Russia - EU: "Soft-powe risks" in the Eurasian-Arctic context

Publication type Article
Status Published
Occupation: кандидат экономических наук
Affiliation: Candidate of Economics, Leading Researcher, Section of Systemic Problems of International Relations, Primakov National Research Institute of World Economy and International Relations, Russian Academy of Sciences (IMEMO)
Address: Profsoyuznaya 23, Moscow, Russian Federation
Journal nameMirovaia ekonomika i mezhdunarodnye otnosheniia
EditionVolume 62 Issue 9

Russia–EU relations are regarded within a framework of the ongoing author’s “Trans-Arctic study”, which allows to consider new formats of global interaction in the Arctic macro-region, often referred to as conflict-free. Behind the “conflict-free Arctic”, the hybrid policy of “Smart & Intelligent Power” hides, which is fraught with the erosion of identity in the Arctic zone of the Russian Federation (AZ RF). Soft-power risks, which are brought to the AZ RF due to transformation of the Russia–EU interaction paradigm, are its part. The modernized “Northern Sea Route” and huge natural resources of the AZ RF are a colossal “capital” of Russia, which cause envy and generate the wish of foes to exercise economic, political, cultural and information control over this “capital”. The multiplier of these challenges is the growth of global significance of the “Eurasian-Arctic field” in the Trans-Arctic, where the “soft-, smart-, intelligent-, sharp-power” has become a popular instrument of foreign policy. An analysis of the EU’s ambitious integrated Arctic strategy and its model of interactions in the region suggests that in the near future, the European Union’s presence in the Trans-Arctic will remain limited. And “soft-power risks” generated here by the EU will be “broadcast” to Russia through the actors of the Trans-Artic multi-level management system, who are closely affiliated with Brussels. For a safe Russia–EU interaction in the “Eurasian-Arctic Field” of the Trans-Arctic or in the AZ RF it is necessary to elaborate a new model, which would take into account the risk of “soft-power and sharp-power” intervention – the one that will not allow to awaken the dormant conflict-generating force of the Trans-Arctic.

KeywordsEurasia, the EU, Russia, Trans-Arctic, security, geopolitics, space, securitization, power
Publication date03.10.2018
Number of characters380
Cite   Download pdf To download PDF you should sign in
Размещенный ниже текст является ознакомительной версией и может не соответствовать печатной

views: 1470

Readers community rating: votes 0

1. 1. Keohane R.O. International Institutions: Can Interdependence Work? Foreign Policy, 1998, issue 110, Spring, pp. 82-96. 2. Burd'yo P. Sotsiologiya sotsial'nogo prostranstva (Per. s frants.) Moskva, Institut ehksperimental'­noj sotsiologii. Sankt-Peterburg, izd-vo “Aleteya”, 2007. 288 s. [Bourdieu P. Sotsiologiya sotsial’nogo prostranstva [Sociology of Social Space]. (Transl. from French). Moscow, Institut eksperimental’noi sotsiologii. Sankt-Petersburg, Aleteiya, 2007. 288 p.] Available at: (accessed 08.02.2018). 3. Naj Dzh. Gibkaya sila. Kak dobit'sya uspekha v mirovoj politike. (Per. s angl.) Moskva, Trend, 2006. 397 s. [Nye J. Gibkaya sila. Kak dobit’sya uspekha v mirovoi politike [Soft Power: The Means to Success in World Politics]. (Transl. from English) Moscow, Trend, 2006. 397 p.] 4. Buzan B. New Patterns of Global Security in the Twenty-First Century. International Affairs, 1991, vol. 67, no. 3, pp. 431-451. 5. Naryshkin zayavil o vedenii SShA gibridnoj vojny protiv stran SNG. [Naryshkin Said about the United States Hybrid War against CIS Countries (In Russ.)] Available at: (accessed 14.03.2018). 6. The Global Risks Report – 2018. Available at: (accessed 09.02.2018). 7. Kostin zayavil o nachale “vojny” Zapada protiv Rossii. [Kostin Declared the Beginning of the “War” of the West against Russia (In Russ.)] Available at: (accessed 09.02.2018). 8. Labetskaya E.O. Transarktika: aspekty global'nogo upravleniya. Mezhsektsionnyj sbornik № 2 “Global'noe upravlenie”. Materialy VIII Konventa RAMI (aprel' 2014 g.): nauchnoe izdanie. Lebedeva M.M., Strezhneva M.V., Panova V.V., Nikitina A.I., red. Moskva, Izdatel'stvo “MGIMO–Universitet”, 2015, ss. 53-61. [Labetskaya E.O. Transarktika: aspekty global’nogo upravleniya [Trans-Arctic: Aspects of Global Governance]. Mezhsektsionnyi sbornik № 2 “Global’noe upravlenie”. Materialy VIII Konventa RAMI (aprel’ 2014 g.): nauchnoe izdanie [Intersectional Collection № 2 “Global Management”. Materials of the VIII Convention of RAMI (April 2014): Scientific Edition]. Lebedeva M.M., Strezhneva M.V., Panova V.V., Nikitin A.I., eds. Moscow, Izdatel’stvo “MGIMO–Universitet”, 2015, pp. 53-61.] 9. Zagorskij A.V. Nestrategicheskie voprosy bezopasnosti i sotrudnichestva v Arktike. Moskva, IMEhMO RAN, 2016. 104 s. [Zagorskii A.V. Nestrategicheskie voprosy bezopasnosti i sotrudnichestva v Arktike [Nonstrategic Issues of Security and Cooperation in the Arctic]. Moscow, IMEMO, 2016. 104 p.] DOI:10.20542/978-5-9535-0492-8 10. Lomonosov M.V. Kratkoe opisanie raznykh puteshestvij po severnym moryam i pokazanie vozmozhnogo prokhodu Sibirskim okeanom v vostochnuyu Indiyu. [Lomonosov M.V. Kratkoe opisanie raznykh puteshestvii po severnym moryam i pokazanie vozmozhnogo prokhodu Sibirskim okeanom v vostochnuyu Indiyu [Brief Description of Different Trips to Northern Seas, and Indication of a Possible Passage by Siberian Ocean to Eastern India]] Available at: (accessed 14.03.2018) 11. Il'in I.A. O Rossii. Tri rechi. [Il’in I.A. O Rossii. Tri rechi [About Russia. Three Speeches]] Available at: (accessed 10.02.2018). 12. Labetskaya E.O. Transarkticheskij kontekst strategicheskikh prioritetov RF. Puti k miru i bezopas­nosti, 2014, № 2(47), ss. 81-88. [Labetskaya E.O. Transarkticheskii kontekst strategicheskikh prioritetov RF [The Trans-Arctic Context of Russia’s Strategic Priorities]. Puti k miru i bezopasnosti, 2014, no. 2(47), pp. 81-88.] Available at: (accessed 14.03.2018). 13. Joint Communication to the European Parliament and the Council. An Integrated European Union Policy for the Arctic. Available at: (accessed 08.02.2018). 14. Zasedanie Soveta Bezopasnosti po voprosu realizatsii gosudarstvennoj politiki v Arktike. [Meeting of the Security Council on the Implementation of Public Policy in the Arctic (In Russ.)] Available at: (accessed 14.03.2018). 15. Ehrenzeller B., Hrbek R., Malinverni G., Thurer D. Federalism and Foreign Policy. Politorbis, 2003, no. 1(32), pp. 18-38. 16. V MID RF zayavili, chto Arktika dolzhna ostavat'sya regionom mira i stabil'nosti. [The Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Russian Federation Stated that the Arctic Should Remain a Region of Peace and Stability (In Russ.)] Available at: (accessed 14.03.2018). 17. Nevskaya A. US Sanctions on Russian Energy Sector: First Results and Side Effects. Available at: (accessed 29.01.2018). 18. SBER neobkhodimo “idti v nogu so vremenem” – Lavrov. [The BEAR Needs to “Keep up with the Times” – Lavrov (In Russ.)] Available at: (accessed 09.02.2018). 19. V Nar'yan-Mare otkrylas' konferentsiya parlamentariev Barentseva regiona. [The Conference of the Barents Region Parliamentarians Was Opened in Naryan-Mar (In Russ.)] Available at: (accessed 09.02.2018). 20. Kharitonova E.M. “Myagkaya sila” vo vneshnej politike gosudarstva: opyt Velikobritanii (vtoraya polovina 1990-kh – 2010-e gg.). Diss. kand. pol. nauk. Moskva, IMEhMO RAN, 2017. [Kharitonova E.M. “Myagkaya sila” vo vneshnei politike gosudarstva: opyt Velikobritanii (vtoraya polovina 1990-kh – 2010-e gg.). Diss. kand. pol. nauk [“Soft power” in the Foreign Policy of the State: the Experience of Great Britain (the Second Half of the 1990s – 2010s). PhD. Diss. (pol.)]. Moscow, IMEMO, 2017.] Available at: (accessed 14.03.2018). 21. Surguladze V.Sh. Skrytye metody bor'by za identichnost'. “Tverdaya”, “myagkaya”, “umnaya” – buduschee vlasti v trekh litsakh sily. Problemy natsional'noj strategii, 2015, № 4(31), ss. 233-240. [Surguladze V.Sh. Skrytye metody bor’by za identichnost’. “Tverdaya”, “myagkaya”, “umnaya” – budushchee vlasti v trekh litsakh sily [Hidden Methods of the Fight for Identity. “Hard-”, “Soft-” and “Smart-Power” – the Future of Power in Three Power Forms]. Problemy natsional’noi strategii, 2015, no. 4(31), pp. 233-240.] 22. Nye J.S. Jr. How Sharp Power Threatens Soft Power. The Right and Wrong Ways to Respond to Authoritarian Influence. Available at: (accessed 31.01.2018). 23. Semenenko I.S. “Novyj” natsionalizm i ehtnopoliticheskaya konfliktnost': diskursy i praktiki politiki identichnosti (tezisy doklada). [Semenenko I.S. “Novyi” natsionalizm i etnopoliticheskaya konfliktnost’: diskursy i praktiki politiki identichnosti (tezisy doklada) [“New” Nationalism and Ethnopolitical Conflict: Discourses and Practices of the Identity Policy (Theses of the Report)]] Available at: (accessed 05.02.2018). 24. Norvezhskaya myagkaya sila v bor'be za Arktiku: kak “barentsy” menyayut v svoyu pol'zu buduschee. [Norwegian Soft Power in the Struggle for the Arctic: How the “Barents” Change the Future in Their Favor (In Russ.)] Available at: (accessed 16.02.2018). 25. Zhuravlev A. Ne proigrat' bitvu za Arktiku. [Zhuravlev A. Ne proigrat’ bitvu za Arktiku [Not to Lose the Battle for the Arctic]] Available at: (accessed 14.03.2018). 26. Ivanov I.S. RF i Evropa: ot romantiki k pragmatike. [Ivanov I.S. RF i Evropa: ot romantiki k pragmatike [Russia and Europe: from Romance to Pragmatics]] Available at: (accessed 02.02.2018).

Система Orphus