The Evolution of Franco-German Relations in 1949–2022: From the German Problem to the Franco-German Tandem and the Idea of the Power of Europe

After the Second World War, the most important priority of French foreign policy in Europe was the solution of the German problem, in other words, the prevention of the revival of Germany as a revanchist state. At the same time, French diplomacy, influenced by the “power complex”, sought to ensure the leading role of its country in the Western European part of the continent. Hence Paris's course, first towards anti-German alliances and then, following the proclamation of the Federal Republic of Germany in 1949, towards the formation of European defence structures with the participation of the FRG, to at least keep its possible rearmament under control. The accession of the Federal Republic of Germany into NATO in 1955 signalled the failure of this strategy. Charles de Gaulle, who came to power in 1958, tried to form a Franco-German alliance that would allow the creation of a “European Europe” independent of the United States. The failure of this policy, due to the pro-Atlantic stance of the Federal Republic, prompted his successors to take a more flexible position. On the one hand, the French created a tandem with their German partner in order to strengthen European integration, particularly in the field of defence (European Autonomous Defence); on the other hand, they strengthened France's relations with the USA and NATO. Yet the reunification of Germany on the basis of the constitution of the Federal Republic of Germany in 1990 exacerbated the already existing problem of power disparity in the Franco-German tandem in favour of Germany, which is slowly developing its own sovereign interests However, since his election in 2017, French President Emmanuel Macron, a staunch Europeanist, has been trying to use this tandem to promote the idea of a “European state” in the EU that can compete with the United States and China. However, the prospects for the implementation of this conception are very ambiguous.

Keywords

France, Germany, foreign policy, European integration, the German problem, foreign policy concepts, NATO, military security, military policy, defence capabilities, military-technical cooperation, collective defence

Received

25.05.2023

Publication date

31.08.2023

Number of characters

44746

Cite

GOST	Chernega V. The Evolution of Franco-German Relations in 1949–2022: From the German Problem to the Franco-German Tandem and the Idea of the “Power of Europe” // Novaia i noveishaia istoriia – 2023. – Issue 4 C. 151-166 [Electronic resource]. URL: https://nni.jes.su/S013038640024674-9-1 (circulation date: 18.05.2024). DOI: 10.31857/S013038640024674-9
MLA	Chernega, Vladimir "The Evolution of Franco-German Relations in 1949–2022: From the German Problem to the Franco-German Tandem and the Idea of the “Power of Europe”." Novaia i noveishaia istoriia 4 (2023):151-166. DOI: 10.31857/S013038640024674-9
APA	Chernega V. (2023). The Evolution of Franco-German Relations in 1949–2022: From the German Problem to the Franco-German Tandem and the Idea of the “Power of Europe”. Novaia i noveishaia istoriia (4), pp.151-166 DOI: 10.31857/S013038640024674-9

100 rub.

When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 1, views: 140

Readers community rating: votes 0

1. Manoilo A.V. Sovremenniye podhody Evropeyskogo soyuza k sozdaniyu sobstvennih vooruzhennih sil [Modern approaches of the European Union to the creation of its own armed forces] // Aktualinie problemi Evropi [Current problems of Europe]. 2020. № 4. S. 75–94. (In Russ.)

2. Nikulichev Yu.V. Probuzhdeniye “spychei krasavitsi”. Programma PESCO mezhdu atlantismom et evropeismom [Awakening of the “sleeping beauty”. PESCO program between Atlanticism and Europeanism] // Problemy evropeiskoi bezopasnosti [Problems of European security]. 2018. № 3. S. 47–63. (In Russ.)

3. Obichkina E.O. Vneshnyaya politika Emmanuelya Makrona: poiski geopolititcheskoi strategii v razladivsheysya mirivoi ierarhii [Foreign policy of Emmanuel Macron: the search for a geopolitical strategy in a disordered world hierarchy] // Aktualinie problemi Evropi [Current problems of Europe]. 2021. № 3. S. 235–274. (In Russ.)

4. Rubinsky Yu.I. Frantsiya: vremya Sarkozy [France: the time of Sarkozy]. Moskva, 2011. (In Russ.)

5. Rubinsky Yu.I., Sandeev A.A. Ot Eliseyskogo lj Ahenskogo dogovora [From Elysian to Aachen Treaty] // Sovremennaya Evropa [Contemporary Europe]. 2019. № 1. S. 26–41. (In Russ.)

6. Shmelev D.V. Franko-germanskii otnosheniya v kontekste evropeiskoi integratsii (1970-e godi [French-German relations in the context of European integration (in the 1970s) // Zapad – Vostok [West – East]. 2019. № 12. S. 29–42. (In Russ.)

7. Sidorov A.S. “Evropeiskaya oborona” cherez prizmu frantsuzskih interesov i vozmoznostey [“European defense” through the prism of French interests and capabilities] // Aktualinie problemi Evropi [Current problems of Europe]. 2020. № 4. S. 137–169. (In Russ.)

8. Sidorov A.S. Franko-germanskoye voenno-politicheskoye sotrudnichestvo: “okno vozmozhnostei” ili dvizheniye po inertsii [French-German militay-political cooperation: “window of opportunities” or movement by inertia? Aktualinie problemi Evropi [Current problems of Europe]. 2019. № 4. S. 172–186. (In Russ.)

9. Sidorov A.S. Voyenno-politicheskoye izmereniye evropeyskoi integratsii: pozitiya Frantsii (ot de Gollia do nashih dnei) [Military-political dimension of the European integration: the position of France (from de Gaulle to the present day)]. Мoskva, 2023. (In Russ.)

10. Timofeev P.P., Horolskaya M.V. Podhodi franko-germanskogo tandema k vzaimodeistviyu s Turtsiei v ochagah nestabilnosti Sredizemnomoria [Approaches of the French-German tandem to the pockets of instability in the Mediterranean] // Aktualinie problemi Evropi [Current problems of Europe]. 2022. № 4. S. 134–159. (In Russ.)

11. Trunov O.F. Postkolonialniy franzuskiy Sahel: strategichsekoye proniknoveniye FRG [Post-colonial French Sahel: the strategic penetration of the Federal Republic of Germany] // Politicheskaya nauka [Political Science]. 2022. № 1. S. 205–2023. (In Russ.)

12. Zueva K.P. Vneshniya politika Frantsii v epohu neogollisma [Foreign policy of France in the era of neo-gaullism] // Mirovaya ekonomika i mezhdunarodniye otnosheniya [World economy and international relations]. 2004. № 1. S. 70–79. (In Russ.)

13. Zvereva T.V. Vneshniya politika sovremennoi Frantsii [Foreign policy of the contemporary France]. Moskva, 2014. (In Russ.)

14. Adamczyk M. 1961, l’échec du “Plan Fouchet”, Enseigner de Gaulle // URL: https://enseigner.charlesde-gaulle.org/1961-lechec-du-plan-fouchet (access date: 14.01.2023).

15. Barotte N. Allemagne: les ambitions de la Bundeswehr minent l’équilibre franco-allemand // Le Figaro. 22.VIII.2022. URL: https://www/lefigaro.fr/international/allemagne-les-ambitions-de-la-bundeswehr-minent-l-equilibre-franco-allemand-20220822 (access date: 24.02.2023).

16. Bozo F. La politique étrangère de la France depuis 1945. Paris, 2019.

17. Bruno R. Ni vu, ni connu, Hollande veut réintégrer plainement la France à l’OTAN // Marianne. 20.I.2016. URL: htttps://marianne.net/politique/ni-vu-ni-connu-hollande-veut-reintegrer-la-france-danslotan (access date: 16.01.2023).

18. Carpentier J., Lebrun F. Histoire de France. Paris, 1987.

19. Charillon F. Guerres d’influence. Les Etats à la conquête des esprits. Paris, 2022.

20. Delaume C. Le couple franco-allemand n’existe pas. Paris, 2018.

21. Duby G. Histoire de France. Paris, 1970.

22. Dumoulin A., Gros-Verheide N. La politique européenne de sécurité zet de défense commune. Bruxelles, 2017.

23. Gerbet P. Jean Monnet – Charles de Gaulle. Deux conceptions de la construction européenne // Bossuet G., Wilkens A. Jean Monnet et les chemins de la paix. Paris, 1999. P. 411–433.

24. Kunz B. Paris et Berlin: un moteur stratégique de l’Europe en panne // La France dans le monde / sous la direction de F. Charillon. Paris, 2021. P. 86–93.

25. Lefebvre M. La politique étrangère de la France. Paris, 2019.

26. Lequesne Ch. Récurrences et changements dans l’engagement européen // La France, une puissance contrariée / sous la direction de B. Badie et D. Vidal. Paris, 2021. Р. 72–80.

27. Lorot P. La France dans le grand jeu mondial. Pour un nouveau leadership. Paris, 2022.

28. Meddah H. Emmanuel Macronréclame un budget record de 400 milliards d’euros pour les armées // L’Usine nouvelle. 20.II.2023. URL: https:// www.usinenouvelle.com/article/pourquoi-macron-reclame-un-budget-record-400-milliards-d-euros-pour-les armees (access date: 24.02.2023).

29. Michels P. La France face aux déclarations d’indépendance slovène et croate // Revue d'études comparatives Est-Ouest. 1996. Vol. 27. № 3. P. 75–101. URL: https://www.persee.fr/doc/receo_0336_0599_1996_num_27_3-2800 (access date: 01.02.2023).

30. Nivet B. L’Europe puissance, mythes et réalités. Bordeau, 2019.

31. Ouvry L. La difficile “voie française” au sein de l’OTYAN et ses enjeux // Défense et sécurité international. 2022. № 158. P. 88–95.

32. Pène F. Qu’est-ce que le Fonds européen de défense? // URL: //https://www.touteleurope.eu/l-uedans-le-monde/qu-est-ce-que-le-fonds-europeen-de-defense/ (access date: 02.07.2022).

33. Peyrefitte A. C’était de Gaulle. T. 1. La France redevient la France. Paris, 1994.

34. Pfeil U. La portée du voyage de François Mitterand en RDA (20–22 décembre 1989) // La mise en oeuvre de l’unification allemande (1998–1990) / sous la direction de A. Saint Sauveur et G. Scheilin. Paris, 1998. P. 325–340.

35. Soutou G-H. La France et l’entrée de deux Allemagnes aux Nations Unies // Relations internationales. 2006. № 127. P. 79–94. URL: https://www;cairn.info/revue-relations-internationales-2006-3-page-79.html (access date: 26.01.2023).

36. Strrobants J.-P. Défense: la Commission dévoile son projet pour réarmer le continent // Le Monde. 18.V.2022. URL: //https://www.lemonde.fr/economir/article/2022/05/18/defense-la-commission-devoileson-projet-pour-rearmer-le-continent_6126679 (access date: 30.06.2022).

37. Thomann P.-E. Le couple franco-allemand et le projet européen. Représentations géopolitiques, unité et rivalités. Paris, 2015.

38. Vaïsse M. Une puissance moyenne // La France, une puissance contrariée / sous la direction de B. Badie et D. Vidal. Paris, 2021. P. 95–102.

39. Vincent E. Berlin rallie quatorze pays de l’OTAN a l’achat d’un bouclier anti-missile, au grand dam de Paris // Le Figaro. 15.X.2022. URL: https://www.lemonde.fr/international/article/2022/10/15/berlin-rallie-quatorze-pays-de-l-otan-a-l-achat-d-un-bouclier-anti-missile-au-grand-dam-de-paris (access date: 10.01.2023).

40. Vincent E., Bezat M. Nouvel accord politique sur le SCAF, projet d’avion de combat européen du future // Le Monde. 19.X.2022. URL: https://www.lemonde.fr/economie/article/2022/11/19/nouvel-accord-politique-sur-le-scaf-projer-d-avion-de-combat-europeen-du-future_6150650_3234.html (access date: 10.01.2023).

41. Zajec O. La variable atlantiste // La France, une puissance contrariée / sous la direction de B. Badie et D. Vidal. Paris, 2021. P. 54–63.