Samoyeds at the Budapest Zoo in 1882: Exploitation or Collaboration?

The article explores the history of the exhibit of a group of five Samoyeds in the Zoological Garden of Budapest in June-July 1882. A special attention is given to issues of organizing the Samoyeds’ trip to Europe, to the prehistory of their exhibiting, to the specific cultural context presenting them in Hungary, where the Samoyeds were presented as distant relatives of the Hungarians, one of the authors of that time even wrote about “brothers in the zoo”. Particular attention is also paid to the question of whether the Samoyeds were exposed to their exploitation by the impresario, or the Samoyeds actively and voluntarily participated in this show, independently defining the boundaries of their participation. It is noted that although the texts talk about the diseases of the Samoyeds, about making them drinking alcohol, about unusual food for them, about their melancholy, and finally, about the death of one of them in the same summer, at the same time they also mention their pride in themselves, about their gaiety, enterprise, the ability to dashingly drive a sled with reindeer, etc. As a result, the indications of the texts look contradictory, which reflects both the literary structure of the studied texts and the complex reality of the exhibitions themselves, in which the Samoyeds took part in Budapest and other cities.

Keywords

ethnic exhibitions, Samoyeds, Nenets people, Zoo, Budapest, Hungary, Russia, Mezen, inequality ideologies, nationalism, racism

Received

19.11.2020

Publication date

19.07.2021

Number of characters

38198

Cite

GOST	Savitskiy E. Samoyeds at the Budapest Zoo in 1882: Exploitation or Collaboration? // ISTORIYA – 2021. – V. 12. – Issue 6 (104) [Electronic resource]. URL: https://history.jes.su/S207987840016258-2-1 (circulation date: 18.05.2024). DOI: 10.18254/S207987840016258-2
MLA	Savitskiy, Evgeniy "Samoyeds at the Budapest Zoo in 1882: Exploitation or Collaboration?." ISTORIYA 12.6 (104) (2021) DOI: 10.18254/S207987840016258-2
APA	Savitskiy E. (2021). Samoyeds at the Budapest Zoo in 1882: Exploitation or Collaboration?. ISTORIYA 12(6 (104)) DOI: 10.18254/S207987840016258-2

100 rub.

When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 0, views: 180

Readers community rating: votes 0

1. Dobrovol'skij V. N. Smolenskij ehtnograficheskij sbornik. Ch. 2. SPb.: Tip. E. Evdokimova, 1893.

2. Zefel'd A. Dvadtsatipyatiletie S.-Peterburgskogo zoologicheskogo sada, 1865—1890. Istoricheskij ocherk. SPb.: Tip. Eh. Goppe, 1890.

3. Laplandtsy na Neve // Vsemirnaya illyustratsiya. 1880. T. 23. № 582.

4. Leskinen M. V. «Chto my, Gagenbeki kakie, chto li?» Lyudi v zoosadakh Rossijskoj imperii // Antropologicheskij forum. № 43.

5. Mirzekhanov V. Nation in the Imperial and Post-Imperial Dimension: the Multidimensionality of the Historical Experience of the 19th — 21st Centuries // ISTORIYA. 2018. Vol. 9. Issue 8 (72). URL: https://history.jes.su/s207987840002436-8-1/ DOI: 10.18254/S0002436-8-1

6. Myur V. K. Peterburgskie stseny i tipy: Yurta samoedov i oleni na Neve // Vsemirnaya illyustratsiya. 1877. T. 17. № 482.

7. Savitskij E. E. Demony v zooparke: Sovremennoe iskusstvo i kolonizatsiya Severa v Rossii 1890-kh gg. // Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. 2017. № 2 (144).

8. Savitskij E. E. Kak kupets Kalintsov v Vene v 1882 godu samoedov pokazyval: pokornost' i soprotivlenie «vse ravno chto zhivotnykh» // Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. 2020. № 1 (161).

9. Khomich A. V Nentsy: Istoriko-ehtnograficheskie ocherki. M., L.: Nauka, 1966.

10. A szamojédok // Borsszem Janko. 16 Julius 1882. 757 (29) szám.

11. Andreassen R. Human Exhibitions: Race, Gender and Sexuality in Ethnic Displays. L.: Ashgate, 2015.

12. Budenz J. Adalék a jurák-szamojed nyelv ismeretéhez // Nyelvtudományi Közlemények. 1890. Vol. 22. № 2.

13. Budenz J. Jurák-szamojed szójegyzék // Nyelvtudományi Közlemények. 1891. Vol. 22. № 5.

14. Czarnecka D. “A w niedzielę szło się oglądać ludzi”: Pokazy etnograficzne we wrocławskim ogrodzie zoologicznym 1876—1930 // Etnografia Polska. 2018. Vol. 62. № 1-2.

15. D. Die Schlittenfahrt der Samojeden auf einer Berliner Eisbahn // Über Land und Meer: Allgemeine Illustrierte Zeitung. 1883. Jg. 49. №. 20.

16. Demski D. Spaces of Modernity: Ethnic Shows in Poznań, 1879—1914 // East Central Europe. 2020. Vol. 47. № 2-3.

17. Dreesbach A. Kalmücken im Hofbräuhaus. Die Vermarktung von Schaustellungen fremder Menschen am Beispiel München // Exotica. Konsum und Inszenierung des Fremden im 19. Jahrhundert / hg. H.-P. Bayerdörfer, E. Hellmuth. Münster: Lit, 2003.

18. Happel J. Nomadenbilder um 1900: das Beispiel der Basler Völkerschauen // Basler Zeitschrift für Geschichte und Altertumskunde. 2007. Vol. 107.

19. J. v. Die Samojeden // Die Gartenlaube 1883. № 6.

20. Kollmann J. Beiträge zur Rassen-Anatomie der Indianer, Samojeden und Australier // Verhandlungen der Naturforschenden Gesellschaft in Basel. 1884. Bd. 7. № 3.

21. Kontler L. Relocating the “Human Zoo”: Exotic Displays, Metropolitan Identity and Ethnographic Knowledge in Late Nineteenth-Century Budapest // East Central Europe. 2020. Vol. 47. № 2-3.

22. Matiegka H. Der Schädel des Samojeden Wasko // Mittheilungen der Anthropologischen Gesellschaft in Wien. 1893. Bd. 23.

23. Meißner J. Feuilleton: Naturwissenschaftliche Rundschau // Deutsche Zeitung. 1882. № 3692.

24. Müller F. Einleitung zu: Szombathy J. Abbildungen von fünf Jurak-Samojeden // Mittheilungen der Anthropologischen Gesellschaft in Wien. 1886. Bd. 16.

25. Photographies anthropologiques // Bulletin de la Société d’anthropologie de Lyon. 1883. № 2.

26. Schwarz W. M. Anthropologische Spektakel: Zur Schaustellung “exotischer” Menschen, Wien 1870—1910. Wien: Turia und Kant, 2001.

27. Soma S. Atyafiak a budapesti állatkertben // Szarvasi ujsag. 1882. 28-ik szám. Julius 9-en.

28. Staehelin B. Völkerschauen im Zoologischen Garten Basel, 1879—1935. Basel: Basler Afrika Bibliographien, 1993.

29. Szamojéd scalád Budapesten // Vasárnagi újság. 1882. № 28.

30. Szombathy J. Abbildungen von fünf Jurak-Samojeden // Mittheilungen der Anthropologischen Gesellschaft in Wien. 1886 Bd. 16.

31. Thode-Arora H. “Charakteristische Gestalten des Volkslebens”: Die Hagenbeckschen Südasien-, Orient- und Afrika-Völkerschauen // Fremde Erfahrungen. Asiaten und Afrikaner in Deutschland, Österreich und in der Schweiz bis 1945 / hg. G.Höpp. Berlin: Das Arab. Buch, 1996.