A new source for Russian Religious History: the American Catholic Press, 1917–1924

 
PIIS013038640007610-9-1
DOI10.31857/S013038640007610-9
Publication type Article
Status Published
Authors
Affiliation: Brandeis University
Address: USA, Waltham
Journal nameNovaia i noveishaia istoriia
EditionIssue 6
Pages65-84
Abstract

Soviet antireligious policy not only eradicated religious institutions and their press, but also drastically reduced and distorted the corpus of historical documentation. While the state, party, and police did generate a substantial volume of materials against religious organizations and believers, the disestablishment of organized religion meant that much of the information assembled before 1917 was no longer collected. To help fill this void in the source base, it is important to draw upon materials available outside the former Soviet Union. This paper examines the American Catholic press in the first six years of Soviet power – a period when both the Vatican and Soviet authorities engaged in wide-ranging diplomatic discussions. This period was also a watershed for the Catholic press: in 1920 the National Catholic Welfare Council (the central Catholic institution in America) created what came to be called the Catholic News Agency (CNA), which collected information from around the world and provided a key source not only for American diocesan newspapers, but for the secular press in the United States and around the world. CNA gave particular attention to Russia, partly because of the Vatican’s diplomatic activities, partly because of expectations that the Catholic Church could proselytize among a Russian population that, by the Catholic account, remained religious despite Bolshevik antireligious campaigns. The agency’s editors, professional journalists from leading newspapers, assiduously solicited materials from Catholics still in Russia as well as those who had recently emigrated. Significantly, the American Catholic press did not closely adhere to the Vatican «line» and played a critical role in delaying recognition of the USSR until long after most European countries.

KeywordsCatholic Church, Soviet religious policy, Vatican-Soviet relations, Catholic show trial
AcknowledgmentThis study has been supported by the Russian Science Foundation (no. 19-189-00482) for the project: «Entangled Histories: Russia and the Holy See, 1917–1958».
Received22.11.2019
Publication date05.12.2019
Number of characters61841
Cite  
100 rub.
When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 0, views: 1741

Readers community rating: votes 0

1. Beglov A. L., Tokareva E. S. Sudebnyj protsess nad katolicheskim dukhovenstvom 1923 g. v osveschenii poslantsa Vatikana v Rossii. – Ehlektronnyj nauchno-obrazovatel'nyj zhurnal «Istoriya», t. 9, vyp. 4 (68). [Ehlektronnyj resurs]. URL: https://history.jes.su/s207987840002218-8-1/ (data obrascheniya 20.08.2019).

2. Zerno iz ehtoj zemli… Mucheniki Katolicheskoj Tserkvi v Rossii KhKh veka. Red. B. O. Chaplitskij. SPb., 2002.

3. Konfessional'naya politika Vremennogo pravitel'stva Rossii. Sbornik dokumentov. Sost. i red. M. A. Babkin. M., 2018.

4. Konfessional'naya politika sovetskogo gosudarstva 1917–1991 gg., t. 1, ch. 1–4. Otv. sost. M. I. Odintsov. M., 2018.

5. Karlov Yu. E. Sovetskaya vlast' i Vatikan v 1917–1924 g. – Rossiya i Vatikan v kontse XIX – pervoj treti XX vv. SPb., 2003, s. 157–184.

6. Kosik O. V. Golosa iz Rossii: Ocherki sbora i peredachi za granitsu informatsii o polozhenii Tserkvi v. SSSR (1920-e – nachalo 1930-kh godov). M., 2013.

7. Petrakki A. Papskaya missiya pomoschi Rossii. 1921–1923. – Rossiya i Vatikan v kontse XIX – pervoj treti KhKh veka, s. 183–259.

8. Rimsko-katolicheskaya tserkov' na Severo-Zapade Rossii v 1917–1945 gg. Sost. M. V. Shkarovskij. SPb., 1998.

9. Tikhij K. T. Amerikantsy o strane Sovetov. Vladivostok, 2000.

10. Tokareva E. S. Otnosheniya SSSR i Vatikana: ot peregovorov k razryvu 1922–1929. – Rossiya i Vatikan v kontse XIX – pervoj treti KhKh veka, s. 260–318.

11. Friz G. «Votserkovlenie» 1917 goda: tserkovnyj krizis i prikhodskaya revolyutsiya. – Gosudarstvo, religiya, tserkov' v Rossii i za rubezhom, 2019, №1–2, s. 30–57.

12. Bassow W. The Moscow Correspondents: Reporting on Russia from the Revolution to Glasnost. New York, 1989.

13. Baumgartner A. Catholic Journalism: A Study of Its Development in the United States, 1789–1930. New York, 1967.

14. Carey P. W. Catholics in America. A History. Westport, 2004.

15. Catholic Church before the Revolution 1917. Collection of Papers. Ed. M. Radvan. Lublin, 2003.

16. Catholic News Agency (CNA). - URL: https://thecatholicnewsarchive.org (accessed 15.08.2019).

17. Catholic Press Directory for 1923. Chicago, 1923.

18. Deedy J. G. The Catholic Press: The Why and the Wherefore. – The Religious Press in America. Ed. by Martin Marty et al. New York, 1963, p. 65–121.

19. Delahaye A. N. Elite Catholic Newspapers of the United States. PhD. Diss. University of Missouri, 1970.

20. Edmondson C. M. The Politics of Hunger: The Soviet Response to Famine, 1921. – Soviet Studies, v. 29, № 4, 1977, p. 506–518.

21. Filene P. G. Americans and the Soviet Experiment, 1917–1933. Cambridge, 1967.

22. Freeze G. L. From Dechristianization to Laicization: State, Church, and Believers in Russia. – Canadian Slavonic Papers, 2015, v. 57, p. 6–34.

23. Gallagher L. J. With the Papal Relief Mission in Russia. – Studies: An Irish Quarterly Review, v. 13, № 49, 192, p. 44–63.

24. Gallagher L. J. Edmund A. Walsh, S.J. A Biography. New York, 1962.

25. Gribble R. Cooperation and Conflict between Church and State: The Russian Famine of 1921–1923. – Journal of Church and State, v. 51, №4, 2009, p. 634–664.

26. Gribble R. Roman Catholicism an U.S. Foreign Policy – 1919–1935: A Clash of Policies. – Journal of Church and State, v. 50, №1, 2008, r. 73–99.

27. Gribble R. United States Recognition of Soviet Russia: 1917–1933 – Church and State Responses. – American Catholic Studies, v. 119, № 4, 2008, r. 21–51.

28. Hall F. A. Justin McGrath: First Director of NCWC News Service. – Catholic Press Annual, 1962, p. 38–41.

29. Hull H. L. The Holy See and Soviet Russia, 1918–1930. A Study in Full-Circle Diplomacy. Ph.D. diss. Georgetown University, 1970.

30. Laqueur W. The Fate of the Revolution. New York, 1967.

31. McAvoy T. T. The Americanist Controversy in Roman Catholicism 1895–1900. Notre Dame, 1963.

32. McCullagh F. The Bolshevik Persecution of Christianity. London, 1924.

33. McGowan R. A. Bolshevism in Russia and America. New York, 1920.

34. McKeown E. Apologia for an American Catholicism: The Petition and Report of the National Catholic Welfare Council to Pius XI. April 25, 1922. – Church History, v. 43, № 4, 1974, p. 514–528.

35. McNamara P. Russia, Rome, and Recognition: American Catholics and Anticommunism in the 1920s. – U.S. Catholic Historian, v. 24, № 2, 2006, p. 71–88.

36. McNamara P. A Catholic Cold War. Edmund A. Walsh, S.J., and the Politics of American Catholic Anticommunism. New York, 2005.

37. National Catholic Welfare Council. Bulletin, v. 1–3. Washington (D. C.), 1920–1923.

38. NCWC Press Department Completes Successful Year. – NCWC. Bulletin, v. 1, № 9, 1921, p. 7–8.

39. NCWC. 10th Anniversary of the N.C.W.C. News Service. – N.C.W.C. Review, v. 12, 1930, p. 6–7, 13.

40. Office of the Historian. Papers Relating to the Foreign Relations of the United States. - URL: https://history.state.gov/historicaldocuments (accessed 15.08.2019).

41. Pamphlet Explains Bolshevism in Russia and America. – NCWC, Bulletin, v. 1, №1, 1920, p. 14–15.

42. Pożarski K. Historia Kościoła Rzymskokatolickiego w Rosji i Polsce w Imperium Rosyjskim (XVIII–XX w.) w dokumentach Rosyyjskiego Państwowego Archiwum Historycznego, t. 1–2. Saint-Petersburg – Warsaw, 1999–2000.

43. Records of The Department of State Relating to the Internal Affairs of Russia and the Soviet Union, 1910–1929. Washington: National Archives, National Archives and Records Service, General Services Administration, 1960.

44. Reilly L. W. The Weak Points of the Catholic Press. – American Ecclesiastical Review, v. 10, 1894, p. 117–125.

45. Reilly M. L. A History of the Catholic Press Association, 1911–1968. Metuchen (N.J.), 1971.

46. Shaughnessy G. Has the Immigrant Kept the Faith? A Study of Immigration and Catholic Growth in the United States 1790–1920. New York, 1925.

47. Shelley T. J. The Oregon School Case and the National Catholic Welfare Conference. – Catholic Historical Review, v. 75, 1989, p. 439–457.

48. Slawson D. The Foundation and First Decade of the National Catholic Welfare Council. Washington (D. C.), 1992.

49. Stehle H. The Eastern Politics of the Vatican, 1917–1979. Athens, 1981.

50. Szczeniak B. The Russian Revolution and Religion. Notre Dame, 1959.

51. The Catholic Advance. Wichita, Kansas. - URL: https://www.newspapers.com/title_4467/the_catholic_advance/ (accessed 15.08. 2019)

52. The Pittsburgh Catholic. Pittsburgh, Pa. - URL: http://digital.library.duq.edu/cdm-pc/document.php?CISOROOT-/pc4&CISOPTR-7479&REC-99 (accessed 15 Aug. 2019).

53. The Witness. Dubuque, Iowa. URL: http://dubuquewitness.advantage-preservation.com/search?k-russia&st-1801&co-1780&t-31103&i-t&d-01/01/1901–12/31/2018&bcn-1&m-between&ord-k1 (accessed 15.08.2019).

54. Tokareva E. S. Vatican and Catholics in Russia in 1920–1930: Communication Problems. – Procedia: Social and Behavioral Sciences, v. 236, 2016, p. 379–384.

55. Trythall M. P. Pius XI and American Pragmatism. – Pius XI and America, ed. Charles Gallagher et al. Berlin, 2012. P. 25–85.

56. Trythall M. P. Russia’s Misfortune Offers Humanitarians a Splendid Opportunity: Jesuits, Communism, and the Russian Famine. – Journal of Jesuit Studies, v. 5, 2018, p. 71–96.

57. Valentinov A. A. The Black Book (The Assault of Heaven). Paris, 1924.

58. Walsh E. Papal Relief in Russia. – Woodstock Letters, v. 52, № 1, 1932, p. 32–41.

59. Walsh E. The Catholic Church in Present-Day Russia. – Catholic Historical Review, v. 18, № 2, 1932, r. 177–204.

60. Weir T. H. A European Culture War in the Twentieth Century? Anti-Catholicism and Anti-Bolshevism between Moscow, Berlin, and the Vatican 1922 to 1933. – Journal of Religious History, v. 39, № 2, 2015, p. 280–306.

61. Woywod S. The New Canon Law: a Commentary and Summary of the New Code of Canon Law. New York, 1918.

62. Yearbook of American Churches 1921–1922. New York, 1922.

63. Zatko J. A Contemporary Report on the Condition of the Catholic Church in Russia, 1922. – Harvard Theological Review, v. 53, № 4, 1922, p. 277–295.

64. Zatko, J. The Roman Catholic Church and Its Legal Position under the Provisional Government in Russia in 1917. – Slavonic and East European Review, v. 38, № 91, 1960, p. 476–92.

65. Zatko J. The Vatican and Famine Relief in Russia. – Slavonic and East European Review, v. 42, № 98, 1963, p. 54–63.

Система Orphus

Loading...
Up