All
 
|
 
 


Was there an “August Mistake”? How to assess the role of the Communist Party of Cuba and the Comintern in the anti-Machado revolution of 1933
 
PIIS0044748X0026848-1-1
DOI10.31857/S0044748X0026848-1
Publication type Article
Status Published
Authors
Victor Jeifets 
Affiliation: Saint Petersburg State University
Address: Russian Federation, Saint Petersburg
Lazar Jeifets
Affiliation:
Saint Petersburg State University
Saint-Petersburg University of Aerospace University
Address: Russian Federation, Saint Petersburg
Journal nameLatin America
EditionIssue 8
Pages45-66
Abstract

The article examines the little–studied nature of relations between the III International, its Caribbean Bureau and the Communist Party of Cuba in connection with the so-called "August mistake" - the attitude taken by the Cuban section of the Comintern during the anti-Machado revolution of 1933. The role of the informal leader of the party Ruben Martinez Villena is analyzed and the evolution of assessments of his activities during this period by the international Communist Party is shown. While originally as the Comintern emissaries as also the structures of the Executive Committee of the Comintern condemned sharply Martinez Villena’s activities during the overthrow of the dictatorship of G.Machado, finally this attitude was shifting and Moscow was ready to come to terms with him on condition of admitting a “mistake”. Later, as the authors showed, Moscow partially (but not publicly) came to conclusion that it was wrong to bet on the seizure of power in Cuba by the forces of exclusively communists and their affiliated structures. This recognition was part of the Comintern's “historic turn” to the policy of the Popular Front, which in Cuba meant the transition of the Communist Party to a broad alliance. This alliance laid the foundations for the subsequent expansion of communist influence.

Keywords“The August Mistake”, Cuban Revolution of 1933, the Communist Party, PCC Comintern
AcknowledgmentThe research was carried out thanks to financial support of the Russian Scientific Fund, grant № 19-18-00305, “The Comintern in Latin America: historical traditions and political processes”.
Received27.04.2023
Publication date24.08.2023
Number of characters56571
Cite  
100 rub.
When subscribing to an article or issue, the user can download PDF, evaluate the publication or contact the author. Need to register.

Number of purchasers: 0, views: 182

Readers community rating: votes 0 

1. Sinani G. Konets kapitalisticheskoj stabilizatsii, revolyutsionnyj pod'em, sostoyanie i zadachi kompartij YuKA. Problemy Yuzhnoj i Karaibskoj Ameriki. Sbornik statej pod obschej redaktsiej G. Sinani. M., Institut mirovogo khozyajstva i mirovoj politiki pri Komakademii, 1934, ss. 249-310.
2. Lamrani S. Los orígenes de la Revolución Cubana de 1959. Hors-Dossier. Anthropologie de l’expérience de l’accouchement dans le monde. Decembre 2021, N 50. Available at:  https://journals.openedition.org/etudescaribeennes/23080  (accessed 12.12.2022).
3. Tabares del Real J.A. La revolución del 30: sus dos últimos años. La Habana, Editorial de Ciencias Sociales, 1971, 324 p.
4. Rodríguez R. La revolución que no se fue a bolina. La Habana, Editorial de Ciencias Sociales, 2013, 733 p.
5. Rosell M. Luchas obreras contra Machado. La Habana, Editorial Ciencias Sociales, 1973, 396 p.
6. Soto L. La revolución del 33. La Habana, Editorial de Ciencias Sociales, 1977, t.II, 435 p.
7. Aguilar L.E. Cuba 1933: Prologue to Revolution. Ithaca, Cornell University Press, 1972, 256 p.
8. Carrillo J. Cuba 1933: estudiantes, yanquis y soldados. Coral Gables, Miami, University of Miami, 1985. 422 p.
9. Farber S. Revolution and Reaction in Cuba, 1933-1960. A Political Sociology from Machado to Castro. Middletown, Wesleyan University Press, 1976, 283 p.
10. Gelman I. Roosevelt and Batista: Good Neighbor Diplomacy in Cuba, 1933-1945. Albuquerque, University of New Mexico Press, 1973, 303 p.
11. Carr B. From Caribbean Backwater to Revolutionary Opportunity: Cuba’s Evolving Relationship with the Comintern, 1925-34. T.Reese & A.Thorpe. International Communism and the Communist International, 1919-43. Manchester, Manchester University Press, 1998, pp.234-253.
12. Jeifets V., Jeifets L. La Odisea Roja. Varias líneas Al Retrato político De Jorge Vivó d’Escoto. Revista CS, Cali, 2014, N14 (diciembre), pp.167-200.
13. Roa R. Evocacion de Ruben Martinez Villena. Cuba Socialista. La Habana, Marzo de 1965, N 43, pr.58-59.
14. Blaquier Rojas A. Primer Partido Comunista de Cuba. 1925-1935. Editorial Oriente. Santiago de Cuba, 2005, t.I, 280 p.
15. Massón Sena C. Comintern y comunismo en Cuba. Una reflexión crítica. Izquierdas. Santiago de Chile, 2010 Año 3, N7.
16. Rosales García J. Martínez Villena: actualidad de su ideario politico. C.Massón (dir.). Las Izquierdas Latinoamericanas: Multiplicidad y Experiencias durante el Siglo XX. Santiago, Ariadna Ediciones, 2017, rr.377-389.
17. Ruben Martines Vijena. Kommunisticheskij Internatsional. M., 1934. №3 (20 yanvarya), s.63. [Ruben Martines Viyena [Ruben Martinez Villena]. Kommunisticheskii Internatsional. Moscow, 1934, N3. January 20, r.63. (In Russ).
18. Daily Worker. New York, 26.07.1933.
19. L’Humanité. Paris, 14.08.1933.
20. L’Humanité. Paris, 15.08.1933.
21. Gomets. Revolyutsionnye sobytiya na Kube i zadachi kompartii. Kommunisticheskij Internatsional. M., 1933, №25, ss.42-48.
22. Sinani. Novaya faza revolyutsionnykh sobytij na Kube. Kommunisticheskij Internatsional, M., 1933, №28, s.17.
23. Sinani G. Revolyutsionnye sobytiya na Kube. Mirovoe khozyajstvo i mirovaya politika. M., 1933. №10, ss.60-75. [Sinani G. Revolutsionnye sobytiya na Kube. [The Revolutionary Events in Cuba]. Mirovoye khoziaistvo i mirovaya politika. Moscow, 1933, N 10, rr.60-75. (In Russ).
24. G.S. [G. Sinani]. Na Kube voznikayut Sovety. Kolonial'nye problemy. Chast' 2. M., Komakademiya, 1934.
25. The Draft of a Resolution on the CP of Cuba, 1933. Russian State Archive for Social and Political History (RGASPI). F. 495, op. 105, folder. 65, rr. 3-4.
26. Jeifets V., Jeifets L. El encuentro de la izquierda cubana con la Revolución Rusa: el Partido Comunista y la Comintern. Historia Crítica. Bogotá, 2017, N64, pp.81-100.
27. Hatzky Ch. Julio Antonio Mella (1903-1929). Eine Biografie. Frankfurt am Mein, Vervuert, 2004, 472s.
28. Khejfets V.L., Khejfets L.S. Latinskaya Amerika v orbite mirovoj revolyutsii. M., Politicheskaya ehntsiklopediya, 2020, 759 s.
29. Kommunisticheskij Internatsional pered VII vsemirnym kongressom. (Materialy). M., Partizdat TsK VKP(b), 1935.
30. Schelchkov A.A. Trotskistskoe dvizhenie na Kube. Latinoamerikanskij istoricheskij al'manakh. M., 2017, №18, ss. 155-177.
31. De la Osa E. Cronica del ano 33. La Habana, Editorial de ciencias sociales, 1989, 157 r.
32. Junta del CC, a 11 de octubre de 1933. RGASPI. F. 495, op.105, folder 71, rr.27-39.
33. Johny’s Report on Cuba. September 4th 1933. RGASPI. F. 495, op. 105, folder 68, rr.1-3.
34. Roca B. Así conocí a Ruben Martínez Villena. Hoy. 20.01.1965.
35. Roka B. Osnovy sotsializma na Kube. M., Gospolitizdat, 1961, 243 s.
36. Nitoburg Eh.L. Pokhischenie zhemchuzhiny. Poltora veka ehkspansionistskoj politiki SShA na Kube. M., Nauka, 1968.
37. Nitoburg Eh.L. Politika amerikanskogo imperializma na Kube. M., Nauka, 1965.
38. Farrar V.J. and Beers H.P. (eds.). Foreign Relations of the United States. Diplomatic Papers, 1933. The American Republics. Washington, United States Government Printing Office, 1952, vol.5, rr. 347-348.
39. Junta del CC. Agosto 29 de 1933. RGASPI. F.495, op. 105, folder 71, rr.19a-21.
40. Carta del CC del PCC (Sampedro) al CEIC. RGASPI. F.495, op. 105, folder 75, r.43.
41. CC del PCC al SLA de la I.C. Habana, a 27 de junio de 1933. RGASPI. F. 495, op. 105, folder 75, r.24.
42. Zapis' besedy s predstavitelyami Narodno-sotsialisticheskoj partii Kuby t.t. Roka i Ehskalante 6 oktyabrya 1956 goda. Rossijskij gosudarstvennyj arkhiv novejshej istorii. Fond 5, op. 8, d.440, ll.51-52.
43. The discussion of “the Error of August” at the Latin American Lender-Secretariat of the ECCI. RGASPI. F.495, op.79, folder 196, rr.22-62.
44. The continuation of Com. Juan’s Report at the South American Lender-Secretariat, 17.VI.1934. RGASPI. F. 495. op.79, folder 196, rr.63-79.
45. Buehno. Kak rabochie i krest'yane mogut vzyat' i uderzhat' vlast' na Kube. Kommunisticheskij Internatsional. 1935 (20 marta), №9, ss.47-52.
46. The report, 15.VII.1935. RGASPI. F.495, op.105, folder 119, rr.1-2.
47. The Letter of the Cuban CP delegation at the VII Congress of the Comintern to the CC of the Cuban CP. 26.Kh.1935. RGASPI. F.495, op.105, folder 120, rr.8-12.

Система Orphus

Loading...
Up