The spali of Jordan and the pali of Pliny the Elder.

The historicity of Jordanes’ narrative of the migration of the Goths to the country of Oyum, and of the tribe of the Spali, encountered by the Goths when crossing a river, remains controversial in modern scholarship. A number of scholars deny the historicity of this tribe and the entire “Gothic resettlement saga”, some others identify the Spali as the early Slavs, and others correlate them with the Spalaei of Pliny the Elder. S.R. Tokhtas’ev argued that the similarity of the ethnonyms of the Spalaei-Spali is accidental and can be explained by dittography, which is supported by the name of King Palakos and the name of the Palakion fortress among the Crimean Scythians. Combining the hypothesis of Tokhtas’ev and the hypothesis of L.A. El’nitskiy about the possible proximity of the Spalaei and Pali, the author argues that Pliny’s Spalaei and the Spali of Jordanes may be identified with the Pali who lived in the steppe part of the Crimea from the second century BC and are mentioned by Diodorus, Strabo, Pliny the Elder and Stephanus of Byzantium. The royal fortress of Palakion fortress and the name of the King Palakos confirm this version.

Keywords

Jordanes, Pliny the Elder, Strabo, Pomponius Mela, Goths, Spali, Satharcheos, Crimea

Received

28.12.2020

Publication date

28.12.2020

Number of characters

34288

Cite

GOST	Sharov O. The “spali” of Jordan and the “pali” of Pliny the Elder. // Vestnik drevnei istorii – 2020. – V. 80. – Issue 4 C. 979-994 [Electronic resource]. URL: http://ras.jes.su/vdi/s032103910012253-1-1-en (circulation date: 19.01.2025). DOI: 10.31857/S032103910012253-1
MLA	Sharov, Oleg "The “spali” of Jordan and the “pali” of Pliny the Elder.." Vestnik drevnei istorii 80.4 (2020):979-994. DOI: 10.31857/S032103910012253-1
APA	Sharov O. (2020). The “spali” of Jordan and the “pali” of Pliny the Elder.. Vestnik drevnei istorii 80(4), pp.979-994 DOI: 10.31857/S032103910012253-1

100 rub.

When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 0, views: 1418

Readers community rating: votes 0

1. Alekseev, A.Yu. 2003: Khronografiya evropeyskoy Skifii VII–IV vv. do n.e. [Chronography of the European Scythia of the 7th–4th Cent. BC]. Saint Petersburg.

2. Anfertyev, A.N. 1994: [Jordan]. In: L.A. Gindin, S.A. Ivanov, G.G. Litavrin (eds.), Svod drevneyshikh pis’mennykh izvestiy o slavyanakh. T. I. I–VI vv. [The Collection of the Oldest Written Sources on the Slavs. Vol. I. 1st–6th Centuries]. Moscow, 98–161.

3. Bierbrauer, V. 1994: Archäologie und Geschichte der Goten vom 1.–7. Jahrhundert. Versuch einer Bilanz. Frühmittelalterliche Studien 28, 51–171.

4. Budanova, V.P. 1990: Goty v epokhu Velikogo pereseleniya narodov [Goths in the Era of the Great Migration]. Saint Petersburg.

5. Christensen, A.S. 2002: Cassiodorus, Jordanes and the History of the Goths. Studies in a Migration Myth. Copenhagen.

6. Gibbon, E. 1997: Istoriya upadka i razrusheniya Rimskoy Imperii [The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire]. Saint Petersburg.

7. Herrmann, A. 1927. Spalaei. In: RE. 2. R. Hbd. 5, 1259.

8. Khazanov, A.M. 1975: Zoloto skifov [Gold of the Scythians]. Moscow.

9. Khrapunov, I.N. 2007: Drevnyaya istoriya Kryma [Ancient History of Crimea]. 3rd ed. Simferopol.

10. Kokowski, А., Leiber, Chr. 1995: Schätze der Ostgoten. Stuttgart.

11. Krause, W. 1953: Handbuch des Gotischen. München.

12. Kulikowski, M. 2007: Rome’s Gothic Wars: From the Third Century to Alarich. Cambridge.

13. Latyshev, V.V. 1948: [Reports of ancient writers about Scythia and the Cauca-sus. Part one. Greek Writers (continued)]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 3, 217–330.

14. Latyshev, V.V. 1949: [Reports of ancient writers about Scythia and the Cauca-sus. Part two. Latin writers (continued)]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 2, 271–356

15. Lewicki, T. 1951 Zagadnienie Gotyv na Krymie. Przegląd Zachodni 5/8 (R. VII), 77–99.

16. Lowmianski, H. 1963 Poczatki Polski. Т. 1. Warszawa, 1963.

17. Magomedov, B.V. 2001: Chernyakhovskaya kul’tura. Problema etnosa [Chernyakhov Culture. The Problem of Ethnicity]. Lublin.

18. Merrills, A. 2005: History and Geography in Late Antiquity. Cambridge.

19. Mishulin, A.V. 1947. [Sources about the Scythians and the study of culture of pre-Slavic population in the history of the USSR (to the reprint of “Scythica et Caucasica” by V.V. Latyshev)]. Vestnik drevney istorii [Journal of Ancient History] 1, 255–262.

20. Mommsen, T. 1882: Jordanis Romana et Getica. Prooemium. In: Monumenta Germaniae Historica. Auctores antiquissimi. T. V. Pt. I. Berlin, V–LXXIII.

21. Olkhovsky, V.S. 1981: [Classical authors on the population of the Crimea]. Sovetskaya arkheologiya [Soviet Archaeology] 3, 52–65.

22. Podossinov, A.V., Skrzhinskaya, M.V. 2011: Rimskie geograficheskie istochniki: Pomponiy Mela i Pliniy Starshiy. Teksty, perevod, kommentariy [Roman Geographical Sources: Pomponius Mela and Pliny the Elder. Texts, Translation, Commentary]. Moscow.

23. Puzdrovsky, A.E. 1999: [Ethnic history of Crimean Scythia (2nd cent. BCE – 3rd cent. CE)]. Khersonesskiy sbornik [Chersonese Collected Papers] X, 209–225.

24. Raevsky, D.S. 2006: Mir skifskoy kul’tury [World of the Scythian Culture]. Moscow.

25. Rostovtzeff, M.I. 1925: Skifiya i Bospor. Kriticheskoe obozrenie pamyatnikov literaturnykh i arkheologicheskikh [Scythia and the Bosporus. Critical Review of Literary and Archaeological Sources]. Leningrad.

26. Rostowzew, М. 1931: Skythien und der Bosporus. Berlin.

27. Schmidt, L. 1934: Geschichte der deutschen Stämme bis zum Ausgang der Völkerwanderung. Die Ostgermanen. 2. vollig umgearb. Aufl. München.

28. Sedov, V.V. 1994: Slavyane v drevnosti i v rannem srednevekov’e. T. 1. Slavyane v drevnosti [The Slavs in Antiquity and in the Early Middle Ages. Vol. 1. Slavs in Antiquity]. Moscow.

29. Sedov, V.V. 2002: Slavyane. Istoriko-arkheologicheskoe issledovanie [The Slavs. Historical and Archaeological Research]. Moscow.

30. Sharov, O.V. 2009: Bospor i varvarskiy mir Tsentral’noy i Vostochnoy Evropy v pozdnerimskuyu epokhu (seredina II – seredina IV vv. n.e). [Bosporus and the Barbarian World of Central and Eastern Europe in the Late Roman Era (mid 2nd–mid 4th Cent. CE)]. Dr. habil. Thesis. Saint Petersburg.

31. Sharov, O.V. 2010: [Data from written and archaeological sources on the ap-pearance of the Germans on the Bosporus (the problem of distinguishing “German antiquities” on the Bosporus)]. Stratum plus. Kul’turnaya an-tropologiya i arkheologiya [Stratum plus. Archaeology and Cultural Anthropology] 4, 251–285.

32. Sharov, O.V. 2013: [In search of the Oyum country: epic or reality?]. In: N.E. Berlizov (ed.), Drevnosti Zapadnogo Kavkaza [Antiquities of the Western Caucasus]. Issue I. Krasnodar, 118–155.

33. Shchukin, M.B. 2005: Gotskiy put’ (Goty, Rim i chernyakhovskaya kul’tura) [Gothic Way (Goths, Rome and Chernyakhov Culture)]. Saint Petersburg.

34. Shchukin, M.B., Machinskiy, D.A., Voronyatov, S.V. 2011: [Gothic way, the most fertile lands of Oium and the Velbark-Chernyakhov settlement Lepesovka]. In: D.A. Machinskiy (ed.), Evropeyskaya Sarmatiya. Sbornik, posvyashchennyy Marku Borisovichu Shchukinu. Po materialam konferentsii, provedennoy v ramkakh XIV chteniy pamyati Anny Machinskoy. Staraya Ladoga, 26–27 dekabrya 2009 g. [European Sarmatia. Papers Collection Dedicated to Mark Borisovich Shchukin. Based on the Materials of a Conference Held as Part of the XIV Readings in Memory of Anna Machinskaya. Staraya Ladoga, December 26–27, 2009]. Saint Petersburg, 246–291.

35. Skrzhinskaya, E.Ch. 1997: Iordan. O proiskhozhdenii i deyaniyakh getov [Jordan. On the Origin and Deeds of the Getae]. 2nd ed. Saint Petersburg.

36. Solomonik, E.I. 1964: Novye epigraficheskie pamyatniki Khersonesa [New Epigraphic Monuments of Chersonesos]. Kiev.

37. Stückelberger, A., Graßhoff, G. (Hrsg.) 2006: Klaudios Ptolemaios. Handbuch der Geographie. Griechisch–Deutsch. Einleitung, Text und Übersetzung, Index. Bd. 1–2. Basel.

38. Thompson, E.A. 2003: Rimlyane i varvary. Padenie Zapadnoy Imperii [Romans and Barbarians. The Fall of the Western Empire]. Saint Petersburg.

39. Tokhtas’ev, S.R. 2005: [The problem of the Scythian language in modern sci-ence]. In: V. Cojokaru (ed.), Ethnic Contacts and Cultural Exchanges North and West of the Black Sea from the Greek Colonization to the Ot-toman Conquest. Iași, 59–108.

40. Trubachev, O.N. 1979: [“Old Scythia” (᾽Αρχαίη Σκυθίη) of Herodotus (IV. 99) and the Slavs. Linguistic aspect]. Voprosy yazykoznaniya [Topics in the Study of Language] 4, 29–45.

41. Trubachev, O.N. (ed.) 1981: Etimologicheskiy slovar’ slavyanskikh yazykov. Praslavyanskiy leksicheskiy fond [The Etymological Dictionary of Slavic languages. Pre–Slavic Lexical Fund]. Issue 8. Moscow

42. Trubachev, O.N. 1999: [A case from typology: the problem of the “old Aryans” and the “Aryan section”]. In: O.N. Trubachev, Indoarica v Severnom Prichernomor'e. Rekonstruktsiya reliktov yazyka. Etimologicheskiy slovar' [Indoarica in the Northern Black Sea Region. Reconstruction of Relics of the Language. Etymological Dictionary]. Moscow, 99–102.

43. Vernadsky, G.V., Karpovich, M.M. 1999: Drevnyaya Rus’. Istoriya Drevney Rusi [Ancient Russia. History of Ancient Russia]. Vol. 1. Moscow.

44. Vernadsky, G. 1943. Ancient Russia. 2nd ed. New Haven.

45. Voronyatov, S.V., Machinsky, D.A. 2010: [On the time, circumstances and sense of the appearance of Sarmatian tamgas on German spears]. In: O.A. Shcheglova, M.M. Kazansky, V. Novakovskiy (eds.), «Germania–Sarmatia»: sbornik nauchnykh statey po arkheologii narodov Tsen-tral’noy i Vostochnoy Evropy, posvyashchennyy pamyati M.B. Shchukina [“Germania–Sarmatia”: Collection of Scientific Articles on Archeology of the Peoples of Central and Eastern Europe, Dedicated to the Memory of M.B. Shchukin]. Issue 2. Kaliningrad–Kursk, 57–77.

46. Wolfram, H. 2003: Goty. Ot istokov do serediny VI veka (opyt istoricheskoy etnografii) [Goths. From the Origins to the Middle of the 6th Century (the Experience of Historical Ethnography)]. Saint Petersburg.

47. Yatsenko, S.A. 1997: [Germans and alans: about the destruction in the Azov sea region in 236–276 CE]. Stratum plus, 154–163.

48. Zhikh, M.I. 2014a: [Slavs and Gotha on Volhyn and in the Top Dniester. Problem of localization of the earth of Oium and “tribe” (gens) of Spali]. Rusin 2 (36), 76–103.

49. Zhikh, M.I. 2014b: [To a question of a ratio of Spali of Jordanes and Pliny the Elder Satarcheos Spalaeos]. Materialy po arkheologii i istorii antichnogo i srednevekovogo Kryma [Proceedings in Archaeology and History of Ancient and Medieval Crimea] 6, 178–182.