Repressed Vainakhs in the Social Memory of Deported Kalmyks

The article is devoted to problems regarding the perception of representatives of repressed Chechens in the social memory of repressed Kalmyks and its pragmatics, which have not been posed earlier in Russian anthropology. The sources used are field materials collected by the author, as well as published memories of the deportation of the Kalmyks and materials posted on Facebook by the Chechen group “We Remember. Deportation and return”. Results: Both exiled peoples had the status of “punished peoples”. But in the social memory of the Kalmyks, there remained exactly what the Chechens differed by - the practices of Islam, adherence to Sharia law and adat, gender traditions (polygamy, etc.) — those practices that reflected the identity of the ethnic group and worked to unite it. The Kalmyks remembered what seemed unusual, and single examples were carried over to the whole group. This essentialization of ethnicity in memory reflected a traumatic past and attempts for reconciliation with it.

Keywords

Vainakhs, Kalmyks, Chechens, deportation of Kalmyks, repressions, “punished peoples”, Siberia, spetspereselentsy, social memory

Received

09.08.2021

Publication date

15.11.2021

Number of characters

61307

Cite

GOST	Guchinova E. Repressed Vainakhs in the Social Memory of Deported Kalmyks // ISTORIYA – 2021. – V. 12. – Issue 10 (108) [Electronic resource]. URL: https://history.jes.su/S207987840017090-8-1 (circulation date: 17.05.2024). DOI: 10.18254/S207987840017090-8
MLA	Guchinova, Elza-Bair "Repressed Vainakhs in the Social Memory of Deported Kalmyks." ISTORIYA 12.10 (108) (2021) DOI: 10.18254/S207987840017090-8
APA	Guchinova E. (2021). Repressed Vainakhs in the Social Memory of Deported Kalmyks. ISTORIYA 12(10 (108)) DOI: 10.18254/S207987840017090-8

100 rub.

When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 1, views: 268

Readers community rating: votes 0

1. Aleksander D. Smysly sotsial'noj zhizni: kul'tur-sotsiologiya / per. s angl. G. Ol'khovikova. M.: Praksis, 2013.

2. Arlyapova E. S. Deportatsiya chechentsev i ingushej 1944—1957 g. Stanovlenie istoriografii // Istoricheskie zapiski. Sbornik nauchnykh trudov / pod red. Pervushkina V. I. Vyp.15. Penza: GUMNITs, 2011. S. 216—224.

3. Assman A. Dlinnaya ten' proshlogo. Memorial'naya kul'tura i istoricheskaya politika. M.: NLO, 2014.

4. Baberovski J. Vyzhzhennaya zemlya. Stalinskoe tsarstvo nasiliya. M: ROSSPEhN, 2014.

5. Bart F. (red.) Ehtnicheskie gruppy i sotsial'nye granitsy. Sotsial'naya organizatsiya kul'turnykh razlichij / per. s angl. I. Pil'schikova. M.: Novoe izdatel'stvo, 2006.

6. Batukaeva Z. A. Tajny semejnogo arkhiva brat'ev Nalaevykh // «Marsho». 5 fevralya 2010. № 13-14.

7. Bezugol'nyj A. Yu., Bugaj N. F, Krinko E. F. Gortsy Severnogo Kavkaza v Velikoj Otechestvennoj vojne 1941—1945. Problemy istorii, istoriografii i istochnikovedeniya. M.: Tsentrpoligraf, 2012.

8. Bugaj N. F. Operatsiya «Ulusy». Ehlista: «Dzhangar», 1991.

9. Bugaj N. F., Gonov A. M. Kavkaz: Narody v ehshelonakh (20—60-e gg.). M.: Insan, 1998.

10. Vajnakhi i imperskaya vlast': problema Chechni i Ingushetii vo vnutrennej politike Rossii i SSSR (nachalo XIX — seredina KhKh vv.). / pod red. Kruglova i dr. M.: ROSSPEhN, 2010.

11. «GAZ. Russkie mashiny. Doroga dlinoj v 70 let». Fil'm T. Bekmambetova i B. Kilimbaeva [Ehlektronnyj resurs]. URL: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NJ3NVV7oCzA (data obrascheniya: 18.08.2021).

12. Gakaev Dzh. Ocherki politicheskoj istorii Chechni (KhKh v.). M.: ChKZ, 1997.

13. Guchinova Eh.-B. M. Ulitsa «Kalmyk roud». Istoriya, kul'tura i identichnosti kalmytskoj obschiny SShA. SPb: Aletejya, 2004.

14. Guchinova Eh.-B. M. U kazhdogo svoya Sibir'. Dve istorii o deportatsii kalmykov // Antropologicheskij forum. 2005. № 3. C. 400—442.

15. Guchinova Eh.-B. Pomnit' nel'zya zabyt': antropologiya deportatsionnoj travmy kalmykov. Shtutgart, 2005.

16. Guchinova Eh.-B. M. U kazhdogo svoya Sibir'. Ssyl'nye kalmyki v Srednej Azii // Diaspory. 2008. № 1. C. 194—220.

17. Guchinova Eh.-B. M. Diskursivnye strategii narrativa o Shiroklage // Magna absurgit. 2019. № 1. C. 7—22. DOI 10.22162/2541-9749-2019-7-1-7-22.

18. Guchinova Eh.-B. M. U kazhdogo svoya Sibir'. Gody vojny i deportatsii v monologakh L. T. Dordzhieva i E. S. Basanovoj // Oriental Studies. 2020. T. 13. № 4. S. 976—1011. DOI: 10.22162/2619-0990-2020-50-4-976–1011.

19. Guchinova Eh.-B. Ehtnicheskaya identichnost' kak stigma: kalmyki v deportatsii (1943—1956 gg.) // Antropologicheskij forum. 2020b. № 47. S. 154—180. DOI: 10.31250/1815-8870-2020-16-47-154-180.

20. Guchinova Eh.-B. M. U kazhdogo svoya Sibir': dva zhenskikh rasskaza o deportatsii kalmykov // Mongolovedenie. 2020v. № 4. S. 778—800. DOI: 10.22162/2500-1523-2020-4-778-800.

21. Ermekbaev Zh. A, Isakieva Z. S. Ehtnografiya zhizni chechentsev v Tsentral'nom Kazakhstane // Teoriya i praktika obschestvennogo razvitiya. 2014. № 20 [Ehlektronnyj resurs]. URL: http://teoria-practica.ru/rus/files/arhiv_zhurnala/2014/20/history/yermekbayev-isakiyeva (data obrascheniya: 01.05.2021).

22. Il'miev B. «Belaya kniga». Groznyj; Alma-Ata, 1991 // Arkhiv pamyati: 1944—1957 [Ehlektronnyj resurs]. URL: https://telegra.ph/Arhiv-pamyati-1944-1957-04-22 (data obrascheniya: 23.08.2021).

23. Isakieva Z. S. K voprosu o deportatsii chechenskogo i ingushskogo narodov v 1944 g. // Nauchnye problemy gumanitarnykh issledovanij. 2010. № 3. S. 36—42.

24. Karpov Yu. Yu., Kapustina E. L. Gortsy posle gor. Migratsionnye protsessy v Dagestane v XX — nachale XXI vv.: ikh sotsial'nye i ehtnokul'turnye posledstviya i perspektivy. SPb: Peterburgskoe Vostokovedenie, 2011.

25. Kozlov V. A., Kozlova M. E., Benvenuti F. Paradoksy ehtnicheskogo vyzhivaniya (1944 — nachalo 1960-kh gg.). Stalinskaya ssylka i repatriatsiya chechentsev i ingushej posle Vtoroj mirovoj vojny. SPb: Nestor-Istoriya: 2016.

26. Koryukhin D. A. Problemy istoricheskoj pamyati i rossijskoj identichnosti u chechenskoj molodezhi // Istoricheskaya pamyat' i rossijskaya identichnost' na Severnom Kavkaze / pod red. A. K. Alikberova. M., 2017. S. 71—79.

27. Mamaeva G. E. Vyselenie chechentsev v Semipalatinskuyu oblast' // Sotsial'no-ehkonomicheskie i kul'turnye protsessy v Verkhnem Priirtysh'e v XVII–XX vv.: sb. materialov mezhdunarodnoj nauchnoj konferentsii. Novosibirsk, 2011. S. 244—248.

28. Maksimov K. N. Velikaya Otechestvennaya vojna: Kalmykiya i kalmyki. 2-e izd., dop. M.: Nauka, 2010.

29. My — iz vyslannykh navechno. Vospominaniya deportirovannykh kalmykov 1943—1957 / sost., red. P. O. Godaev. Ehlista: Izd-vo KGU, 2003.

30. Nekrich A. M. Nakazannye narody. N'yu-Jork, 1978.

31. Osmaev A. FB ot 15.01.2021 [Ehlektronnyj resurs]. URL: https://www.facebook.com/groups/23021944.ru (data obrascheniya: 23.08.2021).

32. Ochirov U. B. Voennye mobilizatsii v Kalmytskoj ASSR // Velikaya Otechestvennaya vojna: sobytiya, lyudi, istoriya: sb. nauch. st. Ehlista. 2001. S. 45—64.

33. Polyan P. M. Ne po svoej vole… Istoriya i geografiya prinuditel'nykh migratsij v SSSR. M.: OGI. 2001.

34. Polyan P. M. Deportatsii i ehtnichnost' // Stalinskie deportatsii. 1928—1953. M., 2005.

35. Polyan P. M. Kosa i kamen': konfliktnyj ehtnos v krepchayuschikh ob'yatiyakh Sovetskoj vlasti «Zvezda». 2007. № 12 S. 119—150.

36. Pol' M. Neuzheli ehti zemli mogilami nashimi stanut? Chechentsy i ingushi v Kazakhstane (1944—1957) // Diaspory. 2008. № 2. S. 158—204.

37. Solzhenitsyn A. I. Arkhipelag GULAG, 1918—1956: Opyt khudozhestvennogo issledovaniya: V 3 t. M.: Sov. Pisatel': Nov. mir, 1989. T. 3. S. 385—404.

38. Tishkov V. A. Obschestvo v vooruzhennom konflikte. Ehtnografiya chechenskoj vojny. M.: Nauka, 2001.

39. Uralov A. (Avtorkhanov A.) Ubijstvo checheno-ingushskogo naroda: narodoubijstvo v SSSR. M.: Vsya Moskva, 1991.

40. Ubushaev V. B. Kalmyki: vyselenie i vozvraschenie (1944—1957 gg.). Ehlista: «Sanan», 1991.

41. Khataev A. Ts. Ehshelony bespraviya. M: «Violanta», 1997.

42. Khal'bvaks M. Sotsial'nye ramki pamyati / per. Zenkina. M.: Novoe izdatel'stvo, 2007.

43. Shnirel'man V. A. Byt' alanami. Intellektualy i politika na Severnom Kavkaze v XX v. M.: «Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie», 2006.

44. Conquest R. The nation killers: The Soviet deportation of nationalities. L.: Macmillan, 1978.

45. Gall C., De Waal T. Chechnya: A Small Victorious War. L., 1997.

46. Lieven A. Chechnya: Tombstone of Russian Power. Bolton, 1998.

47. Smith S. Allah’s Mountains: The Battle for Chechnya. L.; N. Y., 2001.

48. Wakamiya L. R. Post-Soviet Contexts and Trauma Studies // Slavonica. 2011. Vol. 17. № 2. November. P. 134–144.