A Person in a Totalitarian State. Article One: War and Fear

 
PIIS023620070009632-2-1
DOI10.31857/S023620070009632-2
Publication type Article
Status Published
Authors
Occupation: Chief Research Fellow, Head of the Philosophy of Culture Sector
Affiliation: RAS Institute of Philosophy
Address: 2/1 Goncharnaya Str., Moscow 109240, Russian Federation
Journal nameChelovek
EditionVolume 31 Issue №2
Pages128-149
Abstract

Just as totalitarianism of the Soviet type determined the nature, consciousness, and features of human existence in peacetime, so, if not to a greater extent, with the beginning of the great Patriotic war, it affected the consciousness and actions of the fighting person. The first post-war reflections on this subject were offered in the military prose of wartime writers — in the novel “Cursed and killed” by Viktor Astafiev, in the stories of Vasil Bykov, as well as in the novel “Life and fate” by the war correspondent Vasily Grossman.

Having arisen in the USSR with the beginning of Stalin's rule, totalitarianism quickly found its own fundamental basis — the fear based on the human instinct of self-preservation. It was fear, fueled by often purposeless, but constant and brutal repression, that took hold of Soviet society so much that, along with political and organizational factors, it became one of the causes of the large-scale catastrophic defeats of the beginning of the great Patriotic war. The definition of the Patriotic war not only as a people's war, but also as a war of the totalitarian state, does not agree with the position that Stalin's wartime totalitarianism with its characteristic cruelty was necessary, that its critical analysis is not permissible and should be regarded as anti-Patriotic.

The article attempts to show that Soviet totalitarianism had historical roots, and in the war not only did not contribute to, but objectively prevented the victory over fascism. Totalitarianism reduced the human warrior to the level of a means of solving problems, created conditions in which courage and professionalism gave way to fear and cowardice, often gave rise to the desire in the moods of people to please the leader and his inner circle at any cost, in general, was the enemy of a free man and if possible destroyed such a person.

Keywordsman, war, totalitarianism, autocracy, politics, masses, movements, freedom, heroism, cowardice
Received09.05.2020
Publication date15.05.2020
Number of characters46669
Cite  
100 rub.
When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 0, views: 817

Readers community rating: votes 0

1. Aleksievich S. “Nas uchat tol'ko tomu, kak umeret' za Rodinu”: Interv'yu [We are only taught how to die for our Country: Interview]. Meduza. URL: https://meduza.io/feature/2020/02/18/ya-vsyu-zhizn-prozhila-v-strane-politsaev?utm_source=facebook.com&utm_medium=share_fb&utm_campaign=share&fbclid=IwAR2RIhrx6fWzYB052J2nJ1gSEw9GBLxNXa8M4DLuAoF3s9a8NYOcnt65GF0 (date of access: 03.02.2020).

2. Arendt H. Istoki totalitarizma [The origins of Totalitarianism]. Мoscow: CentrKom Publ., 1996.

3. Astafyev V. Proklyaty i ubity [The Cursed and the Slain]. Мoscow: Eksmo Publ., 2007.

4. Astafyev V.P. Moya voina. Pisatel' v okopah. Voina glazami soldata [My War. Writer in the Trenches. War Through the Eyes of a Soldier]. Мoscow: ООО “ТD Algorithm” Publ., 2012.

5. Beshanov V.V. Stalin — grobovshchik Krasnoi Armii. Glavnyi vinovnik katastrofy 1941 goda [Stalin — the Undertaker of the Red Army. The Main Culprit of the Disaster in 1941]. Мoscow: Yauza-press Publ., 2012.

6. Bykov V.V. Dozhit' do rassveta [To Live Till Sunrise]. Мoscow: Eksmo Publ., 2010.

7. Bykov V.V. Цитаты [Quotes]. Sinergiya. 2020. URL: http://www.sinergialib.ru/index.php?section_id=3234&id=5003&view=print (date of access: 03.02.2020).

8. Gorbatov A.V. Gody i voiny [Years and War]. Мoscow: Voenizdat Publ., 1989. (Voennye memuary [War Memoirs]).

9. Grossman V.S. Zhizn' i sud'ba [Life and Fate]. Kharkiv; Belgorod: Book Club “Family Leisure Club” Publ., 2016.

10. Isaev A.V. Neizvestnyi 1941. Ostanovlennyi blickrig [Unknown 1941. Stopped Blitzkrieg]. Мoscow: Yauza: Eksmo Publ., 2012.

11. Neretina S.S., Nikolsky S.A., Porus V.N. Filosofskaya antropologiya Andreya Platonova [Philosophical Anthropology of Andrey Platonov]. Мoscow: RAS Institute of Philosophy Publ., 2019.

12. Nikolsky S.A. Rossiyskaya filosofiya istorii: opit ponimania [Russian Philosophy of History: an Experience of Understanding]. Filosofskiy jurnal. 2018. Vol. 11, N 4.

13. Platonov A.P. Efirnyi trakt. Povesti 1920-h — nachala 1930-h godov [Etheric Tract. Stories of the 1920s and early 1930s]. Мoscow: Time Publ., 2011.

14. Solonin М.S. 22 iyunya. Anatomiya katastrofy [June 22. Anatomy of a disaster]. Мoscow: Yauza: Yauza Publ., 2009.

15. Cherushev N.S. 1937 god: Elita Krasnoi Armii na Golgofe [1937: Elite of the Red Army on Golgotha]. Мoscow: Veche Publ., 2003.

Система Orphus

Loading...
Up