Rhetorical Practices of the State Duma of the Russian Empire: Features of the Transfer of European Parliamentary Traditions into the Russian Political Context (1906—1916)

Usmanova, Dilara

doi:10.18254/S207987840016147-0

Home

ISTORIYA

Issue 6 (104)

Rhetorical Practices of the State Duma of the Russian Empire: Features of the Transfer of European Parliamentary Traditions into the Russian Political Context (1906—1916)

Annotation
Reviews
References

Rhetorical Practices of the State Duma of the Russian Empire: Features of the Transfer of European Parliamentary Traditions into the Russian Political Context (1906—1916)

PII

S207987840016147-0-1

DOI

10.18254/S207987840016147-0

Publication type

Article

Status

Published

Authors

Dilara Usmanova

Affiliation: Kazan Federal University
Address: Russian Federation, Kazan

Journal name

ISTORIYA

Edition

Abstract

The article analyzes the influence of the European parliamentary experience on the process of formation of Russian parliamentarism and development of parliamentary rhetorical practices in late imperial Russia. Particular attention is paid to parliamentary rhetoric. In addition to the political context and the acuteness of certain public problems, it was greatly influenced by the nature of the meeting room in the Tauride Palace, the order of the sessions, and the professional skills of the speaker and the members of the presidium. Russian liberals, who were considered students of their “Western teachers”, acted as translators of European political experience in the first place. The channels for the spread of Western influence can be seen in the experience of Russians in Europe during their student years, during short private visits, or on official business. Books and the mass publication of translated literature on oratory were also of great importance in the transfer of rhetorical experience. In addition to considering the main channels for the transfer of Western parliamentary traditions, it is also important to analyze how the influence of European parliamentary practices was evaluated and interpreted by different political forces both inside and outside the Tauride Palace, especially during political debates.

Keywords

State Duma, parliamentary rhetoric, Tauride Palace, transfer of Western parliamentary traditions

Received

06.02.2021

Publication date

19.07.2021

Number of characters

67183

Cite

GOST	Usmanova D. Rhetorical Practices of the State Duma of the Russian Empire: Features of the Transfer of European Parliamentary Traditions into the Russian Political Context (1906—1916) // ISTORIYA – 2021. – V. 12. – Issue 6 (104) [Electronic resource]. URL: https://history.jes.su/S207987840016147-0-1 (circulation date: 26.07.2024). DOI: 10.18254/S207987840016147-0
MLA	Usmanova, Dilara "Rhetorical Practices of the State Duma of the Russian Empire: Features of the Transfer of European Parliamentary Traditions into the Russian Political Context (1906—1916)." ISTORIYA 12.6 (104) (2021) DOI: 10.18254/S207987840016147-0
APA	Usmanova D. (2021). Rhetorical Practices of the State Duma of the Russian Empire: Features of the Transfer of European Parliamentary Traditions into the Russian Political Context (1906—1916). ISTORIYA 12(6 (104)) DOI: 10.18254/S207987840016147-0

100 rub.

When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 0, views: 395

Readers community rating: votes 0

1. Azham M. Iskusstvo govorit' publichno. Psikhofiziologicheskaya teoriya krasnorechiya. Perevod so 2-go frantsuzskogo izdaniya. SPb., 1900 (2-e i 3-e izd. — 1908 i 1910 gg.).

2. Aronov V. D. Pervyj spiker. Opyt nauchnoj biografii Sergeya Andreevicha Muromtseva. M., 2006.

3. Bogdanov S. V. Natsional'nyj i zarubezhnyj opyt v formirovanii i funktsionirovanii Gosudarstvennoj Dumy i Gosudarstvennogo Soveta v nachale KhKh v.: dis. … kand. ist. nauk. M., 2003.

4. Borodin N. A. Idealy i dejstvitel'nost'. Sorok let zhizni i raboty ryadovogo russkogo intelligenta (1879—1919). Berlin; Parizh, 1930.

5. Bublikov A. A. Russkaya revolyutsiya (ee nachalo, arest Tsarya, perspektivy). Vpechatleniya i mysli ochevidtsa i uchastnika. N'yu-Jork, 1918.

6. Vinaver M. M. Nedavnee (Vospominaniya i kharakteristiki). 2-e izdanie, dopolnennoe. Parizh, 1926.

7. Govorov A. Oratorskoe iskusstvo v drevnee i novoe vremya. Kazan', 1897.

8. Gosudarstvennaya Duma Rossijskoj imperii: portrety politicheskikh liderov (1906—1917). M., 2006.

9. Gromyko S. A. «Duma narodnogo gneva». O rechevoj agressii v Pervoj Gosudarstvennoj Dume // Russkaya rech'. 2006. № 6.

10. Gromyko S. A. «Natsional'nyj argument» v russkoj parlamentskoj ritorike (na materiale diskussii v Gosudarstvennoj dume Rossijskoj imperii) // Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. 2018. Vyp. 56.

11. Gromyko S. A. Pervoe russkoe ritoricheskoe rukovodstvo po politicheskomu krasnorechiyu (O knige M. N. Popova «Politicheskoe krasnorechie. Chto nuzhno dlya oratora») // Nauchnyj dialog. 2019. № 9.

12. Gromyko S. A. Russkij politicheskij diskurs nachala KhKh v.: na materiale diskussii v I Gosudarstvennoj Dume 1906 g. Diss… kand. filol. nauk. Vologda, 2007.

13. Gromyko S. A. Yazyk rossijskogo parlamenta: stanovlenie otechestvennoj parlamentskoj kommunikatsii v nachale KhKh v. // Politicheskaya lingvistika. 2011. № 2 (36).

14. Dessuar M. Oratorskoe iskusstvo dlya vsekh. Pg., 1915.

15. Dnevnik Alekseya Sergeevicha Suvorina. London; M., 1999.

16. Dubentsov B. B. Osnovnye zakony Rossijskoj imperii 1906 g. kak transfer zapadnogo konstitutsionalizma: otsenki trenda togda i teper' // Peterburgskij istoricheskij zhurnal. 2015. № 2.

17. Dulesov E. P. Metafora v parlamentskom diskurse (na materiale rechej rossijskikh deputatov nachala KhKh v.): avtoreferat dis. … kand. filol. nauk. Izhevsk, 2019.

18. Izvol'skij A. P. Vospominaniya (byvshego Ministra inostrannykh del). Pg.; M., 1924.

19. Kolonitskij B. I. Simvoly vlasti i bor'ba za vlast': k izucheniyu politicheskoj kul'tury rossijskoj revolyutsii 1917 g. SPb., 2012.

20. Kulikov S. V. Narodnoe predstavitel'stvo Rossijskoj imperii (1906—1917 gg.) v kontekste mirovogo konstitutsionalizma nachala KhKh v.: sravnitel'nyj analiz // Tavricheskie chteniya — 2009: Aktual'nye problemy istorii parlamentarizma v Rossii (1906—1917 gg.). Mezhdunarodnaya nauchnaya konferentsiya, S.-Peterburg, Tavricheskij dvorets, 4 dekabrya 2009 g. Sbornik nauchnykh statej / pod red. A. B. Nikolaeva. SPb., 2010.

21. Lukoyanov I. V. U istokov rossijskogo parlamentarizma: Istoriko-dokumental'noe izdanie. SPb., 2003.

22. Maklakov V. A. Iz vospominanij. N'yu-Jork, 1954.

23. Maklakov V. A. Vtoraya Gosudarstvennaya Duma (Vospominaniya sovremennika). M., 2006.

24. Maklakov V. A. F. N. Plevako. Lektsiya, prochitannaya v mae 1909 g. v Peterburge v Obschestve lyubitelej oratorskogo iskusstva. M., 1910.

25. Maksudi S. Angliyagә sәyakhәt. Kazan', 1914.

26. Medushevskij A. N. Demokratiya i avtoritarizm: Rossijskij konstitutsionalizm v sravnitel'noj perspektive. M., 1997.

27. Muromtsev S. Vnutrennij rasporyadok Gosudarstvennoj Dumy. M., 1907.

28. Nakaz Gosudarstvennoj Dumy (po rabotam 2-j Gosudarstvennoj Dumy) s ob'yasneniyami / sost. V. A. Maklakov i O. Ya. Pergament. SPb., 1907.

29. Nakaz Gosudarstvennoj Dumy. Predmetnyj ukazatel' k nakazu. Pg., 1915.

30. Nakazy palaty deputatov Frantsuzskoj respubliki // Zhurnal Ministerstva yustitsii. 1906. № 2.

31. Nakazy Rejkhstaga Germanskoj imperii i Prusskoj palaty deputatov // Zhurnal Ministerstva yustitsii. 1906. № 1.

32. Novikov M. M. Ot Moskvy do N'yu-Jorka: Moya zhizn' v nauke i politike. N'yu-Jork, 1952.

33. Nol'de A. Poryadki Avstrijskogo parlamenta // Zhurnal Ministerstva yustitsii. 1906. № 3.

34. Obolenskij V. A. Moya zhizn', moi sovremenniki. P., 1988.

35. Oznobishin A. A. Vospominaniya chlena IV-j Gosudarstvennoj dumy. Parizh, 1937.

36. Olar A. Oratory revolyutsii. T. 1. Uchreditel'noe sobranie. M., 1907; T. 2. Zakonodatel'noe sobranie i Konvent. M., 1908.

37. Pilenko A. A. Russkie parlamentskie pretsedenty. SPb., 1907. Vyp. 1; 1908. Vyp. 2.

38. Popov M. N. Politicheskoe krasnorechie. SPb., 1906.

39. Protokol zasedaniya 7 fevralya 1908 g. obschestva lyubitelej oratorskogo iskusstva // Pravo. 23.03.1908.

40. Rozanov V. V. V Tavricheskom dvortse // Rozanov V. V. Sobranie sochinenij. Kogda nachal'stvo ushlo… / sost. P. P. Apryshko i A. N. Nikolyukin. M., 1997.

41. Rozental' I. S. Provokator Roman Malinovskij: Sud'ba i vremya. M., 1996.

42. Rusanov N. S. V ehmigratsii: vospominaniya. M., 1929.

43. Savrasov A. F. Nakaz Gosudarstvennoj dumy (1906—1917): istoriya sozdaniya i primeneniya: dis. … kand. ist. nauk. Voronezh, 2010.

44. Senin A. S. Aleksandr Ivanovich Guchkov. M., 1996.

45. Solov'ev K. A. Politicheskaya kul'tura // Ocherki russkoj kul'tury. Konets XIX — nachalo XX vv. T. 2: Vlast'. Obschestvo. Kul'tura. M., 2011.

46. Tan-Bogoraz V. G. Muzhiki v Gosudarstvennoj dume. Ocherki. M., 1907.

47. Tyrkova-Vil'yams A. Na putyakh k svobode. N'yu-Jork, 1952.

48. Usmanova D. M. Musul'manskie predstaviteli v Rossijskom parlamente. Kazan', 2005.

49. Usmanova D. M. Oratorika v revolyutsionnom zakonodatel'nom sobranii: ritoricheskij portret Gosudarstvennoj dumy 1-go i 2-go sozyvov (1906—1907) // Ab imperio. 2014. № 1.

50. Formizano Ronal'd P. Ponyatie politicheskoj kul'tury // Pro et Contra. 2002. T. 7. № 3.

51. Shidlovskij S. I. Vospominaniya. Ch. 1. Berlin, 1923.

52. Schegol'kov A. «Ob oratorskom iskusstve»: chto nuzhno znat' nachinayuschemu oratoru dlya umeniya proiznosit' rechi sudebnye, dukhovnye, politicheskie i salonnye. Pg., 1917.

53. Yarov A. Oratorskoe iskusstvo. M., 1917.

54. Almond G., Verba S. The Civic Culture: Political Attitudes and democracy in Five Nations. Princeton, 1963.

55. Manow Philip. Im Schatten des Königs. Die politische Anatomie demokratischer Repräsentation. Frankfurt am Main, 2008.

56. Mergel Thomas, Parlamentarische Kultur in der Weimarer Republik: politische Kommunikation, symbolische Politik und Öffentlichkeit in Reichstag. Düsseldorf, 2002.

57. Orlando Figes, Kolonitskii Boris. Interpreting the Russian Revolution. The language and Symbols of 1917. New Haven; L., 1999.

58. Parlamentarische Kulturen vom Mittelalter bis in die Moderne: Reden — Räume — Bilder. Jörg Feuchter, Johannes Helmrath (Hrsg.). Düsseldorf, 2013.

59. Semyenov A. “The Real and Live Ethnographic Map of Russia”: the Russian Empire in the Mirror of the State Duma // Empire Speaks Out. Languages of Rationalization and Self-Description in the Russian Empire. Ed.: Ilya Gerasimov, Jan Kusber and Alexander Semyenov. Leiden, 2009.

60. Usmanova D. Revolutionsrhetorik im russischen Parlament. Die Staatsduma zur Zeit der Revolution von 1905—1907 // Parlamentarische Kulturen vom Mittelalter bis in die Moderne: Reden — Räume — Bilder. Düsseldorf, 2013.