Ban as a Political Instrument in the Russian Church of the Middle 11th Century New Data about Luka Zhidyata

The article deals with the biography of Luka Zhidyata, the Bishop of Novgorod. The mention of the consecration of St. Sophia of Novgorod by him probably dates back to the “Primary Chronicle”. Information of the chronicles about his three-year suspension and imprisonment in Kiev is compared with the norms of Byzantine canon law. The only rule by which Luka could be subjected to such punishment is a ban for clerics to play dice or communicate with the players. Such an accusation clarifies the role of his servant Dudika in in Luka’s process. The reason for the punishment of Luka by Metropolitan Ephraim was not revenge after Yaroslav's death for his participating in the election of Hilarion and the appointment of new Russian bishops in 1051, but rather the precarious political situation of Ephraim himself after 1054 and Luka's possible attempt to obtain the status of archbishopric for Novgorod.

Keywords

Russian Metropolis, Novgorod, 11th century, Luke Zhidyata, canon law

Received

13.06.2021

Publication date

18.10.2021

Number of characters

42324

Cite

GOST	Vinogradov A. Ban as a Political Instrument in the Russian Church of the Middle 11th Century New Data about Luka Zhidyata // ISTORIYA – 2021. – V. 12. – Issue 9 (107) [Electronic resource]. URL: https://history.jes.su/S207987840017171-7-1 (circulation date: 19.05.2024). DOI: 10.18254/S207987840017171-7
MLA	Vinogradov, Andrey "Ban as a Political Instrument in the Russian Church of the Middle 11th Century New Data about Luka Zhidyata." ISTORIYA 12.9 (107) (2021) DOI: 10.18254/S207987840017171-7
APA	Vinogradov A. (2021). Ban as a Political Instrument in the Russian Church of the Middle 11th Century New Data about Luka Zhidyata. ISTORIYA 12(9 (107)) DOI: 10.18254/S207987840017171-7

100 rub.

When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 0, views: 246

Readers community rating: votes 0

1. Artamonov Yu. A. «Gipoteza, vystroennaya na gipotezakh»: po povodu novogo issledovaniya A. Poppeh // Vestnik tserkovnoj istorii. 2013. № 1-2 (29-30).

2. Barmin A. V. Protivolatinskaya polemika Drevnej Rusi: vizantijskie paralleli // Vizantijskij vremennik. 2010. T. 69.

3. Vilkul T. L. Novgorodskaya pervaya letopis' i Nachal'nyj svod // Palaeoslavica. 2003. T. 11.

4. Vinogradov A. Yu. Sv. Sofiya Kievskaya v kontekste vizantijskoj arkhitektury 2 chetv. XI v. // Khram i lyudi. Zbirka statej do 90-richchya z dnya narodzhennya S. O. Visots'kogo. Kiev, 2013.

5. Vinogradov A. Yu. O khronologii russkikh mitropolitov XI v. (po povodu novoj gipotezy A. P. Tolochko) // Slovĕne. 2019. 8.1. T. 8.1.

6. Vinogradov A. Yu. O vremeni sozdaniya Rostovskoj episkopii // Istoriya i kul'tura Rostovskoj zemli. 2019. Rostov, 2020.

7. Vinogradov A., Zheltov M. Life and Death of Theodorets of Vladimir: Justice or Reprisal? // ISTORIYA. 2019. Vol. 10. Issue 10 (84). URL: https://history.jes.su/s207987840008052-6-1/ DOI: 10.18254/S207987840008052-6

8. Vinogradov A. Yu., Zheltov M., svyasch. Poryadok vstupleniya ierarkhov na kafedru v domongol'skoj Rusi i voprosy khronologii pervykh mitropolitov Kievskikh // Bogoslovskie trudy. 2019. T. 49.

9. Gajdenko P. I. O prave suda nad episkopatom na Rusi (XI—XIII vv.). Postanovka problemy // Khristianskoe chtenie. 2020. № 1.

10. Gimon T. V. Sobytiya XI — nachala XII vv. v novgorodskikh letopisyakh i perechnyakh // Drevnejshie gosudarstva Vostochnoj Evropy, 2010 g.: Predposylki i puti obrazovaniya Drevnerusskogo gosudarstva. M., 2012.

11. Gimon T. V. Ustnaya traditsiya o sobytiyakh XI v. v srednevekovom Novgorode // Drevnejshie gosudarstva Vostochnoj Evropy, 2016 g.: Pamyati G. V. Glazyrinoj. M., 2018.

12. Gimon T. Esche raz o vremeni uchrezhdeniya Novgorodskoj arkhiepiskopii // Christian Russia in the Making. In memory of Professor Andrzej Poppe (12 July 1928 — 31 January 2019). Warsaw, 2020.

13. Gippius A. A. K istorii slozheniya teksta Novgorodskoj pervoj letopisi // Novgorodskij istoricheskij sbornik. 1997. T. 6 (16).

14. Gippius A. A. K prochteniyu nadpisi № 1541 Sofii Kievskoj // Vostochnaya Evropa v drevnosti i srednevekov'e. XXVIII Chteniya pamyati chlena-korrespondenta AN SSSR Vladimira Terent'evicha Pashuto. Moskva, 20—22 aprelya 2016. M., 2016.

15. Gippius A. A. Kleveta na episkopa Luku: ehpigraficheskie svidetel'stva letopisnogo ehpizoda // Trudy otdela drevnerusskoj literatury. 2016. T. 64.

16. Gippius A. A. K voprosu o vremeni uchrezhdeniya novgorodskoj arkhiepiskopii // Kompleksnyj podkhod v izuchenii Drevnej Rusi. Materialy Kh Mezhdunarodnoj nauchnoj konferentsii, 9—13 sentyabrya 2019 g., Moskva, Rossiya. M., 2019.

17. Dergacheva I. V. Novgorodskij vladyka Luka Zhidyata i ego pouchenie // Drevnyaya Rus'. Voprosy medievistiki. 2013. Vyp. 3 (53).

18. Dergacheva I. V., Mil'kov V. V., Mil'kova S. V. Luka Zhidyata: svyatitel', pisatel', myslitel'. M., 2016 //Pamyatniki drevnerusskoj mysli: issledovaniya i teksty. Vyp. IX.

19. Ioannisyan O. M., Yolshin D. D., Zykov P. L., Ivakin G. Yu., Kozyuba V. K., Komar A. V., Lukomskij Yu. V. Desyatinnaya tserkov' v Kieve (predvaritel'nye itogi issledovanij 2005—2007 gg.) // Slozhenie russkoj gosudarstvennosti v kontekste rannesrednevekovoj istorii Starogo sveta. SPb., 2009.

20. Maksimovich K. A. Novella CXXIII sv. imperatora Yustiniana I (527—565 gg.) «O razlichnykh tserkovnykh voprosakh» (perevod i kommentarij) // Vestnik PSTGU. 2007. Vyp. 3 (19).

21. Mil'kov V. V. Novgorodskij svyatitel' Luka: Kharakter deyatel'nosti i idejnye aspekty tvorchestva // Novgorodskaya zemlya v ehpokhu Yaroslava Mudrogo. Velikij Novgorod, 2010.

22. Nazarenko A. V. Drevnyaya Rus' i slavyane. M., 2009.

23. Nazarenko A. V. Dudika, Negvar': dva germanskikh antroponima v novgorodskikh pamyatnikakh // Slověne. 2015. T. 4.1.

24. Pechnikov M. V. «A se novgorodskyi episkopy»: Spornye voprosy rannej tserkovnoj istorii Novgoroda (konets X — 70-e gg. XI v.) // Vestnik tserkovnoj istorii. 2015. Vyp. 3/4 (39/40).

25. Poppeh A. Studity na Rusi: Istoki i nachal'naya istoriya Kievo-Pecherskogo monastyrya. Kiїv, 2011 // Ruthenica. Supplementum. 3.

26. Rybina E. A., Rozenfel'dt R. L. Igry vzroslykh i detej // Arkheologiya: Drevnyaya Rus'. Byt i kul'tura. M., 1997.

27. Sedov Vl. V. Osnovnye rezul'taty raskopok tserkvi Blagovescheniya na Gorodische v 2016—2017 gg.: arkheologiya i arkhitektura // Arkhitekturnaya arkheologiya. 2019. T. 1.

28. Sivak S. I. O derevyannoj Sofii v Novgorode // Russia mediaevalis. 1992. Vol. 7.

29. Tolochko A. P. Zamechaniya o pervykh mitropolitakh kievskikh // Vertograd mnogotsvetnyj. Sbornik k 80-letiyu Borisa Nikolaevicha Flori. M., 2018.

30. Khamajko N. V. Osoblivostі ta kharakter davn'orus'koї gri u «Tavlії» u pisemnikh ta epіchnikh zgadkakh // Arkheologіya і davnya іstorіya Ukraїni. 2016. № 3 (20).

31. Chichurov I. Skhizma 1054 g. i antilatinskaya polemika v Kieve (ser. XI — nach. XII v.) // Russia mediaevalis. 1996. T. 9.

32. Shakhmatov A. A. Razyskaniya o drevnejshikh russkikh letopisnykh svodakh. SPb., 1908.

33. Chrysos E. Zur Entstehung der Institution der autokephalen Erzbistümer // Byzantinische Zeitschrift. 1969. Bd. 62.