All
 
|
 
 


Paired Burials of Status Men and Women in the Necropolises of the “New Urban-Centres” of Rus’ People of the East European Plain of the 10th Century: Gender and Sociological Aspects
 
PIIS207987840031102-1-1
DOI10.18254/S207987840031102-1
Publication type Article
Status Published
Authors
Aleksandr Fetisov 
Affiliation: State Museum of Oriental Art
Address: Russian Federation, Moscow
Aleksey Schavelev
Affiliation: National Research University “Higher School of Economics”
Address: Russian Federation, Moscow
Journal nameISTORIYA
Edition
Abstract

The paper discusses the phenomenon of the so-called “paired burials” of men and women from burial grounds that accompanied the largest centres of urbanization of the East European Plain of the 10th century, associated with the settlement of the Rus’ people. Until now, practically no gender-sociological interpretations of this kind of burials have been proposed in historiography. Based on an analysis of a wide sample of burials from necropolises of various settlement centres of the East European Plain of the 10th century and some later Old Russian illustrative examples, it is concluded that in the communities of “new cities”, including groups of the Rus’ people, these were burials of completely equal men and women, most likely spouses (sexual partners) or relatives. The attribution of family burials shows that in these urban societies of the 10th century ideas of posthumous reunion of people connected by close and intimate relationships were widespread. It does not seem justified to associate the spread of these ideas only with the Christianization of the Rus’ people. In general, the elites of all these communities, including the Rus’ people, were distinguished by a high degree of equality of men and women; no clear signs of gender discrimination were found. The dominant hypothesis in historiography that the paired burials were burials of men and their forcibly killed slaves (concubines) is not confirmed by the analysis. The study was carried out within the framework of the project of the “International Center of Anthropology” of the ShIN FGN National Research University “Higher School of Economics” “Interaction of homoarchical and heterarchical cultures in various historical contexts”.

KeywordsRus people, 10th century, chronology, urban-centre, urban sociology, man and woman, gender history, gender archaeology, feminist theory
Received28.11.2023
Publication date15.07.2024
Number of characters42402
Cite  
100 rub.
When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 0, views: 148

Readers community rating: votes 0 

1. Avdusin D. A., Pushkina T. A. Tri pogrebal'nye kamery iz Gnezdova // Istoriya i kul'tura drevnerusskogo goroda. M: Izd. MGU, 1989. S. 190—205.
2. Androschuk F. Oseberg. Zagadki korolevskogo kurgana. Kiev: Laurus, 2017.
3. Buzhilova A. P. Parnye i sovmestnye srednevekovye pogrebeniya na Russkom Severe (po dannym antropologii) // Goroda i vesi srednevekovoj Rusi: arkheologiya, istoriya, kul'tura. M.; Vologda: Drevnosti Severa, 2015. S. 198—207.
4. Zharnov Yu. Eh. Gnezdovskie kurgany s ostatkami trupopolozheniya // Istoricheskaya arkheologiya: Traditsii i perspektivy. K 80-letiyu so dnya rozhdeniya D. A. Avdusina / pod red. T. A. Pushkinoj. M.: Pamyatniki istoricheskoj mysli, 1998. S. 92—105.
5. Zharnov Yu. Eh. Zhenskie skandinavskie pogrebeniya v Gnezdove // Smolensk i Gnezdovo (k istorii drevnerusskogo goroda). M.: Izd. MGU, 1991. S. 200—225.
6. Zharnov Yu. Eh. Pogrebal'nyj obryad v Drevnej Rusi po materialam Gnezdovskogo nekropolya. Diss. … kand. ist. nauk. M.: MGU, 1992.
7. Zozulya S. S. Kleschenko E. A. Kremirovannye ostanki iz kurgana Chernaya mogila v sobranii Istoricheskogo muzeya // Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta. Ser. 23. Antropologiya. 2019. № 1. S. 117—130.
8. Ibn Fadlan. Kniga Akhmada ibn Fadlana / per. s arab. i primech. V. S. Kuleshova // Puteshestvie Ibn Fadlana: Volzhskiĭ put' ot Bagdada do Bulgara. Katalog vystavki / Gosudarstvennyj Ehrmitazh. M.: Izdatel'skij dom Mardzhani, 2016. C. 18—55.
9. Ivakin V. G. Kievskie pogrebeniya X veka // Strarum Plus. Arkheologiya i kul'turnaya antropologiya. 2011. № 5. S. 243—286.
10. Kainov S. Yu. V poiskakh rannego Gnezdova (raskopki kurgana L-210 v Lesnoj kurgannoj gruppe) // Kraj Smolenskij. 2019. № 2. S. 50—52.
11. Kainov S. Yu. Pogrebeniya s predmetami vooruzheniya Gnezdovskogo nekropolya // Gnezdovskij arkheologicheskij kompleks. Materialy i issledovaniya. Vyp. 1 (Trudy Gosudarstvennogo istoricheskogo muzeya. Vyp. 210). M.: Izd. GIM, 2018. S. 211—240.
12. Karger M. K. Drevnij Kiev. Ocherki po istorii material'noj kul'tury drevnerusskogo goroda. T. I. M.; L.: Izd. AN SSSR, 1958.
13. Klejn L. S. Smyslovaya interpretatsiya sovmestnykh pogrebenij v stepnykh kurganakh Bronzovogo veka // Klejn L. S. Ehtnogenez i arkheologiya. T. II. Arii i Varia. SPb.: Evraziya, 2013. S. 26—30.
14. Kleschenko E. A., Kainov S. Yu., Svirkina N. G., Dobrovol'skaya E. V. Krematsii iz kurgana L-210 Gnezdovskogo mogil'nika: pervye rezul'taty kompleksnogo bioarkheologicheskogo issledovaniya // VIII Alekseevskie chteniya. Materialy konferentsii. M.: NII i Muzej antropologii MGU, 2019. S. 65—66.
15. Kozlov S. Basilikoi on the Routes of Gardariki // ISTORIYA. 2019. Vol. 10. Issue 9 (83). URL: https://history.jes.su/s207987840007494-2-1/  DOI: 10.18254/S207987840007494-2
16. Komarov K. I. Pogrebenie druzhinnika vo Vtorom Pekunovskom mogil'nike na Verkhnej Volge // Sovetskaya arkheologiya. 1974. № 3. S. 251—256.
17. Litovskikh E. The Demonstration of a High Status by Icelanders in Family Sagas // ISTORIYA. 2015. Vol. 6. Issue 1 (34). URL: https://history.jes.su/s207987840000957-1-2/ 
18. Makarov N. A. Kolonizatsiya severnykh okrain Drevnej Rusi v XI—XIII vekakh. M.: Skriptorij, 1997.
19. Makarov N. A. Mininskij arkheologicheskij kompleks: obschaya kharakteristika // Arkheologicheskoe izuchenie drevnerusskoj derevni X—XIII vekov // Arkheologiya severorusskoj derevni X—XIII vekov. Srednevekovye poseleniya i mogil'niki na Kubenskom ozere. T. I. Poseleniya i mogil'niki / otv. red. N. A. Makarov. M.: Nauka, 2007. S. 63—76.
20. Makarov N. A. Mogil'nik Minino II: opisanie pogrebal'nykh kompleksov // Arkheologicheskoe izuchenie drevnerusskoj derevni X—XIII vekov // Arkheologiya severorusskoj derevni X—XIII vekov. Srednevekovye poseleniya i mogil'niki na Kubenskom ozere. T. I. Poseleniya i mogil'niki / otv. red. N. A. Makarov. M.: Nauka, 2007. S. 233—338.
21. Makarov N. A. Na mogil'nom lozhe // Rodina. 2002. № 11-12. C. 118—123.
22. Makarov N. A., Zajtseva I. E. Mininskij arkheologicheskij kompleks: pogrebal'nye pamyatniki // Arkheologicheskoe izuchenie drevnerusskoj derevni X—XIII vv. // Arkheologiya severorusskoj derevni X—XIII vv. Srednevekovye poseleniya i mogil'niki na Kubenskom ozere. T. I. Poseleniya i mogil'niki / otv. red. N. A. Makarov. M.: Nauka, 2007. S. 120—182.
23. Melnikova E. Geopolitical and Geo-Economical Conditions of Emergence of Ancient Rus’ // ISTORIYA. 2012. Vol. 3. Issue 5 (13). URL: https://history.jes.su/s207987840000417-7-1/ 
24. Mikhajlov K. A. Ehlitarnyj pogrebal'nyj obryad Drevnej Rusi: kamernye pogrebeniya IX — nachala XI v. v kontekste severoevropejskikh analogij. SPb.: Branko, 2016.
25. Nedoshivina N. G., Fekhner M. V. Pogrebal'nyj obryad Timerevskogo mogil'nika // Sovetskaya arkheologiya. 1985. № 2. S. 101—115.
26. Petrukhin V. Ya. Skandinavskaya zhenschina na vostoke: zhena, rabynya ili «val'kiriya»? // Seks i ehrotika v russkoj traditsionnoj kul'ture / sost. A. L. Toporkov. M.: Ladomir, 1996. S. 31—42.
27. Sedova M. V. Suzdal' v X—XV vv. M.: Russkij mir, 1997.
28. Sergeeva Z. M. Kurgany u der. Bagrinovo vblizi drevnerusskogo Drutska // Kratkie soobscheniya instituta arkheologii. 1969. Vyp. 120. S. 107—111.
29. Tishin V. V., Seregin N. N. Polozhenie zhenschiny v drevnetyurkskom obschestve // Istoricheskaya psikhologiya i sotsiologiya istorii. 2015. № 1. S. 109—127.
30. Filipchuk A. Davnij Plicnes'k khristiyan'skij. L'viv: Davnij Plicnes'k, 2003. (Studia Historia. Vip. 3).
31. Shevchenko Yu. Yu. Knyazhna-amazonka v parnom pogrebenii Chyornoj mogily // Zhenschina i veschestvennyj mir kul'tury u narodov Rossii i Evropy. Sb. Muzeya antropologii i ehtnografii. T. XLVII. SPb.: Peterburgskoe vostokovedenie, 1999. S. 9—22.
32. Schavelev A. S. Rus' (narod); narod rus' do kontsa 9 veka; narod rus' v pervoj treti 10 v. — 970-kh gg.; narod rus' v 970-kh — seredine 11 v. // Bol'shaya rossijskaya ehntsiklopediya. Nauchno-obrazovatel'nyj ehntsiklopedicheskij portal «Znaniya». 2024. [Ehlektronnyj resurs]. URL: https://bigenc.ru/c/rus-narod-fa396e 
33. Schavelev A. S. Genezis drevnerusskoj arkheologicheskoj kul'tury kontsa IX — nachala XII v.: problemy i perspektivy kontseptualizatsii // Mul'tidistsiplinarnye issledovaniya v arkheologii. 2023. № 1. S. 28—55.
34. Schavelev A. S. Izvestie Ipat'evskoj letopisi o Chernoj mogile (K voprosu ob imeni pogrebennogo knyazya) // Chernigiv u seren'ovichnij ta rann'omodernij istoriï tsentral'no-skhidnoï evropii. Zbirnik naukovikh prats', prisvyachenij 1100-littyu pershoï litopisnoï zgadki pro Chernigiv. Chernigiv: Desnyans'ka pravda, 2007. S. 100—106.
35. Fetisov A., Schavelev A. The Map of Cultural-Archaeological Areas of Eastern-European Plain in the 10th Century (to the Problem Posed) // ISTORIYA. 2022. Vol. 13. Issue 5 (115). URL: https://history.jes.su/s207987840021547-0-1/  DOI: 10.18254/S207987840021547-0
36. Schavelev A. S., Fetisov A. A. Ehlita Syurnesgarda: k voprosu o sotsial'noj stratifikatsii naseleniya Gnyozdovskogo arkheologicheskogo kompleksa X — nachala XI vv. // Izvestiya Ural'skogo federal'nogo universiteta. Ser. 2: Gumanitarnye nauki. 2023. T. 25. № 2. S. 9—25.
37. Schapova J. Paradigm-pentad of Archaeological Sciences // ISTORIYA. 2014. Vol. 5. Issue 5 (28). URL: https://history.jes.su/s207987840000759-3-1/ 
38. Schapova J. Archaeological Diversity: Theoretical Context // ISTORIYA. 2017. Vol. 8. Issue 2 (56). URL: https://history.jes.su/s207987840001723-4-1/  DOI: 10.18254/S0001723-4-1
39. Arnold B. Gender and Archaeological Mortuary Analysis // Handbook of Gender in Archaeology / ed. by Nelson S. M. Lanham; N. Y.; Toronto; Oxford: AltaMira Press, 2006. P. 137—170.
40. Gardeła L. Woman & Weapons in the Viking World. Amazons of the North. Oxford; Philadelphia: Oxbow Books, 2012.
41. Ghisleni L., Jordan A., Fiocooprile E. Introduction to “Binary Binds”: Deconstructing Sex and Gender Dichotomies in Archaeological Practice // Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory. 2016. Vol. 23. Is. 3. P. 1—35.
42. Hedenstierna-Jonson Ch., Kjellström A., Zachrisson T., Krzewińska M., Sobrado V., Price N., Günther T., Jakobsson M., Götherström A., Storå J. A Female Viking Warrior Confirmed by Genomics // American journal of physical anthropology. 2017. № 164 (4). P. 1—8.
43. Ivakin V. G. Burial Grounds & Graves in Medieval Kiev (9th to 13th Century) // Rome, Constantinople and Newly Converted Europe. Archaeological and Historical Evidence / eds. by M. Salamon, M. Hardt, M. P. Kruk, A. E. Musin, P. Špehar, A. Sulikowska-Gąska, M. Wołoszyn. Kraków; Leipzig; Rzeszów: CZWO, 2011.
44. Jordan A. “Am No Man”: A Study of Warrior Women in the Archaeological Record // Field Notes: A Journal of Collegiate Anthropology. 2009. Vol. 1. P. 94—110.
45. Kainov S. The “Large” Sword from Chorna Mohyla: Preliminary Results of a New Study // A Viking Century Chernihiv Area from 900 to 1000 AD / ed. by S. Stepanenko. Paris: ACHCByz, 2022. P. 153—172.
46. Liwoch R. Zabytki z wykopalisk Teodora Nieszuja-Ziemięckigo w latopisowym Pleśnisku (Podhorce na Ukrainie). Kraków: Ekodruk, 2018.
47. Murasheva V. V., Kainov S. Yu., Kovalenko E. S., Podurets K. M., Glazkov V. P., Murashev M. M., Chichaev I. A., Presniakova N. N., Tereschenko E. Yu., Retilov V. M., Yatsishina E. B. ‘Barbarian Scepters’ of the Viking Age from the Chernaya Mogila Burial Mound at Chernigov (present-day Ukraine) // Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports. 2021. № 37. P. 1—11.
48. Stalsberg A. The Interpretations of Women’s Objects of Scandinavian Origin from the Viking Period Found in Russia // Were They All Men? An Examination of Sex Roles in Prehistoric Society. Acts of a Workshop Held at Utstein Kloster. Stavanger: Arkeologisk Museum i Stavanger, 1987. P. 33—49.
49. Stalsberg A. Visible Women Made Invisible, Interpreting Varangian Women in Old Russia // Gender and the Archaeology of Death / ed. by B. Arnold, L. N. Wicker. Walnut Creek: AltaMira Press, 2001. P. 65—80.
50. Stalsberg A. Women as Actors in North European Viking Age Trade // Social Approaches to Viking Studies / ed. by R. Samson. Glasgow: Cruithne Press, 1991. P. 75—83.
51. Blifel'd D. I. Davn'orus'ki pam’yatki Shestovitsi. Kiïv: Naukova dumka, 1977.
52. Motsya A. P. Pogrebal'nye pamyatniki yuzhnorusskikh zemel' ІKh—KhSh vv. Kiev: Naukova dumka, 1990.
53. Motsya O., Kazakov A. Davn'orus'kij Chernigiv. Kiïv: Starodavnij Svit, 2011.

Система Orphus

Loading...
Up