All
 
|
 
 


“We Arrived Openly and Without any Disguise on this Coast…”: The Schooner “Vixen” Case in the Investigation Papers and British Press of the Late 1830s
 
PIIS013038640019754-7-1
DOI10.31857/S013038640019754-7
Publication type Article
Status Published
Authors
Dmitry Tkachenko 
Affiliation: North Caucasus Federal University
Address: Russian Federation, Stavropol
Journal nameNovaia i noveishaia istoriia
EditionIssue 1
Pages46-59
Abstract

In this article, the author examines the details of the detention of the British schooner “Vixen” on the north-east coast of the Black Sea in November 1836. Although the analysis of the Russian-British diplomatic controversy surrounding the incident has been undertaken in Russian historiography, it has not made use of original investigative material or official accounts of the perpetrators in the English-language press of the late 1830s. The use of historical computer reconstructions can significantly clarify both the “Vixen” Inquiry materials and correct the conclusions of some contemporary researchers who have addressed the political background of the incident. It also allowed the author to check the credibility of the investigative material collected between 1836 and 1837 as part of the original “Vixen” files. It also clarifies the political conclusions drawn by both Russian imperial authorities and British politicians, and corrects some of the assumptions of contemporary historians focused on examining the political repercussions of the case. The author also examines the conditions of the Russian blockade of the Black Sea coast of the Caucasus at the end of the 1830s. This is consistent with the aim of the study, namely to recreate a complete picture of the capture of the schooner “Vixen”. The latter was beyond the scope of previous studies. The study is based on materials from the Russian Navy State Archives (RGA VMF), as well as publications in British, American, and Australian newspapers. The author used the memoirs of the owner of the “Vixen”, James Stanislaus Bell, and the captain of the Russian ship, N.P. Volf, as additional primary source material. The study corroborates the conclusions that the “Vixen” incident was a premeditated provocation, but disputes the popular perception that the ship was actually carrying a cargo of weapons and gunpowder, as insisted on by the Russian side. The breach of the blockade by “Vixen” was a clear reconnaissance operation, which allowed the British to observe not only the technical inferiority of Russian ships in terms of modern requirements, but also the excessive bureaucratisation of the entire Russian Black Sea Fleet's management system. This gave British diplomacy, which had contested the terms of the Treaty of Adrianople, additional arguments for its diplomatic efforts.

Keywords“Vixen”, Eastern Question, Russia, UK, naval blockade, Circassia, James Bell, investigative material, press, international conflicts, international relations, diplomatic negotiations, Black Sea Fleet
Received15.12.2022
Publication date28.02.2023
Number of characters41404
Cite  
100 rub.
When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 0, views: 137

Readers community rating: votes 0 

1. Abakumov O.Ju. “…Chtob nravstvennaia zaraza ne pronikla v nashi predely”. Iz istorii bor'by III otdelenija s evropejskim vlijaniem v Rossii (1830-e ― nachalo 1860-h gg.) [“... So that the moral contagion does not penetrate into our borders”. From the history of the struggle of the Third branch with European influence in Russia (1830s – early 1860s)]. Saratov, 2008. (In Russ.)
2. Adres-kalendar', ili obshhij shtat Rossijskoj imperii na 1843 god [Address-calendar, or the general state of the Russian Empire for 1843]. Sankt-Peterburg, 1843. (In Russ.)
3. Bibikov G.N. A.H. Benkendorf i politika imperatora Nikolaja I [A.H. Benckendorf and the policy of Emperor Nicholas I]. Moskva, 2009. (In Russ.)
4. Zaichenko O.V. Avgust fon Kocebu: istorija politicheskogo ubijstva [August von Kotzebue: The story of a political assassination] // Novaya i novejshaya istoriya [Modern and Contemporary History]. 2013. № 2. S. 177–191. (In Russ.)
5. Mesjaceslov i obshhij shtat Rossijskoj imperii na (1831–1842) [The monthly calendar and the general staff of the Russian Empire on (1831–1842)] Sankt-Peterburg, 1830–1842. (In Russ.)
6. Pol'sha v 1814–1831 gg. Iz vospominanij generala Klementija Kolachevskogo [Poland in 1814–1831. From the memoirs of General Klementi Kolachevsky] // Russkaja starina [Russian Antiquity]. 1902. T. 110. Kn. 5. S. 409–438; Kn. 6. S. 553–574. (In Russ.)
7. Cherkasov P.P. Russkij agent vo Francii. Jakov Nikolaevich Tolstoj (1791–1867 gg.) [A Russian agent in France. Yakov Nikolaevich Tolstoy (1791–1867)]. Moskva, 2008. (In Russ.)
8. Cherkasov P.P. Tretij chelovek v Tret'em otdelenii. Adam Sagtynskij – pervyj shef rossijskoj vneshnej razvedki [The third person is in the Third Ward. Adam Sagtynsky – the first chief of Russian Foreign Intelligence] // Rodina [Homeland]. 2007. № 9. S. 56–62. (In Russ.)
9. Cherkasov P.P. Shpionskie i inye istorii iz arhivov Rossii i Francii [Spy and other stories from the archives of Russia and France]. Moskva, 2015. (In Russ.)
10. Shil'der N.K. Imperator Nikolaj Pervyj, ego zhizn' i carstvovanie: v 2-h t. [Emperor Nicholas I, his life and reign: in 2 vols]. Sankt-Peterburg, 1903. (In Russ.)
11. (Anonym.) Russian reign of terror and persecution // Polonia or Monthly Reports of Polish affairs. 1832. № IV. P. 241–260.
12. (Anonym.) Welt und Zeit. Aus dem Nachlaß eines russischen Diplomaten / Hrsg. von Levin Schücking. Berlin, 1855.
13. Askenazy S. Lukasinski. Т. 1. Warschawa, 1908.
14. Gedichte von Freiherrn von Schweizer. Stuttgart, 1845.
15. Goedeke K. Grundriss der Geschichte der deutschen Dichtung aus den Quellen. Zweite ganz neu bearbeitete Auflage: in 18 Bd. Bd. XV. Buch VIII. Vom Frieden 1815 bis zur Französischen Revolution 1830. Abteilung VIII. Berlin, 1966.
16. Harring H. Faust im Gewande der Zeit. Ein Schattenspiel mit Licht. Leipzig, 1831.
17. Harring H. Memoiren über Polen unter russischer Herrschaft. Nach zweijährigem Aufenthalt in Warschau. Selbstverlag. Nürnberg, 1831.
18. Hube M. Russisches Schreckens- und Verfolgungs-System sowie die in Preußen begonnene Nachahmung desselben. Paris, 1832.
19. Neuer Nekrolog der Deutschen… / von Friedrich August Schmidt, Bernhardt Friedrich Voigt. Fünfundzwanzigster Jahrgang, Teil 2. 1847. Weimar, 1849.
20. Schulze H. Sand, Kotzebue und das Blut des Verräters (1819) // Das Attentat in der Geschichte / Hrsg. A. Demandt. Köln, 1996. S. 215–232.
21. Skuodis V. Vilniaus universiteto filomatai ir filaretai, jų likimas. Istorinė apybraiža. Vilnius, 2003.


Additional sources and materials

F. 19. Ser.4. f. 370.


RGA VMF. F. 410. Ser.1. f.210.


 


Bell D. Dnevnik prebyvaniya v Cherkessii v techenie 1837-1839 godov [Journal of a Residence in Circassia During the Years 1837, 1838 and 1839]. Nal'chik, 2007. Vol. 1,2. (In Russ.)


RGA VMF. F. 410. Ser.1. f.361.


Caledonian Mercury. – 1837. - № 18,225.


Hansard's Parliamentary Debates. 3-rd series. – London, 1837. – Vol. 37.– P. 621-656.


National Benner and Nashville Whig. – 1837. - №1707.


Pensacola Gazette. – 1837. - №4.


The Charleston Courier. – 1837. - №11,784. – Vol XXXVI.


The Daily Pittsburgh Gazette. – 1837. - №206.


The Leeds Mercury. – 1837. - № 5381.


The Morning Chronicle. - 1836. - December 20.


The Morning Chronicle. – 1837. – Jan.28. - № 20,977.


The Morning Chronicle. – 1837. - № 20,981.


The Morning Post – 1837. - № 20,643.


The Standard. – 1837. - № 3036.


The Sydney Morning Herald. – 1838.- № 678. – Vol. VIII.


The Times. – 1837. - № 16,333.


The York Gazette. – 1837. - № 1136.

Система Orphus

Loading...
Up