PHILOSOPHICAL AND METHODOLOGICAL FOUNDATIONS OF THE CONSTITUTIONALIZATION OF RUSSIAN LAW IN THE CONTEXT OF POST-CLASSICAL JURISPRUDENCE

 
PIIS102694520020621-4-1
DOI10.31857/S102694520020621-4
Publication type Article
Status Approved
Authors
Occupation: Chief Consultant; Associate Professor of the Department of Criminal Procedure Law
Affiliation:
Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation
North-Western Branch of the Federal State Budgetary Educational Institution of Higher Education «Russian State University of Justice», St. Petersburg
Address: Russian Federation,
Abstract

The article demonstrates the cognitive value of the postclassical legal theories underlying the phenomenological and hermeneutic methodology of postmodern philosophy. The ways of overcoming the relativism of postmodernism, which raises the right to the top of the pyramid, based on the foundations of Russian society, forming the context of meaning-making carried out during the constitutionalization of criminal proceedings, are outlined. The article reveals the value component of the methodology of conflict resolution used by the Constitutional Court, based on the postclassical jurisprudence. The author argues that it is impossible to resolve these conflicts through traditional legal and dogmatic methods of law enforcement used by ordinary courts. Constitutionalization is presented as a process for the transformation of natural law into a positive law, carried out in two stages: at the first, a certain right is elevated to the rank of a constitutional norm; at the second, this right is deployed in sectoral legislation. It is concluded that the constitutionalization carried out by the Constitutional Court is nothing more than a way of resolving normative conflicts, during which the Constitutional Court interprets both the provisions of the Constitution and the norms of laws, bringing them into a state of mutual non-contradiction.

Keywordsphenomenology; hermeneutics; context; meaning; postclassical jurisprudence; constitutionalization; normative conflict; legal positivism; legal dogmatics; natural law.
Received24.11.2022
Number of characters39176
100 rub.
When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

1. Alekseev I.M. Prospects of differentiation of the criminal procedural form. "Criminal proceedings in Russia: current state and prospects of development": collection based on the materials of the All-Russian Scientific and Practical conference. Krasnodar, 2019. pp. 5-8.

2. Alekseev I.M. Methodological foundations of uniform application of laws in the field of criminal proceedings. Theory and practice of crime investigation: materials of the IX International Scientific and Practical Conference (April 15, 2021). Krasnodar: Krasnodar University of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, 2021. pp. 358-363.

3. Alekseev I.M. Uniform application of laws in the context of postclassical jurisprudence // Journal of the Siberian Federal University. Humanities. 2021. 14 (11). pp. 1596-1605.

4. Apel K.-O. Transformation of philosophy. M., 2001. 344 p.

5. Bayteeva M.V. Language and law. Monograph. Kazan, 2013. 252 p.

6. Gadamer G.-G. Truth and method. M., 1988. 704 p.

7. Gadamer G.-G. Relevance of the beautiful. M., 1991. 366 p.

8. Gajiyev H.I. The role of judicial interpretation in the evolution of legal relations // Russian Justice. 2022 No. 1. pp. 63-66.

9. Gaponov A.S. The nature of social cognition: the heuristic potential of the phenomenological-hermeneutic program: dissertation of the Candidate of Philosophical Sciences. Tomsk, 2016. 117 p.

10. Golovko L.V. Constitutionalization of the Russian criminal process: between slogans and reality // State and Law. 2013. No. 12. pp. 83-94.

11. Golovko L.V. Post-Soviet theory of law: difficulties of positioning in the historical and comparative legal context // Problems of post-Soviet theory and philosophy of law: collection of articles. M., 2016. pp. 92-126.

12. Gredeskul N.A. To the doctrine of the exercise of law. The intellectual process required for the exercise of the right. Kharkiv. 1900. 325 p.

13. Husserl E. The crisis of European sciences and transcendental phenomenology. St. Petersburg, 2004. 399 p.

14. Ershov V.V. Dialectics of sources and forms of law // Journal of Constitutional Justice. 2021. No. 6 (84). pp. 20-24.

15. Zorkin V.D. Under the sign of the Basic Law, the Constitutional Court at the turn of the fourth decade // Rossiyskaya Gazeta. 2021. No. 247.

16. Zorkin V.D. Constitutional justice: procedure and meaning. SPb., 2021. 154 p.

17. Zorkin V.D. Ten lectures on law: monograph. M., 2021. 400 p.

18. Kokotov A.N. Constitutional Court of Russia as a human rights court // Journal of Constitutional Justice. 2022. No. 2 (86). pp. 1-6.

19. Kravets I.A. The concept and methods of constitutionalization of the legal order // Russian Law Journal. 2003. No. 4 (40). pp. 9-18.

20. Methodological aspects of constitutional control (to the 30th anniversary of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation). St. Petersburg, 2021. 179 p.

21. Resolution of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation No. 49-P dated December 25, 2020 "On the Case of Checking the Constitutionality of Subparagraph 3 of paragraph 5 of the Resolution of the Governor of the Moscow Region "On the introduction of a high-alert regime in the Moscow Region for the Management Bodies and Forces of the Moscow Regional Emergency Prevention and Response System and some measures to prevent the spread of a new coronavirus infections (COVID-2019) on the territory of the Moscow region "in connection with the request of the Protvinsky City Court of the Moscow region". Legal reference system "Consultant Plus" (date of application: 01.05.2022).

22. Polyakov A.V. Communicative concept of law (genesis and theoretical and legal justification): diss. doct. jurid. sciences'. in the form of scientific. dokl. SPb., 2002. 94 p.

23. Polyakov A.V. St. Petersburg School of Philosophy of Law and the tasks of modern jurisprudence // News of higher educational institutions. Jurisprudence. 2000. No. 2 (229). pp. 4-23.

24. Postclassical ontology of law: monograph / edited by I. L. Chestnov. SPb., 2016. 684 p.

25. Habermas Yu. Moral consciousness and communicative action. St. Petersburg, 2000. 377 p.

26. Schutz A. Favorites: A world glowing with meaning. M., 2004. 1054 p.

Система Orphus

Loading...
Up