Wilhelm II and the Power System of Germany at the End of 19th and to Begin of 20th Centuries

On the basis of a historiographical analysis, the authors of this article attempt to reflect on the thirty-year reign of German Emperor Wilhelm II, taking into account the historically shaped tendencies of power, ideology, social and political organisation, as well as the Emperor's own ideas of monarchy and state. The authors systematise historians' assessments of the concepts of “dual modernization”, the “regime of personal rule by the emperor” and “Wilhelminianism” as well as interpretations of the phenomenon of radicalisation of public opinion and the activities of political parties and popular associations. It is their shared opinion that the far-reaching constitutional guarantees and powers proclaimed and granted to the German public by the 1871 Constitution were in fact substantially circumscribed. The Reichstag, as a social and political institution of power, never really became the main actor in the legislative process with controlling powers over the executive. The German middle class failed to secure the “classical prerogatives of parliamentarianism” (Georg Iggers). The constitutionally enshrined preponderance of monarchical power was reinforced by the alliance of the princes with the agrarian elite, which continued to dominate both economically and politically, occupying key positions in both the bureaucracy and the army. Therefore, due to the comparatively late unification of the country, the preservation of medieval monarchical culture and structures of domination, social groups, associations, unions, political movements and parties became the subjects of modernisation changes during this period of time. The war unleashed by the German monarchy and its subsequent tragedy clearly showed the other side of national unity. All these developments are considered in the context of the transformation of the monarchy, but not in the direction of limiting the personal power of the ruler, but in the direction of the traditional view of it ("the alliance between throne and altar"), which predetermined the final disaster of the reign of Emperor Wilhelm II.

Keywords

German Empire, Wilhelm II, “personal rule regime”, authoritarianism, “Wilhelminianism”, “double modernization”, Sonderweg, “imaginary constitutionalism”, militarism, colonialism

Received

08.03.2023

Publication date

26.06.2023

Number of characters

58064

Cite

GOST	Vatlin A., Turygin A., Nevskiy S. Wilhelm II and the Power System of Germany at the End of 19th and to Begin of 20th Centuries // Novaia i noveishaia istoriia – 2023. – Issue 3 C. 7-27 [Electronic resource]. URL: https://nni.jes.su/S013038640024400-8-1 (circulation date: 23.07.2024). DOI: 10.31857/S013038640024400-8
MLA	Vatlin, Alexander, Turygin, Alexander, Nevskiy, Sergey "Wilhelm II and the Power System of Germany at the End of 19th and to Begin of 20th Centuries." Novaia i noveishaia istoriia 3 (2023):7-27. DOI: 10.31857/S013038640024400-8
APA	Vatlin A., Turygin A., Nevskiy S. (2023). Wilhelm II and the Power System of Germany at the End of 19th and to Begin of 20th Centuries. Novaia i noveishaia istoriia (3), pp.7-27 DOI: 10.31857/S013038640024400-8

100 rub.

When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 0, views: 266

Readers community rating: votes 0

1. Abel'skhauzer V. Ekonomika kaizerovskoi Germanii: blagopriiatnaia sreda dlia razvitiia postindustrial'nykh institutov [Economy of the German Empire: a Greenhouse of Post-Industrial Institutions] // Ekonomicheskaia istoriia Germanii: ot epokhi kameralizma do nashikh dnei: v 3 t. T. 1. Ekonomicheskaia istoriia Germanii v Novoe vremia: ot agrarnogo obshchestva k mirovoi promyshlennoi derzhave [The Economic History of Germany: From the Era of Cameralism to the Present Days: in 3 vol. V. 1. The Economic History of Germany in the Modern Times: From the Agrarian Society to the World Industrial Power] / sost., per. s nem., nauch. red. S.I. Nevskogo. Moskva, 2016. (In Russ.)

2. Baranov N.N. Levyi politicheskii liberalizm v vil'gel'movskoi Germanii (1858–1918 gg.): dis. … dokt. ist. nauk [The Left Political Liberalism in Wilhelmine Germany (1858–1918): Thesis for the Degree of Doctor of Historical Sciences]. Ekaterinburg, 2012. (In Russ.)

3. Cherneczkaya E.K. Zhazhda stranstvij: e`migraciya iz Germanskoj imperii v konce XIX – nachale XX v [Wanderlust: Emigration from the German Empire in the late 19th – early 20th century] // Humanitarian accent [Humanitarian Emphasis]. 2017. № 1. P. 59–65. (In Russ.)

4. Elias N. O protsesse tsivilizatsii: Sotsiogeneticheskie i psikhogeneticheskie issledovaniia: v 2-kh t. T. 2. Izmeneniia v obshchestve. Proekt teorii tsivilizatsii [On the Process of Civilization: Sociogenetic and Psychogenetic Studies: in 2 vols. Vol. 2. Changes in society. The Theory of Civilization Project]. Moskva; Sankt-Peterburg, 2001. (In Russ.)

5. Fischer F. Ryvok k mirovomu gospodstvu. Politika voennykh tselei kaizerovskoi Germanii v 1914–1918 gg. [Grab for World Power. Germany's Aims in the First World War] / per. s nem. L. Lannika. Moskva, 2017. (In Russ.)

6. Kamkin A.K. Germaniia – Rossiia: Dogovor o podstrakhovke 1887 goda – upushchennyi mirnyi shans istorii Evropy [Germany – Russia: The Reinsurance Treaty of 1887 – a Missed Chance for Peace in the History of Europe] // Sovremennaia Evropa [Modern Europe]. 2011. № 1 (45). S. 126–138. (In Russ.)

7. Kokovtsov V.N. Iz moego proshlogo. Vospominaniia 1903–1919 gg. [From my past. Memories 1903–1919]: v 2 t. T. 2. Parizh, 1933. (In Russ.)

8. Konstitutsiia Germanskoi imperii [Constitution of the German Empire] // Sobranie konstitutsii [Collection of Constitutions]. V. 1. Moskva, 1905. S. 31–40. (In Russ.)

9. Levshina Y.A. K voprosu o vliyanii pressy na formirovanie obshchestvennogo mneniya Germanii v nachale HKH veka [On the issue of the influence of the press on the formation of public opinion in Germany at the beginning of the twentieth century] // Uchyonye zapiski Orlovskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta [Scientific Notes of the Oryol State University]. 2013. № 4 (54). S. 68–72. (In Russ.)

10. Matveeva A.G. Nekotorye aspekty germanskoj kolonial'noj politiki v 1880–1890 e gg. (po materialam Arhiva vneshnej politiki Rossijskoj imperii) [Some aspects of German colonial policy in the 1880–1890s. (Based on the materials of the Archive of the Foreign Policy of the Russian Empire)] // Elektronnyj nauchno-obrazovatel'nyj zhurnal “Istoriya” [Electronic scientific and educational Journal “History”]. 2020. T. 11. № 8 (94). (In Russ.)

11. Matveeva A.G. Kancler Kaprivi i polyaki. “Novyj kurs” v politike Germanii v 1890–1894 [Chancellor Caprivi and the Poles. “New Deal” in German politics in 1890–1894]. Moskva, 2008. (In Russ.)

12. Matveeva A.G. Vil'gel'm II i otstavka O. fon Bismarka [Wilhelm II and the resignation of O. von Bismarck] // Novaya i Novejshaya Istoriya [Modern and Contemporary History]. 2022. № 5. S. 92–103. (In Russ.)

13. MacDonogh G. Poslednii kaizer. Vil'gel'm Neistovyi [The Last Kaiser. William the Impetuous] / per. s angl. A.M. Filitova. Moskva, 2004. (In Russ.)

14. Maksimov I.P. Biulov i “gottentotskii blok” 1907–1909 godov. Realizatsiia “politiki splocheniia” na praktike [Bülow and the “Hottentot Bloc” of the 1907–1909s. Implementation of the “Cohesion Policy” in Practice] // Vestnik Baltiiskogo federal'nogo universiteta im. I. Kanta. Ser.: Gumanitarnye i obshchestvennye nauki [Bulletin of the Baltic Federal Kant-University. Series: Humane and Social Sciences]. 2017. № 4. S. 90–96. (In Russ.)

15. Mann H. Vernopoddannyi [The Patrioteer]. Moskva, 1985. (In Russ.)

16. Medushevskii A.N. Monarkhicheskii konstitutsionalizm v Germanii i Rossii [The Monarchic Constitutionalism in Germany and Russia] // Demokratiia i avtoritarizm: rossiiskii konstitutsionalizm v sravnitel'noi perspective [Democracy and Authoritarianism: Russian Constitutionalism in a Comparative Perspective]. Moskva; Berlin, 2015. (In Russ.)

17. Medushevskii A.N. Chto takoe mnimyi konstitutsionalizm (istoricheskii opyt Germanii) [What is Imaginary Constitutionalism (the Historical Experience of Germany)] // Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniia [Sociological Research]. 1994. № 2. S. 71–86. (In Russ.)

18. Ol'khovskaia O.V. “Iskliuchitel'nyi zakon o sotsialistakh” 1878 goda i partiia “Tsentr” [“Exceptional Law on Socialists” of 1878 and the Center Party] // Vestnik Brianskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta [Bulletin of the Bryansk State University]. 2010. № 2. S. 35–38. (In Russ.)

19. Poluboyarinova L.N. Literaturnyj obraz Berlina v epohu kajzera Vil'gel'ma II: mezhdu konservatizmom i modernom [The literary image of Berlin in the era of Kaiser Wilhelm II: between conservatism and modernity] // Vestnik Leningradskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta im. A.S. Pushkina [Bulletin of the Leningrad State Pushkin-University]. 2014. T. 1. № 4. S. 23–32. (In Russ.)

20. Radkau J. Epokha nervoznosti. Germaniia ot Bismarka do Gitlera [The Era of Nervousness. Germany between Bismarck and Hitler] / per. s nem. N. Shtil'mark; pod nauch. red. S. Tashkenova. Moskva, 2017. (In Russ.)

21. Röhl J.K.G. Vil'gel'm II Germanskii imperator (1888–1918) [Wilhelm II, Emperor of Germany (1888–1918)] // Shindling A., Tsigler V. Kaizery [Kaisers]. Rostov-na-Donu, 1997. (In Russ.)

22. Shtollyajs M. Istoriya publichnogo prava v Germanii: Vejmarskaya respublika i nacional-socializm [The History of Public Law in Germany: The Weimar Republic and National Socialism]. Moskva, 2017. (In Russ.)

23. Suvorov Iu.V. Stranitsy istorii germanskoi sotsial-demokratii. Ch. 2. Partiia v poslednei treti XIX veka [Pages of the History of German Social Democracy. Part 2. The Party in the Last Third of the 19th Century]. Petrozavodsk, 2013. (In Russ.).

24. Taran V.V. Kajzer i kancler v epohu pravleniya Vil'gel'ma II Gogencollerna [Kaiser and Chancellor in the era of the reign of Wilhelm II of Hohenzollern] // Colloquium-Journal. 2019. № 14 (38). S. 48–50. (In Russ.)

25. Turygin A.A. “Esli by ia byl imperatorom…”: Idei i suzhdeniia Genrikha Klassa o pangermanskoi al'ternative razvitiia Germanii (pervaia chetvert' XX v.) [“If I were an Emperor…”: Ideas and Judgments of Heinrich Klass on the Pan-German Alternative for the Development of Germany (the First Quarter of the 20th Century)] // Vestnik Kemerovskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta [Bulletin of the Kemerovo State University]. 2015. № 3 (63). T. 2. S. 57–60. (In Russ.)

26. Turygin A.A. Karl Peters i obrazovanie Pangermanskogo soiuza [Carl Peters and the formation of the Pan-German Union] // Aktual'nye problemy sovremennykh sotsial'no-gumanitarnykh nauk: materialy Vserossiiskoi nauchno-prakticheskoi konferentsii 15 dekabria 2012 g. [Actual Problems of Modern Social and Humanitarian Sciences: Proceedings of the All-Russian Scientific and Practical Conference, December 15, 2012] / sost. S.K. Buldakov, A.A. Turygin, E.A. Chugunov. Kostroma, 2013. S. 89–97. (In Russ.)

27. Turygin A.A. Pangermantsy i monarkhiia: kritika i videnie perspektivy [Pan-Germans and the Monarchy: Criticism and Perspective Vision] // Vestnik Kostromskogo Gosudarstvennogo universiteta [Bulletin of the Kostroma State University]. Kostroma, 2017. № 4. S. 36–40. (In Russ.)

28. Ustinova Iu.N. Goneniia protiv sotsial-demokratii v Germanskoi imperii i natsional-liberaly: 1878 god [Persecution against the Social Democracy in the German Empire and the National Liberals: 1878] // Vestnik Brianskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta [Bulletin of the Bryansk State University]. 2010. № 2. S. 46–50. (In Russ.)

29. Ball R. Wilhelm the Last: Summary of the 25-year reign of Wilhelm II. Nordhausen, 2017.

30. Bismarck O. Die gesammelten Werke. Friedrichsruher Ausgabe. Bd. 13. Reden / Bearb. von W. Schüßler. Berlin, 1930.

31. Cecil L. Wilhelm II: Prince and Emperor, 1859–1900. Chapel Hill, 1989.

32. Clark C. Wilhelm II. Die Herrschaft des letzten deutschen Kaisers. München, 2008.

33. Clark С. How powerful was the Kaiser? // London Review of Books. 2015. Vol. 37. № 8. URL: https://www.lrb.co.uk/the-paper/v37/n08/christopher-clark/how-powerful-was-the-kaiser (access date: 30.01.2023).

34. Clark С. Kaiser Wilhelm. London, 2000.

35. Der Ort Kaiser Wilhelms II in der deutsche Geschichte / Hrsg. J.C.G. Röhl. München, 1991.

36. Die politischen Reden Kaiser Wilhelms II. Eine Auswahl / Hrsg. M.A. Obst. Paderborn, 2011.

37. Die Reden Kaiser Wilhelms II. Bd. 2. In den Jahren 1896–1900 / Hrsg. J. Penzler. Leipzig, 1912.

38. Egelhaaf G. Theobald von Bethmann Hollweg, der fünfte Reichskanzler. Stuttgart, 1916.

39. Eley G. Review of the View from the Throne: The Personal Rule of Kaiser Wilhelm II // The Historical Journal. 1985. Vol. 28. № 2. P. 469–485.

40. Eschenburg T. Das Kaiserreich am Scheideweg. Bassermann, Bülow und der Block. Berlin, 1929.

41. Eyck E. Das persönliche Regiment Wilhelms II: politische Geschichte des deutschen Kaiserreiches von 1890 bis 1914. Erlenbach-Zürich, 1948.

42. Fischer M. Vierzig Jahre deutsche Chinapolitik. Hamburg, 1962.

43. Fischer R. Das Recht des Deutschen Kaisers. Berlin, 1895.

44. Franz G. Kulturkampf. Staat und katholische Kirche in Mitteleuropa von der Säkularisation bis zum Abschluß des preußischen Kulturkampfs. München, 1954.

45. Genton F. La “misère allemande”, un problème du socialisme européen vers 1900. La controverse Jaurès-Mehring à propos de Frédéric II de Prusse et de l'Aufklärung // Chroniques allemandes. 1998–1999. № 7. P. 77–80.

46. Groepper H. Bismarcks Sturz und die Preisgabe des Rückversicherungsvertrages. Paderborn, 2008.

47. Grothe H. Auswanderung und deutsche Volkswohlfahrt. Berlin, 1919.

48. Hartmann H.-G. Die Innenpolitik des Fürsten Bülow 1906–1909. Kiel, 1950.

49. Hartung F. Deutsche Geschichte vom Frankfurter Frieden bis zum Vertrag von Versailles 1871–1919. Bonn, 1930.

50. Hasselhorn B. Nach dem Königstod. Zum Umgang Wilhelms II. mit seinem Erbe nach 1918 // Preußendämmerung. Die Abdankung der Hohenzollern und das Ende Preußens: Kulturgeschichte Preußens. Colloquien / Hrsg. von T. Biskup, T. Vu Minh, J. Luh. Vol. 8. Heidelberg, 2019. S. 39–51.

51. Hobson R. Maritimer Imperialismus. Seemachtideologie, seestrategisches Denken und der Tirpitzplan 1875 bis 1914. München, 2004.

52. Kaiser Wilhelm II. New Interpretations / eds J.C.G. Röhl, N. Sombart. Cambridge, 1982.

53. Kirby W. Stanford Journal of East Asian Affairs. Stanford, 1984.

54. König W. Wilhelm II. und die Moderne. Der Kaiser und die technisch-industrielle Welt. Paderborn, 2007.

55. Lemke A. Memory spaces of the self: Walter Benjamin's “Berlin childhood around nineteen hundred”. Würzburg, 2005.

56. Langewiesche D. Liberalismus in Deutschland. Frankfurt a.M., 1988.

57. Leibenguth P. Modernisierungskrisis des Kaiserreichs an der Schwelle zum Wilhelminischen Imperialismus. Politische Probleme der Ära Caprivi (1890–1894). Köln, 1975.

58. Lill R. Die Wende im Kulturkampf // Quellen und Forschungen aus italienischen Archiven und Bibliotheken. Bd. 50. Rom, 1971. S. 227–283.

59. Mann G. Deutsche Geschichte des 19. und 20. Jahrhunderts. Frankfurt a.M., 1992.

60. Mann H. Der Untertan. Roman. Leipzig, 1918.

61. Mommsen W.J. War der Kaiser an allem schuld? Wilhelm II. und die preußisch-deutschen Machteliten. Berlin, 2002.

62. Nipperdey T. Deutsche Geschichte 1866–1918. Machtstaat vor der Demokratie. München, 1992.

63. Nuhn W. Kolonialpolitik und Marine. Die Rolle der Kaiserlichen Marine bei der Gründung und Sicherung des deutschen Kolonialreiches 1884–1914. Bonn, 2002.

64. Ostermann T. Die verfassungsrechtliche Stellung des Deutschen Kaisers nach der Reichsverfassung von 1871. Frankfurt am Main, 2009.

65. Rede von Staatsminister Freiherr von Bülow im deutschen Reichstag am Montag, den 6. Dezember 1897 // Verhandlungen des Reichstags. IX. Leg. 5. Sess. Bd. 159. 1897–1898. S. 60.

66. Reich K. Die liberalen Parteien in Deutschland 1918 bis 1933. Osnabrück, 1979.

67. Reichskanzler Theobald von Bethmann Hollweg 1909–1921. Rekonstruktion seines verlorenen Nachlasses / Hrsg. W. Baumgart. Berlin, 2021.

68. Röhl J.C.G. Kaiser Wilhelm II. Cambridge, 2014.

69. Röhl J.C.G. Kaiser, Hof und Staat. Wilhelm II. und die deutsche Politik. München, 1995.

70. Röhl J.C.G. Wilhelm II. Der Weg in den Abgrund 1900–1941. 3. Aufl. München, 2017.

71. Röhr A. Deutsche Marinechronik. Oldenburg, 1974.

72. Schabas W.A. The trial of the Kaiser. Oxford, 2018.

73. Schoeps J.H. Kriegsbegeisterung und Ernüchterung: Über das Selbstverständnis und die Befindlichkeiten deutscher Juden im Ersten Weltkrieg und danach // Zeitschrift für Religions- und Geistesgeschichte. 2014. Vol. 66. № 1. S. 76–89.

74. Sheehan J. Der deutsche Liberalismus von den Anfängen im 18. Jahrhundert bis zum Ersten Weltkrieg, 1770–1914. München, 1983.

75. Sombart N. Wilhelm II. Sündenbock und Herr der Mitte. Berlin, 1996.

76. The interview of the Emperor Wilhelm II on October 28, 1908 // London Daily Telegraph. October 28, 1908.

77. Vietsch E.v. Bethmann Hollweg. Staatsmann zwischen Macht und Ethos. Boppard am Rhein, 1969.

78. Wehler H.-U. Das Deutsche Kaiserreich 1871–1914. Göttingen, 1973.

79. Wehler H.-U. Das Deutsche Kaiserreich 1871–1918. Göttingen, 1980.

80. Wehler H.-U. Deutsche Gesellschaftsgeschichte. 4 B-de. Bd. 3. Von der “Deutschen Doppelrevolution” bis zum Beginn des Ersten Weltkrieges 1849–1914. München, 1995.

81. Winkler J.R. Sozialstruktur und Parteiensystem in Deutschland 1912–1924 // Historical Social Research 1992. Vol. 17. № 1. S. 53–102.

82. Winzen P. Reichskanzler Bernhard von Bülow. Regensburg, 2013.