A. S. Pushkin vs. E. A. Poe:  the History of V. V. Nabokov’s Performative Utterances

The aim of this article is to examine the ways Nabokov alluded to Pushkin and Poe in his ﬁction and to explore his articulated views of the two geniuses. Lolita, Nabokov’s most popular American novel, contains numerous allusions to both Pushkin and Poe. The number of incidental mentionings of Poe in Nabokov’s later ﬁction tends to decrease. After the late 1960s when he was unanimously acknowledged as one of the most important living American authors, Nabokov demonstrates his derogatory attitude to Poe 16 times. Nabokov’s opinion of Pushkin, however, was constantly high if not exalted. The article advances a hypothesis that in Lolita Nabokov used allusions to both Pushkin and Poe as a Friend or Foe Identiﬁcation system. It did work with Poe and failed with Pushkin. The article presents Nabokov’s articulated opinions of Pushkin and Poe as a sequence of Austin type performative utterances, to the extent, «I am a Russian-American Author, though you’ve failed to understand that» — «I am a great American Author, if you say that» — «I am a great Author».

Keywords

V. V. Nabokov, A. S. Pushkin, E. A. Poe, Lolita, Ultima Thule, Performative Utterances

Received

28.03.2019

Publication date

29.03.2019

Number of characters

27743

Cite

GOST	Timofeyev V. A. S. Pushkin vs. E. A. Poe: the History of V. V. Nabokov’s Performative Utterances // Russkaia literatura – 2019. – Issue 1 C. 192-197 [Electronic resource]. URL: http://ras.jes.su/rusliter/s013160950004544-2-1-en (circulation date: 17.01.2025). DOI: 10.31860/0131-6095-2019-1-192-197
MLA	Timofeyev, V. T "A. S. Pushkin vs. E. A. Poe: the History of V. V. Nabokov’s Performative Utterances." Russkaia literatura 1 (2019):192-197. DOI: 10.31860/0131-6095-2019-1-192-197
APA	Timofeyev V. (2019). A. S. Pushkin vs. E. A. Poe: the History of V. V. Nabokov’s Performative Utterances. Russkaia literatura (1), pp.192-197 DOI: 10.31860/0131-6095-2019-1-192-197

100 rub.

When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 2, views: 1419

Readers community rating: votes 0

1. Воронина О. Владимир Набоков и Льюис Кэролл, или Гумберт Гумберт в Стране Чу- дес // Всемирное слово. 2001. № 14.

2. Мейер П. Найдите, что спрятал матрос / Пер. с англ. М. Э. Маликовой. М., 2007.

3. Набоков В. Ultima Thule // Набоков В. Собр. соч. русского периода в пяти томах. СПб., 2000. Т. 5.

4. Набоков В. Интервью Альфреду Аппелю, сентябрь 1966 // Набоков о Набокове и прочем: Интервью, рецензии, эссе. М., 2002.

5. Набоков В. Интервью Бернару Пиво на французском телевидении 1975 года // Звезда. 1999. № 4.

6. Набоков В. Письма к Вере / Вступ. статья Б. Бойдаж; пер. статьи и комм. А. Глебовской. СПб., 2018.

7. Шраер М. Бунин и Набоков: история соперничества. М., 2015.

8. Austin J. L. How to do Things with Words. Cambridge, 1962.

9. Boyd B. Nabokov. The American Years. Princeton, 1993.

10. Boyd B. The Year of Lolita // The New York Times. 1995. Sept. 8.

11. Centerwall B. S. Hiding in Plain Sight: Nabokov and Pedophilia // Texas Studies in Literature and Language. 1990. Vol. 32. № 3.

12. De Vries G. «Perplex’d in the Extreme»: Moral Facets of Vladimir Nabokov’s Work // Nabokov Studies. 1995. Vol. 2. № 1.

13. Freeman E. Honeymoon with a Stranger: Pedophiliac Picaresques from Poe to Nabokov // American Literature. 1998. Vol. 70. № 4.

14. Grossman J. D. Edgar Allan Poe in Russia: A Study in Legend and Literary In?uence. Wurzburg, 1973.

15. Johnson D. B. Nabokov’s Ada and Pushkin’s Eugene Onegin // Slavic and East European Journal. 1971. Vol. 15. № 3 (Fall).

16. Jones H. M. Nabokov’s Dark American Dream: Pedophilia, Poe, and Postmodernism in Lolita: A Thesis Submitted to the Department of English of the State University of New York, College at Brockport, 1995.

17. Luxembourg A. M. The Mystery of Vladimir Nabokov’s Sources: Some New Ideas on Lolita’s Intertextual Links // Connotations. 2004/2005. Vol. 14. № 1–3.

18. Maddox L. Nabokov’s Novels in English. Athens, 1983.

19. Manolescu-Oancea M. Humbert’s Arctic Adventures: Some Intertextual Explorations // Nabokov Studies. 2007/2008. Vol. 11. Project MUSE. Doi: 10.1353/nab 0.0006.

20. McNeely T. «Lo» and Behold: Solving the Lolita Riddle // Studies in the Novel. 1989. Vol. 21. № 2.

21. Meyer P. Find What the Sailor Has Hidden. Middletown, 1988.

22. Nabokov V. Letters to Vera / Ed. and transl. by O. Voronina and B. Boyd. New York, 2015.

23. Nabokov V. Selected Letters, 1940–1977 / Ed. by D. Nabokov and M. Bruccoli. San Diego; New York; London, 1989.

24. Nabokov V. Strong Opinions. New York, 1973.

25. Nabokov V. The Annotated Lolita / Ed. A. Appel. New York, 1970.

26. Nabokov V. Ultima Thule // Nabokov V. The Collected Stories. London, 1997.

27. Nyegaard O. Poshlust and High Art: A Reading of Nabokov’s Aesthetics // Orbis Litterarum. 2004. Vol. 59. № 5.

28. Peterson D. E. Nabokov and Poe // The New Romanticism: A Collection of critical Essays / Ed. by E. Alsen. New York; London, 2000.

29. Peterson D. E. Nabokov and the Poe-etics of Composition // The Slavic and East European Journal. 1989. Vol. 33. № 1 (Spring).

30. Power E. The Cinematic Art of Nympholepsy: Movie Star Culture as Loser Culture in Nabokov’s Lolita // Criticism. 1999. Vol. 41. № 1.

31. Proffer C. R. Keys to Lolita. Bloomington, 1968.

32. Sweeney S. E. Purloined Letters, Poe, Doyle, Nabokov // Russian Triquarterly. 1991. № 24.

33. Tamir-Ghez N. Rhetorical Manipulation in Lolita // The Structural Analysis of Narrative Texts. Columbus, OH, 1980.

34. Timofeev V. Nabokov’s «Ultima Thule»: An Exercise in Generative Narratology // Emerging Vectors of Narratology / Ed. by P. K. Hansen et al. Berlin; Boston, 2017 (Narratalogia; vol. 57).

35. Voronina O. The Tale of Enchanted Hunters: Lolita in Victorian Context // Nabokov Studies. 2006. Vol. 10.