Nation and democracy Article 2. The Illusion of a Post-national World and the Crisis in Western Democracies

Publication type Article
Status Published
Occupation: Professor
Affiliation: NRU HSE, civil service department
Address: 20, Myasnitskaya st., Moscow, 101000 Russian Federation
Occupation: Doctoral student
Affiliation: Centre de recherches Europes-Eurasie, Institut national des langues et civilisations orientales, INALCO
Address: Paris 63 Rue de Grand Moulins France 75013
Journal nameObshchestvennye nauki i sovremennost
EditionIssue 1

The second article (see article 1 in the previous issue) focuses on relationship between national unity and democracy. In this paper, considering both the EU and the US cases, the authors argue that the maintaining of modern democracy needs the very same background condition, whereas the current crisis in western political system is mainly due to such factors as national deconsolidation, deformation of civic nations and the elitist concept of “post-national” world. The article aims at showing that that idea remains an illusion and investigates its links to other fallacies, namely those about the causes of the national-populist wave, Brexit and the unexpected Trump’s election in the United States. The authors’ approach contributes to a better understanding of the relationship between nationhood, democracy and civil participation, as well as highlights the role of national identity as a key collective identity in the modern world.

Keywordsnational consent, national identity, democracy, national populism, cosmopolitanism, West, Europe, USA
Publication date29.01.2018
Number of characters1148
Cite   Download pdf To download PDF you should sign in
Размещенный ниже текст является ознакомительной версией и может не соответствовать печатной

views: 142

Readers community rating: votes 0

1. Agayev V. (2017) Pristupy identichnosti [Twists of identity]. Kommersant. 06.02 (

2. Bossuat G. (2005) Histoire d’une controverse. La référence aux héritages spirituels dans la Constitution européenne. Matériaux pour l’histoire de notre temps, vol. 78, no. 1, pp. 68–82.

3. Boyle N. (2017) The Problem with the English: England Doesn’t Want to Be Just Another Member of a Team. The New European (

4. Boym S. (2013) Budushcheye nostalgii [The future of nostalgia]. Neprikosnovenny zapas, no. 3 (

5. Chevalier L. (1958) Classes laborieuses et classes dangereuses pendant la première moitié du XIXe siècle. Paris: Pion.

6. Della Sala V. (2016) Europe’s Odyssey? Political Myth and the European Union. Nations and Nationalism, vol. 22, no. 3, pp. 524–541.

7. Dieckhoff A., Filippova E. (2014) Pereosmysleniye nacii v “postnatsionalnuyu” epokhu [Rethinking nation in the “post-national” era]. Etnograficheskoye obozreniye Online, no. 1, pp. 193–199.

8. Edwards-Levy A. (2016) Half of Americans Want to Take the Country Back to the 1950s. Huffington Post (

9. EU Official Tusk: Idea of One European Nation Is “Illusion” (2016) Daily Mail (

10. Fukuyama F. (2013) Problemy evropeyskoy identichnosti [The problems of European identity]. Gefter. 17.06 (

11. Furedi F. (2017) There Is an Alternative. (

12. Gaskell S. (2016) For Donald Trump, Making America “Great Again” Means Making It More like the 1950s. Mic. 16.09 (

13. Greenfeld L. (2012) Nacionalizm. Pyat’ putey k sovremennosti [Nationalism: five roads to modernity]. Мoscow: Per Se.

14. Gutteridge N. (2016) Stop the EUSSR! Hungary PM Slams Brussels ‘Sovietisation’ in Savage Attack on Federalism. Express. 24.10 (

15. Habermas J. (2016) Core Europe to the Rescue: A Conversation with Jürgen Habermas about Brexit and the EU Crisis. Social Europe. 12.07 (

16. Hosking G. (2016) Why Has Nationalism Revived in Europe? Nations and Nationalism, vol. 22, no. 2, pp. 210–221.

17. Huntington S. (2004) Kto my? Vyzovy amerikanskoy nacional’noy identichnosti [Who are we? The challenges to America’s national identity]. Moscow: AST.

18. Klaus V., Weigl J. (2017) OOO “Pereseleniye narodov” – Kratkoye posobiye dlya ponimaniya sovremennogo migracionnogo krizisa [The “Migration of peoples” Ltd. A short handbook to understand the current migrant crisis]. Moscow: Gaidar Institute.

19. Lacoste Y. (2014) La nation, ce concept géopolitique fort, n’est pas d’essence populiste. L’Express. 02/04 (

20. Lasch Ch. (2002) Vosstaniye elit i predatel’stvo demokratii [The revolt of the elites and the betrayal of democracy]. Moscow: Logos; Progress.

21. Level of Citizens’ Confidence in EU Institutions. Eurostat (

22. Lilla M. (2016) The End of Identity Liberalism. The New York Times. 18.11 (https://www.nytimes. com/2016/11/20/opinion/sunday/the-end-of-identity-liberalism.html).

23. Lukyanov F. (2017) Nervozny Myunkhen [A Nervous Munich]. Russia in Global Affairs. 20.02 (

24. Manin B. (2008) Printsipy predstavitelnogo pravleniya [The principles of representative government]. St.-Petersburg: European Univ. Press.

25. Merler S. (2017) Compensating the “Losers” of Globalization. Bruegel. 09.01 (

26. Milano B. (2017) To Understand Trump, Learn from His Voters. Harvard Gazette. 23.02 (http://news.

27. Miller A. (2015) Evropeyskiye voyny pamyati: kto vzorval konsensus istorii i chem za eto zaplatit [European memory wars: who broke the consensus and what she will pay for it]. Russia in Global Affairs. 02.06 (

28. Morin E. (2016) Le temps est venu de changer de civilisation. Acteurs de l’économie – La Tribune. 11.02 (

29. Mudde C. (2016) The Revenge of the Losers of Globalization? Brexit, Trump and Globalization. Huffington Post. 09.08 (

30. Obolonsky A. (2011) Krizis byurokraticheskogo gosudarstva: Reformy gosudarstvennoy sluzhby. Mezhdunarodny opyt i rossyskiye realii [The crisis of the bureaucratic state: civil service reforms. International experience and Russian realities]. Moscow: Fond “Liberal’naya Missiya”.

31. Petite S. (2016) Ne parlez plus des réfugiés de 1956 à la Hongrie. Le Temps. 26.20 (

32. Petry F. (2016) Nas nakroyet moshchnaya volna patriotizma [Here comes a new wave of patriotism]. Kultura. 15.12 (

33. Sedensky M. (2016) America Divided: The Rebellion of the Angry White Man. LGBTQ Nation. 20.10 (

34. Suleiman E. (2003) Dismantling Democratic States. Princeton, NJ: Princeton Univ. Press.

35. Taguieff P.-A. (2015) La revanche du nationalisme: Néopopulistes et xénophobes à l’assaut de l’Europe. Paris: Presses universitaires de France.

36. Taylor Ch. (2006) Pochemu demokratiya nuzhdayetsya v patriotizme [Why democracy needs patriotism]. Logos, no. 2, pp. 130–131.

37. Tishkov V., Filippova E. (eds.) Kulturnaya slozhnost’ sovremennykh nacy [Cultural complexity of modern nations]. Moscow: Politicheskaya enciklopediya.

38. Urbinati N. (2016) Iskazhennaya demokratiya. Mneniye, istina i narod [Democracy disfigured: opinion, truth, and the people]. Moscow: Gaidar Institute.

39. Vasagar J. (2013) German “Should Be a Working Language of EU”, Says Merkel’s Party. The Telegraph. 18.06 (

40. Weber E. (1976) Peasants into Frenchmen: The Modernization of Rural France, 1870–1914. Stanford, CA: Stanford Univ. Press.

Система Orphus