Problems of the Conflict on the CER in the works of Soviet scientists of the first half of the XX century

Occupation: Professor
Affiliation:
Institute for Demographic Research—Branch of the Federal Center of Theoretical and Applied Sociology of the Russian Academy of Sciences
Institute of Oriental Studies of the Russian Academy of Sciences
Address: 12, Rozhdestvenka St., Moscow, Russian Federation, 107031

Journal name

Problemy Dalnego Vostoka

Edition

Issue 1

Pages

180-191

Abstract

The article is devoted to the problem of the Conflict on the Chinese Eastern Railway in the works of Soviet orientalist experts — contemporaries of the events. The Conflict on the CER is the Soviet-Chinese confrontation on the Chinese Eastern Railway, starting in 1924. The chronological framework is determined by the history of the Conflict of the Chinese Eastern Railway — the period of the second half of the 1920s — early 1930s. Already at the end of 1924, the first conflict between the Soviet and Chinese sides of the road took place. The conflict at the Chinese Eastern Railway in early 1926 moved to a qualitatively new level. The Soviet-Chinese Conflict at the CER in 1929 was already a military conflict between the two countries. In the 1920s-1930s little attention was paid to this conflict in Soviet literature. The reason for the increased interest of the public and expert experts in the Conflict at the Chinese Eastern Railroad was the sharp aggravation of the conflict and the military events of 1929. Already in 1929, brochures describing the military conflict were published in Siberia, and detailed materials on the problems of the Conflict at the Chinese Eastern Railroad appeared in periodicals. The source for the research was the publications of the contemporaries of the events. The works of Soviet orientalists such as B.N. Melnikov, S.A. Dridzo, A.A. Ivanov, G.N. Zarkhin, G.B. Skalov, V.Ya. Aboltin. In addition, other publications by various authors devoted to the Soviet-Chinese Conflict at the Chinese Eastern Railway in 1929 were considered. Analysis of the publications made it possible to conclude that an extremely simplified picture of events was given in the Soviet scientific and popular science literature, the analysis of problems was replaced by propaganda and ideological clichés, the authors reduced the causes of the conflict to the intrigues of external enemies.

Keywords

The Conflict on the CER, the historiography of Soviet-Chinese relations, Soviet experts-orientalists

Received

19.01.2022

Publication date

16.02.2022

Number of characters

29203

Cite

GOST	Datsyshen V. Problems of the Conflict on the CER in the works of Soviet scientists of the first half of the XX century // Problemy Dalnego Vostoka – 2022. – Issue 1 C. 180-191 [Electronic resource]. URL: https://pdv.jes.su/S013128120018309-0-1 (circulation date: 09.10.2024). DOI: 10.31857/S013128120018309-0
MLA	Datsyshen, Vladimir "Problems of the Conflict on the CER in the works of Soviet scientists of the first half of the XX century." Problemy Dalnego Vostoka 1 (2022):180-191. DOI: 10.31857/S013128120018309-0
APA	Datsyshen V. (2022). Problems of the Conflict on the CER in the works of Soviet scientists of the first half of the XX century. Problemy Dalnego Vostoka (1), pp.180-191 DOI: 10.31857/S013128120018309-0

100 rub.

When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 5, views: 731

Readers community rating: votes 0

1. Avarin V. Imperializm v Man'chzhurii. T. 1. Etapy imperialisticheskoj bor'by za Man'chzhuriyu (Imperialism in Manchuria. T.1. Stages of the imperialistic fight for Manchuria). 2-e peresmotrennoe i dopolnennoe izdanie. M.-L.: OGIZ, 1934.

2. Barandov G. Vooruzhennyj oplot sovetskogo gosudarstva (Armed stronghold of the Soviet state). M.: OGIZ, SOCEKGIZ, 1941.

3. Butlickij E., Teplov D. Voennaya ugroza na Dal'nemVostoke. Chto proiskhodit na Sovetsko-kitajskoj granice (Military threat in the Far East. What is happening on the Soviet-Chinese border). M: GIZ, 1929.

4. Chicherin G.V. Stat'i po voprosam mezhdunarodnoj politiki (Articles on questions of international politics). M.: Izd-vosoc-ekon. lit., 1961.

5. Glebov N. Yaponskie agressory v Kitae (Japanese aggressors in China). M.: Partizdat, 1938.

6. Dacyshen V.G. Russko-kitajskaya vojna. Man'chzhuriya 1900 g. (The war between Russia and China. Manchuria 1900). SPb., 1996.

7. Dacyshen V.G. «Konflikt na KVZhD 1926 g.» i «Konflikt na KVZHD 1929 g.»: sravnitel'no-istoricheskij analiz sovetskoj politiki (“Conflict on the CER in 1926” and “Conflict on the CER in 1929”: a comparative historical analysis of Soviet politics). Sravnitel'naya politika. 2018. No. 9(4).

8. Doronin M. Zahvat Kitajsko-Vostochnoj zheleznoj dorogi (The seizure of the Chinese Eastern Railway). Novosibirsk: Sibkrajizdat, 1929.

9. Ignatovich K.I. Problemy kitajskoj kolonizacii Severnoj Man'chzhurii i metody ee osushchestvleniya (Problems of the Chinese colonization of Northern Manchuria and methods of its implementation). Severnaya Aziya. 1929. № 5–6.

10. Ivin A. Za SSSR, za revolyucionnyj Kitaj (For the USSR, for revolutionary China). M.-L.: Gosudarstvennoe izd-vo, otdel voennoj literatury, 1929.

11. Kitaj i russkaya emigraciya v dnevnikah I.I. i A.N. Serebrennikovyh (China and Russian emigration in the diaries of I.I. and A.N. Serebrennikovs). V 5 t. Tom I. M.: ROSSPEN, 2006.

12. Konev N. Na sovetsko-kitajskoj granice (On the Soviet-Chinese border). M.: Molodaya gvardiya, 1930.

13. Kostarev N. Granica na zamke (The border is locked). M.: Molodaya gvardiya, 1930.

14. Man'chzhuriya. Ekonomiko-geograficheskoe opisanie. Ch. 1 (Manchuria. Economic and geographic description. Part 1). Harbin: Tipo-litografiya Kit. Vost. zhel. dor., 1934.

15. Melihov G.V. Belyj Harbin: Seredina 20-h (White Harbin. Mid 1920s). M.: Russkij put', 2003.

16. Mif P. Kitajskaya kommunisticheskaya partiya v kriticheskie dni (The Chinese Communist Party in critical days). M.-L.: Gosudarstvennoe izdatel'stvo, 1928.

17. Molva. 1928. 3 oktyabrya.

18. Perepiska I.V. Stalina i G.V. Chicherina s polpredom SSSR v Kitae L.M. Karahanom: dokumenty, avgust 1923 g. — 1926 g. (Correspondence of I.V. Stalin and G.V. Chicherin with the plenipotentiary of the USSR in China L.M. Karahan: documents, August 1923–1926). Sost., otv. red. A I. Kartunova. M.: Natalis, 2008.

19. Problemy Kitaya. Zapiski NII po Kitayu pri associacii po izucheniyu nacional'nyh i kolonial'nyh problem (The problems of China. Notes of the Research Institute for China under the Association for the Study of National and Colonial Problems). № 3. M.: Izd-vo Komakademii, 1930.

20. Semenov B. Kitaj i SSSR (China and the USSR). O Kitae. Politiko-ekonomicheskij sbornik. Pod red. A. Lozovskogo. M.-L.: Gosudarstvennoe izdatel'stvo, 1928.

21. Skalov G. KVZhD: Imperializm i kitajskaya reakciya v sobytiyahna KVZhD (CER: Imperialism and Chinese reaction in the events on the CER). M.-L.: Gosudarstvennoe izdatel'stvo. Otdel voennoj literatury, 1930.

22. VKP(b), Komintern i Kitaj: Dokumenty. T. IV. 1931–1937 (The All-Union Communist Party of Bolsheviks, the Comintern and China: Documents. T. IV. 1931–1937). VKP(b), Komintern i sovetskoe dvizhenie v Kitae. 1931–1937. V 2-h chastyah. CH. 1. M.: ROSSPEN, 2003.

23. Vojtinskij G. Zahvat KVZhD i politika SSSR (The seizure of the CER and the policy of the USSR). Krasnaya nov'. 1929. № 9.

24. Vojtinskij G. Repeticiya vojny protiv SSSR. KVZhD, imperialisty i SSSR (The rehearsal of the war against the USSR. The CER, imperialists and the USSR). M.-L.: Gosudarstvennoe izdatel'stvo, 1930.

25. Vojtinskij G. KVZhD i politika imperialistov v Kitae (CER and the policy of imperialists in China). M.: Izd-vo Kommun. akad., 1930.