Sarmatian Archaeological Culture: From Speculative to Network Model

 
PIIS032103910012258-6-1
DOI10.31857/S032103910012258-6
Publication type Article
Status Published
Authors
Affiliation:
Institute of World History, RAS
National Research University Higher School of Economics
State Academic University for the Humanities
Address: Russian Federation, Moscow
Journal nameVestnik drevnei istorii
EditionVolume 80 Issue 4
Pages1062-1083
Abstract

The assumption that cultures are clearly defined, essentially self-contained entities has been subjected to serious doubt in modern archaeology which needs to be reflected also in Sarmatian studies. Such concepts as ‘Sarmatians’, ‘Sarmatian period’ and ‘Sarmatian archaeological culture(s)’ are widely used in archaeological literature. However, the monuments of the different macro-regions that are usually connected in scholarship with the various Sarmatian communities and political entities mentioned in the written sources have significant cultural distinctions. The nature of these differences has not been reliably clarified yet. This leads to contradictions in the interpretation of the same culture groups by representatives of different schools of archaeology. The basiс cause of the contradictions lies in the flaws of the argumentation procedure, which appears to be speculative, and thus devoid of any heuristic potential. It is necessary to develop common approaches to the interpretation of the archaeological material. A promising approach in this regard might be the network model. Such models will make it possible to define an archaeological culture as a stable set of features, objects and phenomena of the material world, reflecting the network connections formed and operating in a certain area within a particular period.

KeywordsSarmatian archaeological culture, speculative model, network model, methodology of material remains study
AcknowledgmentRussian Science Foundation, project no. 18-18-00237
Received28.12.2020
Publication date28.12.2020
Number of characters42331
Cite  
100 rub.
When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 0, views: 1347

Readers community rating: votes 0

1. Abramova, M.P. 1961: [Sarmatian graves of the Don and Ukraine in the 2nd cent. BC– 1st cent. AD]. Sovetskaya arkheologiya [Soviet Archaeology] 1, 91–110.

2. Abramova, M.P. 1979: [On the problem of interrelations of the North Caucasian tribes in the sarmatian epoch]. Sovetskaya arkheologiya [Soviet Archaeology] 2, 31–50.

3. Anfimov, N.V. 1949: [On the problem of the Kuban region population in the Scythian epoch]. Sovetskaya arkheologiya [Soviet Archaeology] 11, 241–260.

4. Artamonov, M.I. 1948: [Scythian kingdom in the Crimea]. Vestnik LGU [Herald of Leningrad State University] 8, 56–78.

5. Bonch-Osmolovskiy, G.A. 1926: [Prehistorical cultures of the Crimea]. Krym [Crimea] 2, 74–94.

6. Braychevskiy, M.Yu. 1991: [About the historical content of the term “archaeological culture”]. In: V.M. Masson, V.I. Boryaz, M.V. Anikovich (eds.), Arkheologicheskie kul’tury i kul’turnaya transformatsiya. Materialy metodologicheskogo seminara LOIA AN SSSR [Archaeological Cultures and Cultural Transformation. Materials of the Methodological Seminar of the Leningrad Branch of the USSR Academy of Sciences]. Leningrad, 55–60.

7. Childe, V.G. 1929: The Danube in Prehistory. Oxford.

8. Demidenko, S.V., Kulcsar, V. 2004: [Sarmatian archaeological cultures]. In: Bol’shaya rossiyskaya entsiklopedia [The Great Russian Encyclopedia]. (URL: https://bigenc.ru/archeology/text/3536769; дата обращения: 04.11.2020)

9. Editorial 1937: [Our tasks in the field of archaeological research according to the directives of the Central Committee of All-USSR Communist Party of Bolsheviks and Sovnarkom of USSR concerning the handbooks on history]. Sovetskaya arkheologiya [Soviet Archaeology] 2, 1–10.

10. Ernst, N.L. 1927: [Neapolis Scythica (to the 100th anniversary of the first excavations)]. In: Vtoraya konferentsiya arkheologov SSSR, Khersones, 10–13 sentyabrya 1927 goda (stoletie khersonesskikh raskopok (1827–1927)) [The Second Conference of Archaeologists of the USSR, Chersonesos, 10–13 September, 1927 (the 100th Anniversary of the Chersonesean Excavations (1827–1927)]. Sevastopol, 23–28.

11. Fraknkfort, H., Frankfort, H.A., Wilson, J., Jacobsen, T. 2001: V preddverii filosofii. Dukhovnye iskaniya drevnego cheloveka [Before Philosophy. The Intellectual Adventure of Ancient Man]. Saint Petersburg.

12. Ganzha, A.I. 1991: [The term “archaeological culture”: multiplicity of approaches and a possibility of an unambiguous definition]. In: V.M. Masson, V.I. Boryaz, M.V. Anikovich (eds.), Arkheologicheskie kul’tury i kul’turnaya transformatsiya. Materialy metodologicheskogo seminara LOIA AN SSSR [Archaeological Cultures and Cultural Transformation. Materials of the Methodological Seminar of the Leningrad Branch of the USSR Academy of Sciences]. Leningrad, 60–65.

13. Glebov, V.P. 2004: [Chronology of the Early Sarmatian and Middle Sarmatian cultures of the Lower Don region]. In: Sarmatskie kul’tury Evrazii: Problemy regional’noy khronologii. Doklady k 5 mezhdunarodnoy konferentsii “Problemy sarmatskoy archeologii i istorii” [Sarmatian Cultures of Eurasia: Problems of Regional Chronology. Texts to the 5th International Conference “Problems of Sarmatian archaeology”]. Krasnodar, 127–133.

14. Gorodtsov, V.A. 1905: [Results of archaeological research in the Izum district of the Kharkov province in 1901]. In: Trudy XII Arkheologicheskogo s”ezda v g. Khar’kove, 1902 g. T. I [Proceedings of the XII Archaeological Congress in Kharkov, 1902. Vol. I]. Moscow, 174–225.

15. Gorodtsov, V.A. 1907: [Results of archaeological research in the Bakhmut district of Ekaterinoslav province in 1903]. In: Trudy XIII Arkheologicheskogo s”ezda [Proceedings of the XIII Archaeological Congress]. Moscow, 211–285.

16. Grakov, B.N. 1947: [Γυναικοκρατούμενοι: relics of matriarchate by the Sarmatians. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 3, 100–121.

17. Kamenetskiy, I.S. 1970: [Archaeological culture – its definition and interpretation]. Sovetskaya arkheologiya [Soviet Archaeology] 2, 18–36.

18. Kamenetskiy, I.S. 2000: Arkheologicheskie pamyatniki meotov Kubani [Archaeological Sites of the Kuban Maiotians]. Krasnodar.

19. Kamenetskiy, I.S. 2011: Istoriya izucheniya meotov [History of Research of the Maiotians]. Moscow.

20. Klein, L.S. 1970: [The problem of definition of archaeological culture]. Sovetskaya arkheologiya [Soviet Archaeology] 2, 37–51.

21. Klein, L.S. 1978: Arkheologicheskie istochniki [Archaeological Sources]. Leningrad.

22. Klein, L.S. 1986: [On the subject-matter of archaeology (on Vladimir Gening's book “The Object and Subject-Matter of Archaeology”)]. Sovetskaya ark-heologiya [Soviet Archaeology] 3, 209–219.

23. Klepikov, V.M. 2002: Sarmaty Nizhnego Povolzh’ya v IV–III vv. do n.e. [Sarmatians of the Lower Volga Region in the 4th–3rd Cent. BC]. Volgograd.

24. Kossina, G. 1936: Die Herkunft der Germanen: zur Methode der Siedlungsar-chäologie. 3. Aufgabe. Leipzig.

25. Kostenko, V.I. 1983: Sarmatskie pamyatniki Dnepro-Donskogo mezhdurech’ya III v. do n.e. – serediny III v. n.e. [Sarmatian Sites of the Dnieper-Don Interfluve from the 3rd Cent. BC to the 3rd Cent. AD]. Dnepropetrovsk.

26. Lebedev, G.S. 1992: Istoriya otechestvennoy arkheologii 1700–1917 gg. [History of Russian Archaeology 1700–1917]. Saint Petersburg.

27. Lobova, I.I. 1956: Sarmaty v Krymu. [The Sarmatians in the Crimea. PhD Thesis]. Moscow.

28. Lysenko, A.V., Mordvintseva, V.I. 2019: [Metal jewelry – votives from the Eklizi-Burun sanctuary of Roman time (to the cultural attribution of the site)]. Problemy istorii, filologii, kul’tury [Journal of Historical, Philological and Cultural Studies] 4 (66), 240–296.

29. Masson, V.M., Boryaz, V.I., Anikovich, M.V. (eds.) 1991: Arkheologicheskie kul’tury i kul’turnaya transformatsiya. Materialy metodologicheskogo seminara LOIA AN SSSR [Archaeological Cultures and Cultural Transformation. Materials of the Methodological Seminar of the Leningrad Branch of the USSR Academy of Sciences]. Leningrad.

30. Mordvintseva, V.I. 2008: [Phalerae from votive hoards of the North Pontic Area of the 3rd–1st cent. BC and the Sarmatian paradigm]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 3, 162–183.

31. Mordvintseva, V. 2013: The Sarmatians: the creation of archaeological evidence. Oxford Journal of Archaeology 32 (2), 203–219.

32. Mordvintseva, V.I. 2016a: [Formation of the concept of cultural and historical processes in the ‘barbarian’ world of the North Pontic region in the 3rd cent. BC – mid-3rd cent. AD.] Istoriya i arkheologiya Kryma [History and Archaeology of the Crimea] 3, 178–199.

33. Mordvintseva, V.I. 2016b: [Burial complexes of elite as a source of detecting political identities according to archaeological material]. In: Elity Bospora i bosporskaya elitarnaya kul’tura. Materialy mezhdunarodnogo Kruglogo stola [Elites of Bosporos and Bosporan elite culture. Materials of the international Round table (Saint Petersburg, 22–25 November 2016)]. Saint Petersburg, 251–259.

34. Mordvintseva, V.I. 2017: [The concept ‘Sarmatians’ as a cultural and historical phenomenon in the contact zone of North Pontic Area]. In: N.V. Pet-lyuchenko (ed.), Kontsepty i kontrasty [Concepts and Contrasts]. Odessa, 153–160.

35. Mordvintseva, V.I. 2018: [Principles and methods of a comparative analysis of burial complexes of elites]. In: A.S. Skripkin (ed.), Problemy arkheologii i muzeevedeniya. Sbornik statey, posvyashchennyy pamyati N.V. Khabarovoy [Problems of archaeology and museum study. A collection of articles devoted to the memory of N.V. Khabarova]. Volgograd, 192–197.

36. Mordvintseva, V.I. 2019: [Archaeological cultures of „Barbarians“ of the North Pontic Area 3rd cent. BC – 3rd cent. AD: criticizing the ethnic model]. In: E.V. Kruglov, A.S. Lapshin, I.Yu. Lapshina (eds.), Arkheologiya kak zhizn’. Pamyati Evgeniya Pavlovicha Mys’kova [Archaeology as a Life. To the Memory of Eugeniy Pavlovich Mys’kov]. Volgograd, 93–98.

37. Moshkova, M.G. 1963: Pamyatniki Prokhorovskoy kul’tury [Monuments of Prokhorovka culture]. Moscow.

38. Moshkova, M.G. 1989a: [A short overview of history of the Sauromatian-Sarmatian tribes]. In: A.I. Melyukova (ed.), Stepi evropeyskoy chasti SSSR v skifo-sarmatskoe vremya [Steppes of the European Part of USSR in the Scythian-Sarmatian Time]. Moscow, 153–158.

39. Moshkova, M.G. 1989b: [History of research of the Sauromatian-Sarmatian tribes]. In: A.I. Melyukova (ed.), Stepi evropeyskoy chasti SSSR v skifo-sarmatskoe vremya [Steppes of the European part of USSR in the Scythian-Sarmatian Time]. Moscow, 158–164.

40. Moshkova, M.G. (ed.) 1994: Statisticheskaya obrabotka pogrebal’nykh pamyatnikov Aziatskoy Sarmatii. Vyp. 1. Savromatskaya epokha [The statistical processing of burial sites of Asian Sarmatia. Issue 1. Sauromatian epoch]. Moscow.

41. Moshkova, M.G. (ed.) 1997: Statisticheskaya obrabotka pogrebal’nykh pamyatnikov Aziatskoy Sarmatii. Vyp. 2. Rannesarmatskaya kul’tura (IV–I vv. do n.e.) [The statistical processing of burial sites of Asian Sarmatia. Issue 2. Early Sarmatian culture (4th–1st cent. BC)]. Moscow.

42. Moshkova, M.G. (ed.) 2002: Statisticheskaya obrabotka pogrebal’nykh pamyatnikov Aziatskoy Sarmatii. Vyp. 3. Srednesarmatskaya kul’tura [The statistical processing of burial sites of Asian Sarmatia. Isuue 3. Middle Sarmatian culture]. Moscow.

43. Moshkova, M.G. (ed.) 2009: Statisticheskaya obrabotka pogrebal’nykh pamyatnikov Aziatskoy Sarmatii. Vyp. 4. Pozdnesarmatskaya kul’tura [The statistical processing of burial sites of Asian Sarmatia. Issue 4. Late Sarmatian culture]. Moscow.

44. Ochir-Goryaeva, M.A. 1992: [The problem of the Savromats in Scythian and Sarmatian archaeology]. Rossiyskaya arkheologiya [Russian Archaeology] 2, 32–40.

45. Polin, S.V. 1992: Ot Skifii k Sarmatii [From Scythia to Sarmatia]. Kiev.

46. Polin, S.V., Simonenko, A.V. 1990: [Early Sarmatian burials of the Northern Black sea region]. In: Issledovaniya po arkheologii Podneprov’ya [Re-search in the Field of the Dnieper Archaeology]. Dnepropetrovsk, 76–95.

47. Potemkin, V.P. (ed.) 1945: Materialy k Vsesoyuznomu arkheologicheskomu soveshchaniyu IIMK AN SSSR im. N.Ya. Marra [Materials to the All-USSR archaeological meeting of Institute for the History of Material Culture named after N.Ya. Marr, Academy of Sciences of the Soviet Union]. Moscow.

48. Rabinovich, B.Z. 1936: [On the dating of some Scythian barrows of the Middle Dnieper region]. Sovetskaya arkheologiya [Soviet Archaeology] 1, 79–102.

49. Rau, P. 1927a: Die Hügelgräber Römischer Zeit an der unteren Wolga (Ergebnisse der Gräberforschung in der Wolgadeutschen Republik). (Mitteilungen des Zentralmuseums der Aut. Sozial. Räte-Republik der Wolgadeutschen. Jahrgang. 1. Heft 1–2). Pokrowsk.

50. Rau, P. 1927b: Prähistorische Ausgrabungen auf der Steppenseite des Deutschen Wolgagebiets im Jahre 1926. (Mitteilungen des Zentralmuseums der Aut. Sozial. Räte-Republik der Wolgadeutschen. Jahrgang 2. Heft 1). Pokrowsk.

51. Rau, P. 1929: Die Gräber der frühen Eisenzeit im unteren Wolgagebiet. (Mitteilungen des Zentralmuseums der Aut. Sozial. Räte-Republik der Wolgadeutschen. Jahrgang 4. Heft 1). Pokrowsk.

52. Rostovtzeff, M.I. 1918a: Kurgannye nakhodki Orenburgskoy oblasti epokhi rannego i pozdnego ellinizma. [Barrow Finds in Orenburg Region Dating to the Early and Late Hellenistic Periods]. Petrograd.

53. Rostovtzeff, M.I. 1922: Iranians and Greeks in South Russia. Oxford.

54. Rostovtzeff, M.I. 1925: Skifiya i Bospor. Kriticheskoe obozrenie pamyatnikov literaturnykh i arkheologicheskikh [Scythia and Bosporos. A critical over-view of literal and archaeological sources]. Leningrad.

55. Rostovtzeff, M.I. 1929: The Animal Style in South Russia and China. Princeton.

56. Rostovtzeff, M.I. 2002: Ellinstvo i iranstvo na yuge Rossii [Iranians and Greeks in South Russia]. (1st ed. – 1918). Moscow.

57. Rudenko, S.I. 1918: [Report on the excavations of Prokhorovka barrow]. In: M.I. Rostovtzeff, Kurgannye nakhodki Orenburgskoy oblasti epokhi ran-nego i pozdnego ellinizma [Barrow Finds in Orenburg Region Dating to the Early and Late Hellenistic Periods]. Petrograd, 1–11.

58. Rykov, P.S. 1925: Suslovskiy kurgannyy mogil’nik [Susly Barrow Necropolis]. Saratov.

59. Samokvasov, D.Ya. 1892: Osnovaniya khronologicheskoy klassifikatsii, opisanie i katalog kollektsii drevnostey [Grounds for Chronological Classification, Description and a Catalogue of the Collection of Antiquities]. Warsaw.

60. Samokvasov, D.Ya. 1908: Mogily russkoy zemli [Graves of Russian Soil]. M.

61. Sarianidi, V.I. 1989: Khram i nekropol Tillya-tepe [The Tillya-tepe Temple and Necropolis]. Moscow.

62. Sergatskov, I.V. 1995: [The new data about the Early Sarmatian culture time frame]. Rossiyskaya arkheologiya [Russian Archaeology] 1, 148–158.

63. Sergatskov, I.V. 2002: [The analysis of burial sites of the 1st and 2nd cent. AD]. In: M.G. Moshkova (ed.), Statisticheskaya obrabotka pogrebal’nykh pamyatnikov Aziatskoy Sarmatii. Vyp. 3. Srednesarmatskaya kul’tura [The statistical processing of burial sites of Asian Sarmatia. Issue 3. Middle Sarmatian culture]. Moscow, 22–129.

64. Sergatskov, I.V. 2006: [The problem of the establishment of Middle Sarmatian culture]. In: V.M. Klepikov (ed.), Rannesarmatskaya i srednesarmatskaya kul’tury: problemy sootnosheniya. Materialy seminara Tsentra izucheniya istorii i kul’tury sarmatov. Vyp. I [Early and Middle Sarmatian Cultures: the Problems of Relationship. Materials of the Seminar of the Research Centre of the Sarmatian History and Culture. Issue I]. Volgograd, 37–58.

65. Simonenko, A.V. 2004: [Chronology and periodization of the Sarmatian sites of the Northern Black sea region]. In: Sarmatskie kul’tury Evrazii: problemy regional’noy khronologii. Doklady k 5 mezhdunarodnoy konferentsii “Problemy sarmatskoy arkheologii i istorii” [Sarmatian Cultures of Eurasia: Problems of Regional Chronology. Texts to the 5th International Conference “Problems of Sarmatian archaeology”]. Krasnodar, 134–173.

66. Skripkin, A.S. 1990: Aziatskaya Sarmatia. Problemy khronologii i eye istoricheskiy aspekt [Asian Sarmatia. Problems of chronology and its historical aspect]. Saratov.

67. Skripkin, A.S. 1997: [The analysis of burial sites of the 3rd–1st cent. BC]. In: M.G. Moshkova (ed.), Statisticheskaya obrabotka pogrebal’nykh pa-myatnikov Aziatskoy Sarmatii. Vyp. 2. Rannesarmatskaya kul’tura (IV–I vv. do n.e.) [The statistical processing of burial sites of Asian Sarmatia. Issue 2. Early Sarmatian culture (4th–1st cent. BC)]. Moscow, 131–212.

68. Skripkin, A.S. 2006: [To the problem of correlation between the Early and Middle Sarmatian cultures]. In: V.M. Klepikov (ed.), Rannesarmatskaya i srednesarmatskaya kul’tury: problemy sootnosheniya. Materialy seminara Tsentra izucheniya istorii i kul’tury sarmatov. Vyp. 1 [Early and Middle Sarmatian Cultures: the Problems of Relationship. Materials of the Seminar of the Research Centre of the Sarmatian History and Culture. Issue 1]. Volgograd, 5–36.

69. Skripkin, A.S. 2017: Sarmaty [The Sarmatians]. Volgograd.

70. Smirnov, A.P. 1964: [To the question of an archaeological culture]. Sovetskaya arkheologiya [Soviet Archaeology] 4, 3–10.

71. Smirnov, K.F. 1948: [About burials of the Roxolani]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 1, 213–219.

72. Smirnov, K.F. 1954: [Issues of the research of Sarmatian tribes and their culture in Soviet archaeology]. In: Shelov, D. (ed.) Voprosy skifo-sarmatskoy arkheologii (po materialam konferentsii Instituta istorii material’noy kul’tury Akademii nauk SSSR 1952 g.) [Issues of the Scythian-Sarmatian Archaeology (After the Materials of the Conference of the Institute of Material Culture’s History, USSR Academy of Sciences, 1952)]. Moscow, 195–219.

73. Smirnov, K.F. 1964: Savromaty. Rannyaya istoriya i kul’tura sarmatov [Sauromatians. Early History and Culture of the Sarmatians]. Moscow.

74. Smirnov, K.F. 1984: Sarmaty i utverzhdenie ikh politicheskogo gospodstva v Skifii [Sarmatians and the Establishment of Their Political Dominance in Scythia]. Moscow.

75. Smirnov, K.F. 1989: [Sauromatian and Early Sarmatian cultures]. In: A.I. Melyukova (ed.), Stepi evropeyskoy chasti SSSR v skifo-sarmatskoe vremya [Steppes of the European Part of USSR in the Scythian-Sarmatian Time]. Moscow, 165–177.

76. Spitsyn, A.A. 1896: [Review of some provinces and regions of Russia in the archaeological aspect. The Saratov province]. Zapiski Imperatorskogo russkogo arkheologicheskogo obshchestva [Notes of the Imperial Russian Archaeological Society] 8.1–2, 268–278.

77. Veselovskiy, N.I. 1905: [Barrows of the Kuban region during the period of Roman rule in the North Caucasus]. In: Trudy XII Arkheologicheskogo s’’ezda v g. Khar’kove, 1902 g. T. I. [Proceedings of the XII Archaeological Congress in Kharkov, 1902. Vol. I]. Moscow, 341–373.

78. Vyaz’mitina, M.I. 1969: [Culture of the population of the Lower Dnieper after the fall of the unified Scythia]. Sovetskaya arkheologiya [Soviet Archaeol-ogy] 4, 62–77.

79. Vyaz’mitina, M.I., Terenozhkin, O.I., Illins’ka, V.A., Pokrovs’ka, E.F., Kovpanenko, G.T. 1960: [Barrows near the village of Novopylypivka and the soviet farm “Akkermen”]. In: Arkheologichni pam’yatky URSR [Archaeological sites of Ukrainian Soviet Social Republic] 8. Kiev, 22–135.

80. Yablonskiy, L.T. 2016: [Some theoretical approaches to the question of genesis of the Early Sarmatian culture]. In: L.T. Yablonskiy, L.A. Kraeva (eds.), Konstantin Fedorovich Smirnov i sovremennye problemy Sarmatskoy arkheologii. Materialy IX Mezhdunarodnoy nauchnoy konferentsii “Problemy sarmatskoy arkheologii i istorii”, posvyashchennoy 100-letiyu so dnya rozhdeniya Konstantina Fedorovicha Smirnova [Konstantin F. Smirnov and Current Issues of Sarmatian Archaeology. Materials of the International scientific conference “Problems of Sarmatian archaeology” devoted to the 100th anniversary of Konstantin Fedorovich Smirnov]. Orenburg, 304–310.

81. Zakharuk, Yu.N. 1981: Metodologicheskie problemy arkheologii. [Methodological problems of archaeology. PhD Thesis. Abstract]. Moscow.

82. Zasetskaya, I.P. 1989: [Problems of the Sarmatian zoomorphic style]. Sovetskaya arkheologiya [Soviet Archaeology] 3, 35–47.

83. Zhelezchikov, B.F. 1997: [Analysis of Sarmatian sites of the 4th–3rd cent. BC]. In: M.G. Moshkova (ed.), Statisticheskaya obrabotka pogrebal’nykh pamyatnikov Aziatskoy Sarmatii. Vyp. 2. Rannesarmatskaya kul’tura (IV–I vv. do n.e.) [The statistical processing of burial sites of Asian Sarmatia. Issue 2. Early Sarmatian culture (4th – 1st cent. BC)]. Moscow, 46–130.

Система Orphus

Loading...
Up