All
 
|
 
 


“Solar” cases: could Italy’s withdrawal from the Energy Charter Treaty lead to its collapse?
 
PIIS102694520019171-9-1
DOI10.31857/S102694520019171-9
Publication type Article
Status Published
Authors
Elena Ermakova 
Occupation: associate Professor of Department of Civil Law and Civil Procedure and Private International Law, Law Institute
Affiliation: RUDN University
Address: Russian Federation,
Journal nameGosudarstvo i pravo
EditionIssue 3
Pages150-163
Abstract

The article notes that investments in solar energy have already led to a number of arbitration cases related to the subsequent change in investment incentives. The so-called Solar Cases, initiated by investors under the Energy Charter Treaty (ECT) against Kingdom Spain, Italy and the Czech Republic, focused on the question of whether states could adjust incentives (subsidies and feed-in tariffs) to the detriment of investors after these investors relied on these subsidies to make their investments. Following the results of these arbitration proceedings, the European Union in 2019 decided to revise the text of the ECT. Eight rounds of negotiations were held during 2020 and 2021, the last of which took place in November 2021. Many believe that the reform of the existing treaty has taken too long. In February 2021, France sent a letter to the European Commission on the need for a coordinated EU exit from the ECT. Against this background, Italy’s withdrawal from the ECT on January 1, 2016, as well as Russia’s withdrawal of the signature on the treaty in 2018, are actions that determine the inevitable collapse of the ECT in the very near future. This article is devoted to the study of the causes and legal consequences of these events. Since Russia’s withdrawal from the ECT has already been the subject of study by many Russian and foreign scholars, the author focused their attention on the study of Italian arbitration disputes based on the ECT provisions, as well as on the study of foreign doctrine on this issue.

KeywordsEuropean Union law, Italian law, green finance, energy transition, solar disputes, ECT.
AcknowledgmentThe research was carried out with the financial support of the RFBR in the framework of the scientific project No. 20-011-00270 “a”.
Received30.11.2021
Publication date29.03.2022
Number of characters48927
Cite  
100 rub.
When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 1, views: 388

Readers community rating: votes 0 

1. Dzgoev A.T. (2017). International legal aspects of the settlement of energy disputes within the framework of the Energy Charter Treaty // Scientific works of RUDN - a branch of the RANEPA. 2017. Vol. 8. Issue 1 (28). P. 36–40 (in Russ.).
2. Ermakova E.P. (2014). Alternative Energy Dispute Resolution. Part 2. International disputes // Herald of the State Registration Chamber under the Ministry of Justice of Russia. 2014. No. 1 - 2. P. 37 - 46 (in Russ.).
3. Ermakova E.P. (2021). Arbitration as a means of resolving disputes about climate change // Proceedings of the ISL of the RAS. 2021.Vol. 16. No. 5. P. 55–78. DOI: 10.35427 / 2073-4522-2021-16-5 (in Russ.).
4. Kuzhatov B.G. (2021). Problems of the standard of fair and equal treatment in the Energy Charter Treaty // Herald of the Institute of Legislation and Legal Information of the Republic of Kazakhstan. 2021. No. 2 (65). P. 209 - 216 (in Russ.).
5. Lesnykh A. (2021). France offers the EU to withdraw from the Energy Charter // Vedomosti. 2021. February 15 (in Russ.).
6. Pastushkov O. (2021). The struggle for the dismantling of the little-known Energy Charter Treaty // Vista-Hermes.ru. 11/24/2021. URL: https://vista-hermes.ru/ekonomika/borba-za-demontazh-maloizvestnogo-dogovora-k-energeticheskoj-hartii  / (accessed: 25.11.21) (in Russ.).
7. Pominova I. (2014). Comprehensive study of the risks and benefits for the Russian Federation from participation in the Energy Charter // Energy Charter Secretariat. 2014. URL: https://www.energycharter.org/fileadmin/DocumentsMedia/Occasional/Russia_and_the_ECT_ru.pdf  (accessed: 19.10.2021) (in Russ.).
8. Topalov A. Energy without Charter // JSC “Gazeta.Ru”. 06.08.2009. URL: https://www.gazeta.ru/business/2009/08/06/3233761.shtml  (accessed: 19.10.2021) (in Russ.).
9. Frolova E.E. The new ecosystem of the financial market of the European Union: digitalization and sustainability // Herald of the RUDN. Series: Legal Sciences. 2020. Vol. 24. No. 3. P. 673 - 694. DOI: 10.22363/2313-2337-2020-24-3-673-694 (in Russ.).
10. Baker C.M. et al (2021). Climate change and sustainability disputes: International arbitration perspectives // Norton Rose Fulbright. July 2021. URL: https://www.nortonrosefulbright.com/en-us/knowledge/publications/b4cbedfe/climate-change-and-sustainability-disputes-international-arbitration-perspective  (accessed: 19.10.2021).
11. Behl T., Arora D.  (2021). Modernisation of Energy Charter Treaty: Addressing the Elephant in the Room over Investment Protection v/s Sustainable Development//IJPIEL, 7 May 2021. URL: https://ijpiel.com/index.php/2021/05/06/modernisation-of-energy-charter-treaty-addressing-the-elephant-in-the-room-over-investment-protection-v-s-sustainable-development/?et_fb=1&PageSpeed=off  (accessed: 29.11.2021).
12. Benson C. (2020). The Energy Charter Treaty//Global Arbitration Review. 10 November 2020. URL: https://globalarbitrationreview.com/guide/the-guide-energy-arbitrations/4th-edition/article/the-energy-charter-treaty  (accessed: 19.10.2021).
13. De Luca A. (2015). Renewable Energy in the EU, the Energy Charter Treaty, and Italy’s Withdrawal Therefrom (January 23, 2015). OGEL/TDM 3 (2015), Bocconi Legal Studies Research Paper No. 2657395. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2657395  (accessed: 19.10.2021).
14. Dudin M.N., Frolova E.E., Artemeva Yu. A., etc. Problems and perspectives of BRICS countries transfer to “green” economy and law-carbon energy industry // International Journal of Energy Economics and Policy. 2016. Vol. 6. No. 4. P. 714 - 720.
15. Dupouey V. (2021). 1 million citizens against the Energy Charter Treaty // European Green Party. 10 March 2021. URL: https://europeangreens.eu/content/1-million-citizens-against-energy-charter-treaty  (accessed: 19.10.2021).
16. Eckes C., Ankersmit L. (2021). Komstroy: the beginning of the end for the Energy Charter Treaty? // European Law Blog. 4 Oct. 2021. URL: https://europeanlawblog.eu/2021/10/04/komstroy-the-beginning-of-the-end-for-the-energy-charter-treaty/  (accessed: 19.10.2021).
17. Fiorelli G. (2015). Italy withdraws from Energy Charter Treaty // Global Compliance News UG. May 6, 2015. URL: https://globalarbitrationnews.com/italy-withdraws-from-energy-charter-treaty-20150507/  (accessed: 19.10.2021).
18. Hamama O. (2021). Definition of an “Energy Dispute” according to the Energy Charter Treaty // Arbitration.ru. FEBRUARY 8, 2021. URL: https://journal.arbitration.ru/analytics/definition-of-an-energy-dispute-according-to-the-energy-charter-treaty/  (accessed: 19.10.2021).
19. Keating D. (2019). EU Governments Under Pressure to Quit Energy Charter Treaty// Forbes. 10 December 2019. URL: https://www.forbes.com/sites/davekeating/2019/12/10/eu-governments-under-pressure-to-quit-  energy-charter-treaty/#75c5871163ed (accessed: 19.10.2021).
20. Noilhac A. (2020). Renewable energy investment cases against Spain and the quest for regulatory consistency // Editoriale Scientifica. Jun 14, 2020. URL: http://www.qil-qdi.org/renewable-energy-investment-cases-against-spain-and-the-quest-for-regulatory-consistency/  (accessed: 19.10.2021).
21. Timofeyev I. et al (2020). Investment Disputes Involving the Renewable Energy Industry under the Energy Charter Treaty // GAR. 10 November 2020. URL: https://globalarbitrationreview.com/guide/the-guide-energy-arbitrations/4th-edition/article/investment-disputes-involving-the-renewable-energy-industry-under-the-energy-charter-treaty  (accessed: 19.10.2021).

Система Orphus

Loading...
Up