People with a Human Appearance: the Papuans of New Guinea at Exhibitions in Moscow and St. Petersburg in December 1910 — April 1911

In December 1911, an entrepreneur of Greek origin, Angelo Koufakos, brought to Moscow three Papuans from New Guinea, their names, with some variations, are indicated as Noli, Lakki and Simvay. The Papuans were examined by Professor of Moscow University D. N. Anuchin and other specialists, which also attracted the attention of journalists from various newspapers. From late December 1910 to mid-January 1911, the Papuans were shown in the Moscow cinema “Grand Electro” on Tverskaya Street, and from late February to early April — in St. Petersburg, in the exhibition hall in the Eliseev house on Nevsky Prospect, and then in Cinema “Saturn”. February 4, 1911 one of the Papuans died in Moscow. The revealed publications devoted to these exhibitions, as well as the death of one Papuan, make it possible to reconstruct the circumstances of their recruitment and travel to Russia, the organization of their display to the general public, which is especially important, since such ethnic exhibitions, organized by individual entrepreneurs-adventurers, are much less studied than those that were arranged by large firms that had their own archives. The article examines the question discussed in modern historiography and in the public field, to what extent such exhibitions should be considered as odious “human zoos”, and to what extent — as acceptable and adequate forms of acquaintance with other cultures of that era, including for scientific purposes. Attention is also paid to the ways of representing this exhibition for the Russian public in newspapers and magazines of that time in the specific circumstances of the end of 1910 — beginning of 1911.

Keywords

ethnic exhibition, human zoo, New Guinea, Papuans, anthropology, colonialism, spectacular culture, Russian Empire, Moscow, St. Petersburg, ideas of superiority

Acknowledgment

The study was supported by the Russian Science Foundation (Project No. 20-18-00482).

Received

12.07.2023

Publication date

20.11.2023

Number of characters

74623

Cite

GOST	Savitskiy E. “People with a Human Appearance”: the Papuans of New Guinea at Exhibitions in Moscow and St. Petersburg in December 1910 — April 1911 // ISTORIYA – 2023. – V. 14. – Issue 10 (132) [Electronic resource]. URL: https://history.jes.su/S207987840028559-3-1 (circulation date: 18.05.2024). DOI: 10.18254/S207987840028559-3
MLA	Savitskiy, Evgeniy "“People with a Human Appearance”: the Papuans of New Guinea at Exhibitions in Moscow and St. Petersburg in December 1910 — April 1911." ISTORIYA 14.10 (132) (2023) DOI: 10.18254/S207987840028559-3
APA	Savitskiy E. (2023). “People with a Human Appearance”: the Papuans of New Guinea at Exhibitions in Moscow and St. Petersburg in December 1910 — April 1911. ISTORIYA 14(10 (132)) DOI: 10.18254/S207987840028559-3

100 rub.

When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 5, views: 124

Readers community rating: votes 0

1. Abashin S. Sovetskij kishlak. Mezhdu kolonializmom i modernizatsiej. M.: Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, 2015.

2. Anuchin D. N. Papuasy v Moskve // Russkie vedomosti. 15 dekabrya 1910. № 289. S. 4—5.

3. Arnol'di V. M. Po ostrovam malajskogo arkhipelaga. Vpechatleniya i nablyudeniya naturalista. M.: Minuvshee, 2014.

4. Vishlenkova E. A. Vizual'noe narodovedenie imperii, ili «Uvidet' russkogo dano ne kazhdomu». M.: Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, 2011.

5. Gyote I. V. O nemetskom zodchestve / per. Man N. // Gyote I. V. Sobranie sochinenij v 10 t. T. 10. Ob iskusstve i literature. M.: Khudozhestvennaya literatura, 1980. S. 7—15.

6. Delo akademika V. A. Serova // Rannee utro. 16 dekabrya 1910. № 200. S. 5.

7. Dikari s Novoj Gvinei v Moskve // Vokrug sveta. 1911. № 4. S. 64.

8. Dikari u Fal'ts-Fejna // Rannee utro. 16 dekabrya 1910. № 200. S. 5.

9. Estestvenno-nauchnyj i antropologicheskij muzej i panoptikum Zedel'mejera. Katalog estestvenno-nauchnogo i antropologicheskogo muzeya i panoptikuma Zedel'mejera. Pouchitel'nyj i interesnyj. Riga, 1898.

10. Esche o narodnom teatre // Novoe vremya. 28 yanvarya 1880. S. 1.

11. Zefel'd A. Dvadtsatipyatiletie S.-Peterburgskogo zoologicheskogo sada. 1865—1890: Istoricheskij ocherk. SPb., 1890.

12. Iskovskij A. E. Karl Fisher. Fotograf v Orenburge. Orenburg: Orenburgskaya kniga, 2023.

13. Kojranskij A. A. Lyudoedy v Moskve // Utro Rossii. 14 dekabrya 1910. № 325. S. 5.

14. Leskinen M. V. «Chelovecheskie zooparki» v Rossii: k postanovke problemy // Novoe proshloe. 2018. № 4. S. 148—163.

15. Leskinen M. V. «Chto my, Gagenbeki kakie, chto li»: lyudi v zoosadakh Rossijskoj imperii // Antropologicheskij forum. 2019. № 43. S. 61—88.

16. Miklukho-Maklaj N. N. Puteshestviya v Novoj Gvinee v 1871 g., 1872 g., 1874 g., 1876 g., 1877 g., 1880 g., 1883 g. T. 1. So vstupitel'noj stat'ej D. N. Anuchina. M.: Novaya Moskva, 1923.

17. Miklukho-Maklaj N. N. Puteshestviya na bereg Maklaya. M.: Geograficheskaya literatura, 1956.

18. Mirzekhanov V. Imperial Myth as a National Idea: Explicit and Hidden Meanings of the 1931 International Colonial Exhibition in Paris // ISTORIYA. 2021. Vol. 12. Is. 6 (104). URL: https://history.jes.su/s207987840016273-9-1/ DOI: 10.18254/S207987840016273-9

19. Mogil'ner M. Homo imperii. Istoriya fizicheskoj antropologii v Rossii. M. Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, 2008.

20. Muzej i panoptikum M. A. Shul'tse-Ben'kovskoj. Katalog Muzeya iskusstv, novostej, drevnostej, mekhaniki, muzyki, modelej, inkvizitsii, anatomii i prochego v 10-ti otdeleniyakh. M., 1903.

21. Muskatblit F. G. Lakki // Rannee utro. 6 fevralya 1911. № 29. S. 3.

22. Neizvestnyj Miklukho-Maklaj: Perepiska puteshestvennika s tsarstvuyuschim Domom Romanovykh, Ministerstvom inostrannykh del, Morskim ministerstvom i Imperatorskim Russkim Geograficheskim obschestvom / sost. Karimov O. V. M.: Kuchkovo pole, 2014.

23. Noli, Simvaj i Dlaka. Iz plemeni kaj-kaj // Russkoe slovo. 15 dekabrya 1910. № 289. S. 6.

24. Papuasy-kannibaly v Moskve. Dikari plemeni Kaya-Kaya privezennye s ostrova Novaya Gvineya. Samoe dikoe plemya na vsem zemnom share. Lyudi kamennogo veka. M., 1910.

25. Papuasy-lyudoedy v S. -Peterburge. Dikari plemeni Kaya-Kaya, vyvezennye vpervye v Evropu iz ostrova Novaya Gvineya. Samoe dikoe plemya na vsem zemnom share. Lyudi kamennogo veka. SPb., 1911.

26. Ruga V., Kokorev A. Moskva povsednevnaya: ocherki gorodskoj zhizni nachala KhKh v. M.: Olma-press, 2006.

27. Savitsky E. Exhibition of “Dahomean Amazons” in Moscow in 1901: Between Colonial Arrogance and Provincial Vanity // ISTORIYA. 2022. Vol. 13. Is. 9 (119). URL: https://history.jes.su/s207987840022915-5-1/ DOI: 10.18254/S207987840022915-5

28. Savitskij E. E. Demony v zooparke: sovremennoe iskusstvo i kolonizatsiya Severa v Rossii 1890-kh gg. // Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. 2017. № 2 (144). S. 260—284.

29. Savitskij E. E. Kak kupets Kalintsov v Vene v 1882 g. samoedov pokazyval: pokornost' i soprotivlenie «vse ravno chto zhivotnykh» // Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. 2020. № 1 (161). S. 124—139.

30. Savitsky E. The Exemplary Life of Сarl Hagenbeck, the Animal Trader and Organizer of the “Human Zoos”, in the Soviet Editions of the 1920s — late 1950s: Anti-Colonial Struggle, Scientific Progress, Spectacular Culture and the Construction of Political Identity // ISTORIYA. 2019. Vol. 10. Is. 11 (85). URL: https://history.jes.su/s207987840008088-5-1/ DOI: 10.18254/S207987840008088-5

31. Savitskij E. E. Poehtika i politika ehtnograficheskogo znaniya v postkolonial'nuyu ehpokhu // Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie. 2020. № 1 (161). S. 401—412.

32. Savitsky E. Samoyeds at the Budapest Zoo in 1882: Exploitation or Collaboration? // ISTORIYA. 2021. Vol. 12. Is. 6 (104). URL: https://history.jes.su/s207987840016258-2-1/ DOI: 10.18254/S207987840016258-2

33. Svet Ya. M. Istoriya issledovanij i otkrytiya Avstralii i Okeanii. M.: Mysl', 1966.

34. Smert' dikarya // Moskovskij listok. 5 fevralya 1911. № 28. S. 3.

35. Smert' Lakki // Rannee utro. 6 fevralya 1911. № 29. S. 5.

36. S'edennaya sobakami artistka // Rannee utro. 16 dekabrya 1910. № 200. S. 5.

37. Tumarkin D. D. Belyj papuas: N. N. Miklukho-Maklaj na fone ehpokhi. M.: Vostochnaya literatura, 2011.

38. Ukazatel' istoricheskogo, anatomicheskogo, patologicheskogo i ehtnologicheskogo muzeya i panoptikuma M. A. Shul'tse. Riga, 1891.

39. Fuko M. Nadzirat' i nakazyvat'. Rozhdenie tyur'my / per. Naumov V. M.: Ad Marginem, 1999.

40. Shipova T. N. Moskovskie fotografy, 1839—1930 gg. Istoriya moskovskoj fotografii. M.: Planeta, 2012.

41. Yanchuk N. A. Nikolaj Nikolaevich Miklukho Maklaj i ego uchenye trudy. K 25-letiyu ego konchiny (1846—1888 gg.). SPb., 1913.

42. Ames E. Carl Hagenbeck’s Empire of Entertainment. Washington: University of Washington Press, 2008.

43. Diaz-Andreu M. A World History of Nineteenth-Century Archaeology: Nationalism, Colonialism, and the Past. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2008.

44. Dumézil G. L’Idéologie tripartite des Indo-Européens. Bruxelles: Latomus, 1958.

45. Gordon D. C. The Australian Frontier in New Guinea, 1870—1885. N. Y.: Columbia University Press, 2019.

46. Govor E., Howes H. Russia and the Pacific. Expeditions, Networks, and the Acquisition of Human Remains // The Routledge Companion to Indigenous Repatriation: Return, Reconcile, Renew / ed. Fforde C., McKeown C. T., Keeler H. N. Y.: Routledge, 2020. P. 521—537.

47. Mackenzie J. M. Museums and Empire: Natural History, Human Cultures and Colonial Identities. Manchester: Manchester University Press, 2010.

48. Monroe J. W. Metropolitan Fetish: African Sculpture and the Imperial French Invention of Primitive Art. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 2019.

49. Mückler H. Kolonialismus in Ozeanien. Wien: Facultas, 2012.

50. Nationalism and Archeology in Europe / ed. Diaz-Andreu, Champion T. N. Y.: Routledge, 2016.

51. Novikova I. Imagining Africa and Blackness in the Russian Empire: From Extra-Textual “Arapka” and Distant Cannibals to Dahomey Amazon Shows — live in Moscow and Riga // Social Identities. Journal for the Study of Race, Nation and Culture. 2013. Vol. 19. No. 5. P. 571—591.

52. Rutherford D. Living in the Stone Age. Reflections on the Origins of a Colonial Fantasy. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2018.

53. Savitsky E. Why Hidden Ears Matter: On Kalintsov’s Samoyed Exhibition in Vienna, 1882 // Staged Otherness. Ethnic Shows in Central and Eastern Europe / ed. Demski D., Czarnecka D. Budapest; Vienna: CEU Press, 2022. P. 137—163.

54. Schweighofer E. Vom Neandertal nach Afrika. Der Streit um den Ursprung der Menschheit im 19 und 20 Jahrhundert. Göttingen: Wallstein, 2018.

55. Thode-Arora H. Für fünfzig Pfennig um die Welt. Die Hagenbeckschen Völkerschauen. Frankfurt: Campus, 1989.

56. Thomas N. Entangled Objects: Exchange, Material Culture, and Colonialism in the Pacific. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1991.

57. Wolter S. Die Vermarktung des Fremden. Exotismus und die Anfänge des Massenkonsums. Frankfurt: Campus, 2005.

58. Zoos humains et exhibitions coloniales. 150 ans de l’invention de l’Autre / sous la dir. Blanchard P., Bancel N., Boyotsch G. P.: La Découverte, 2011.