov protiv V.V. Struve: polemika na polyakh Shumera. VDI 76/4, 2016. S. 1011–1029.

12. Krikh, S.B. Avtoistoriografiya sovetskogo uchenogo: pis'mo V.V. Struve v redaktsiyu VDI. VDI 77/3, 2017. S. 778–795.

13. Krikh, S.B. Istoriya porazheniya: N.M. Nikol'skij v bor'be za ponimanie obschestvennogo stroya drevnevostochnykh obschestv. Vostok (Oriens) 1. 2018. S. 13–22.

14. Krikh, S.B. Bor'ba za proshloe: V.I. Avdiev, N.M. Nikol'skij i V.V. Struve o svoej roli v rannej sovetskoj istoriografii. Scripta antiqua. Voprosy drevnej istorii, filologii, iskusstva i material'noj kul'tury 7, 2018. S. 420–432.

15. Kumpan, K.A. K istorii vozniknoveniya Sotskoma v Institute istorii iskusstv (Esche raz o Zhirmunskom i formalistakh). V sb.: Vs. Bagno, Dzh. Malmstad, M. Malikova (sost.), Na rubezhe dvukh stoletij: Sbornik v chest' 60-letiya Aleksandra Vasil'evicha Lavrova. M., 2009. S. 345–360.

16. Kumpan, K.A. Institut istorii iskusstv na rubezhe 1920–1930-kh gg. V sb.: Konets institutsij kul'tury dvadtsatykh godov v Leningrade. Po arkhivnym materialam. M., 2014. S. 8–128.

17. Marchand, S. 2009: German Orientalism in the Age of Empire: Race, Reli-gion, and Scholarship. Cambridge.

18. Mavleev, E.V. Val'dgauer. SPb., 2005.

19. Piotrovskij, M.B. (red.). Zhurnaly zasedanij Soveta Ehrmitazha. Ch. I. 1917–1919 gody. SPb., 2001.

20. Sehpman, I.V. (red.), Rossijskij institut istorii iskusstv v memuarakh. SPb., 2003.

21. Struve, V.V. Zaupokojnyj kul't Drevnego Egipta. Putevoditel' po vystavke v zalakh Ehrmitazha. Pb., 1919.

22. Ctruve, V.V. Sotsial'naya problema v zaupokojnom kul'te drevnego Egipta. V sb.: Religiya i obschestvo. Sbornik statej po izucheniyu sotsial'nykh osnov religioznykh yavlenij drevnego mira. L., 1926. S. 5–28.

23. Struve, V.V. Problema zarozhdeniya, razvitiya i razlozheniya rabovladel'cheskikh obschestv drevnego Vostoka (doklad i zaklyuchitel'noe slovo). Izvestiya Gosudarstvennoj akademii istorii material'noj kul'tury 77, 32–111. 1934. S. 157–181.

24. Struve, V.V. Istoriya drevnego Vostoka. L., 1941.

25. Struve, V.V. Sovetskoe vostokovedenie i problema obschestvennogo stroya drevnego Vostoka. Vestnik LGU 11. 1947. S. 233–242.

26. Tunkina, I.V., Frolov, Eh.D. Istoriograficheskie ehtyudy S.A. Zhebelyova: Tri neizdannykh memuara S.A. Zhebelyova. VDI 3, 1993. S. 180–202.

27. Vassoevich, A.L. Dukhovnyj mir narodov klassicheskogo Vostoka (istoriko-psikhologicheskij metod v istoriko-filosofskom is-sledovanii). SPb., 1998.

28. Washburn, W.E. 1967: Grandmotherology and museology. Curator. The Mu-seum Journal 10. 1, 43–48.

29. Zakharov, A.O. “Drevnij Vostok” v postroeniyakh B.A. Turaeva i V.V. Struve: teoreticheskij analiz. Vostok (Oriens) 1. 2008. S. 11–24.

30. Zubov, V.P. Stradnye gody Rossii: Vospominaniya o revolyutsii (1917–1925). M., 2004.